Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

NUT CONFERENCE SPECIAL Join the Socialist Alliance and fight!

Socialist Organiser no. 393, 15 March 1989 · scan p. 14 · Andy Dixon · about 1,096 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

The union leaders carry in their own sweet way — what can we do about it?" *There are so many issues the membership are angry about — LMS, loss of negotiating rights, the Baker legislation - why don't the union leaders mount some effective action?"

Comments like this are very common, and members soon realise that you cannot do much unless an organised opposition is mounted against McAvoy and Co. You cannot do much as a single association, let alone as a single member.

What sort of an organised opposition would Socialist Organiser like to see in the National Union of We need an organisation which raises the demands of associations around the country to turn the union into a responsive, democratic body.

As far as possible it needs to be a political organisation. We argue for our politics. But the aim is not simply to find an arena for political preaching. Paramount is the organisation of rank and file members into a self-aware, fighting body.

From the late '60s to the mid*70s, Rank and File Teacher was such a body. Since then the Socialist Teachers' Alliance has been the main rank-and-file group.

Rank and File Teacher was started by some members in IS (forerunner of the SWP) and others, It attempted to appeal to the broad base of membership. It had a rather philistine attitude towards 'politics' which did not have a direct relevance to teachers or the NUT - it was always a problem promoting resolutions on Ireland, for instance. It also had some strange ideas about head teachers being employers. But basically it was a healthy organisation until the SWP closed its doors to non-SWP members.

The Socialist Teachers Alliance grew out of that tradition. It was motivated by members of the IMG (forerunner of Socialist Action and Socialist Outlook) and others. It is not as compact an organisation as Rank and File Teacher, but it has had a measure of success.

In the late '70s two STA members - Bernie Regan and Ken Jones -were elected onto the Executive. Others have been elected since. Over recent years the organisation has grown considerably and has had a growing influence on parts of the country outside London.

Two years ago another rank and file body was set up by disgruntled STA members and others counterposed to the STA, called the Campaign for a Democratic and Fighting Union. This body has a rather different character and as yet is small.

Socialist Organiser supporters are members of the Socialist Teachers Alliance and are actively building it in various areas. We are in the STA because it is the largest established opposition to the union leadership and has a sufficiently open structure for a whole range of views to be debated. It still tends to be rather London-based, with a rather vague national structure, but it has proved over the past tew years.

However, we are critical of several aspects of it. One aspect can be illustrated by the fact that this year's main meeting at NUT conference is going to be on Ireland — hardly the issue on most members? minds at the moment.

A more appropriate issue would be 'How do we make the union fight?' It is almost as if the sympathetic NU1 membership are being told: "listen to this, it will be good for you!"

There is a tendency at meetings like this to have large platforms with as many as eight speakers. One year the STA had so many speakers one of them actually fell off the platform! The problem with having so many speakers is that it cuts down on the involvement of contributions from the floor and can alienate people coming along for the first time.

Last year in a one and a half hour meeting there was just one quarter of an hour left at the end for contributions. All this symbolises a rather elitist approach to the ordinary NUT member.

We believe it is important to start from where people are - whilst at the same time not shirking from facing up to the more "difficult" issues when appropriate. We need a mass membership with a strong national infrastructure consisting of a whole range ot opinion in opposition to the union bureaucrats.

That is the only way to ensure a defeat for the likes of Thatcher and Baker and the only way to ensure a healthy, fighting, democratic union.

Join the STA and fight! Andy Dixon reports The first few Executive meetings were fairly quiet. There were ritual skirmishes over elections for Committee Chairs and various outside bodies. (Ladbrokes and Hills were not taking bets on the number of defeated candidates receiving eleven votes).

Those of us who were new spent the first few months trying to understand the archaic and often bizarre procedures used to conduct Executive business.

Until the summer President Horne managed to keep his cool remarkably well. Things began to warm up over the appointment of Dough McAvoy as General Secretary designate, with allegations of illegality and a walkout by Howard Roberts and lan Murch. Since then there seem to have been challenges to the President's ruling almost every meeting.

Un one occasion Malcolm Horne and Barrie Frost had a confrontation over Barrie's refusal to hand back a document outlining the proposed union budget for the year. This followed Mark Slater and Betty Hunter being thrown out of the meeting because they had not signed a declaration of confidentiality (actually Mark had signed, but he had taken the outrageous liberty of qualifying his declaration by saying that he reserved the right to report to members, ie. the people who had elected him, on important issues).

Debate and discussion in the Executive is usually crowded out by Malcolm Horne's interpretation of the Standing Orders, motions that the question be put after the minimum number of speakers (three), and most importantly the shortage of time.

All business is channelled through committee, and often takes six weeks or longer after the committee meetings to reach the full Executive. The Executive meetings are never long enough and therefore the left has to be selective about which issues to challenge from the committee reports.

On two occasions we have resorted to requisitioning special Executive meetings (which we are able to do with 12 signatures): once to discuss the implementation of the Harrogate Conference decisions (not very successful!) and once to discuss the IAC report on pay and conditions and the union's response.

The second of those meetings was called after a normal Executive

----- pull-quotes -----

NAS/UWIT ILTA

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 393

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →