Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Nut Conference Special

Socialist Organiser no. 393, 15 March 1989 · scan p. 16 · Liam Conway · about 655 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 16 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 16

Anti-deportation fighter Anwar Ditta and her children and guilt politics, no!

f it's anti-racism, it must be right; if the union's Black Caucus says it, it must be trueThese have been guiding mottos for some on the lett in recent years, but they have led to some pretty dubious political responses. It's worth looking at a few cases.

Take last year's Burnage Report. It was clear from the report that "top down" management-induced anti-racısm is ineffective and damaging, and actually leads to increased racial tension.

Socialist Organiser supporters yes proposed a conference resolution through the Socialist Teachers' Alliance (STA), defending antiracism, but urging the union to learn the lessons of Burnage. It was opposed by some socialist teachers on the grounds that learning lessons meant saying something negative about anti-racism. Fortunately the resolution remained largely unaltered, although the link between anti-racism and the need for an expanding education service was left unstated.

However, contacts inside the Campaign for a Democratic and Fighting Union (CDFU) now say that Hackney NUT are proposing an amendment to the resolution removing any reference to learning lessons" from Burnage. Why? Because lan MacDonald, a parent at Highbury Quadrant School and chair of the Burnage Inquiry, is apparently involved in the witch-hunt of those teachers at Highbury Quadrant School who were suspended by the Inner London Education Authority supposedly because of their anti-racist teaching practices.

MacDonald may (or may not) be a witch-hunter, but this does not mean that the Burnage Report, for which he was only co-author, has nothing valuable to teach us about the dangers of undemocratic antiracism implemented on a shoestring budget. It is important that the STA left opposes any such moves by any right-wing racist backlash and support the right of Muslims to march in opposition to Rushdie's book. The Rushdie affair is a timely reminder to socialists that tail-ending Black Section MPs like Bernie Grant is no substitute for independent socialist analysis.

The McGoldrick case of 1986/7 illustrates this last point quite effectively. When Brent Council suspended McGoldrick, much of the left gave them unquestioning support on the grounds that the suspension was part of an 'enlightened' anti-racist strategy. Indeed, many felt that Brent Council represented a genuine challenge to the government, despite the fact that it had never confronted the government over rate-capping.

According to Richard Hatcher When comm Matt Cooper al Union of Teachers include many on international solidarity work which mix useful solidarity and awareness with left wisdoms' which are not so left and not so wise.

The resolution on South Africa is. right to call for links with trade unions and raise the issue of prisoners and detainees. But it also has a one-sided emphasis on the ANC and SWAPO as the liberation movement.

There are other sections of the liberation movement - like the black consciousness movement, independent trade unionists and socialist groups - and it is about time the left recognised this.

The motion on the Palestine/Israel conflict is correct to call for links with Palestinian teachers in the occupied territories, but its demand that "any further links with the Israeli Teachers Union are made dependent upon their public support for the rights of Palestinians" is out of order. Would we oppose links with French trade unions not taking a firm stand on New Caledonia, or an American union that did not renounce the Contras strongly enough?

No. Indeed, we are all members of the British labour movement which has consistently failed to take. the question of Northern Ireland seriously. We should maintain links The motion has a subtext, the left wisdom that states "no Israeli Jew is worth talking to unless they renounce the right of the Israeli state to exist." Socialist Organiser opposes this idea and calls for both

----- pull-quotes -----

Anti-racism gu

wisdoms not wise

he motions for this year's conference of the Nation-

and attempt to contact progressive Israeli teachers in the union.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 393

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →