Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

SATANIC VERSES' Who holds a mandate from God?

Socialist Organiser no. 393, 15 March 1989 · scan p. 7 · about 1,426 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

cessful economic reforms will luce the size of the workforce. cording to Kostakov, there could a shake-out of up to 15 million rkers by the mid-1990s. To date, wever, this view has not been lely argued in public, and has in strongly challenged where it been. "Glasnost" and "perestroika" re widened the parameters of cussion about women's issues, swing previously taboo topics to aired in public.

Sut the debate largely continues rest upon extremely conservative umptions about the "natural tiny" of women or the merits of nuclear family. Proposed nomic reforms regard women's Its as secondary to women's gations to raise the quality and ntity of industrial output. There • genuine autonomous women's ement in the Soviet Union, and ign of one emerging. loreover, although greater ussion than in the past has been mitted since Gorbachev came to many aspects of the omic reforms now being imented have created additional lems for women.

ilation has led to a greater scarof basic consumer goods in the 5, as a result of panic-buying hoarding, meaning even longer es for commodities still in The crackdown on the sale of pi has led to sugar rationing as sugar supplies are snapped up for home-brew. And family incomes have fallen - on occasion by as much as 50% as a result of the crackdown on low-quality production and the consequent loss of bonus payments.

The inability of the Stalinist elite to solve the women's problem is a reflection of a far more fundamental dilemma. Commenting on the failure of the Soviet government to achieve the liberation of women, Trotsky wrote:

*The real means at the disposal of the state did not correspond to the plans and intentions of the Communist Party. The family cannot be abolished, it must be replaced. A real liberation of the woman cannot be achieved on the basis of generalised distress."

The Soviet elite lacks both the desire to 'abolish' the nuclear family and also the ability to provide the material basis to allow for it to be 'substituted'. Gorbachev's reforms show no sign of succeeding in overcoming the 'generalised distress? which underpins Soviet society.

And, in any case, even if Gorbachev were able to see through his planned economic reforms, this would not lead to genuine equality between the sexes in the Soviet Union. -Market mechanisms have not liberated women in the West. There is no reason to believe that they would do so in the Soviet Union.

Geoff Ward look the foundations religious bigotry Ayatollah Khomeini's mafia-style contract on Salman Rushdie for his 'blasphemous' novel, "The Satanic Verses' shows that religious bigotry and intolerance still hold powerful sway in the world. And bigotry is not peculiar to Islam.

The last recorded burning of a heretic in England occurred as late as 1612, and not until 1677 did religious crimes cease to be punishable by death.

It is still possible to be prosecuted for blasphemy, as Gay News discovered in 1978. By recognising the 'crime' of blasphemy, the law officially presupposes the existence of god. If god did not exist it would be impossible to offend it.

In the earliest of civilisations, the first gods were imaginary people who were supposed to control natural forces — the god of thunder or the god of the harvest.

-The greater were ignorance and fear of natural events, the more gods were created to 'explain' these things. For communities on the edge of subsistence, success or failure of a harvest was a question of life or death - and of mystery.

Rituals and sacrifices were invented to appease the gods.

If the crops grew, then that proved the power of the gods. If they failed, then the fault must lie with the community.

As society developed to a level where a surplus of basic necessities was produced an elite evolved -taking control of the surplus by coercion. Among other things, they utilised the idea of gods or god to legitimise their rule.

The Egyptian Pharaohs commanded whole slave armies to build their pyramids. They invented some early religious dogmas like belief in an afterlife, where people would get rewards.

Philosophy began as a criticism of religious beliefs. The religious countered with theology - the "science' of divinity. Dissenters were ruthlessly persecuted, as were people with competing religious beliefs.

The collapse of the Roman Empire saw the rise of two of the major dominant regions today - Christianity and, later, Islam.

Muslims share with Christians three basic beliefs: one god rather than many; the role of prophets as voices god; and resurrection. Other ideas shared by Christianity and Islam include god's omniscience and omnipotence; divine Favela and the Day of Jod thron. revelation; knowing through The Christian Bible and the Muslim Koran do, however, differ. In general, people's ideas of god differ according to their level of social and economic development, their culture, and their material circumstances - in a way that makes nonsense of the notion that religion is the word of god, rather than a reflex product of human ignorance and misery.

In the earliest societies almost everything that happened - from a rainstorm to a sudden death supposed to be a deliberate act by a god. As science has progressed, religion has become more cautious, yet it remains fundamentally an alternative to reason and science. The theologian Martin Luther described reason as "God's worst enemy"

The fantastic accounts of miracles defy laws of nature. The Bible gives a description of creation which is contradicted by science.

What is the evidence for the existence of a god?

In the modern religions god is unknowable in any direct sense, possessing transcendental qualities which take god out of the range of human experience and which, indeed, contradict human understanding altogether. God is exempt from natural laws — thus falling outside the domain of scientific explanation — and it is impossible to ascribe positive qualities to god. God is simply "He who is"

Christian theologians have attempted to give god attributes like omnipotent, immutable, incom- prehensible, infinite, omniscient, ieattributes which are designed not to limit god in any way. Most of these traits however define god negatively: "immutable" means god does not change. God therefore is the exact reverse of how we perceive reality, and as such is incomprehensible. the realmoe the dispushed the The further more believers rest their case on faith — belief without rational proof. The conflict between atheism and religion is fundamentally a conflict between reason and faith.

Throughout history, Christianity has sought to eliminate scientific principles that conflict with Christian faith, as in the persecution of Galileo for upholding the view that the earth wasn't the centre of the universe. It is impossible to gain knowledge of god through Christian faith as it is held beyond reason and, if necessary, against reason. Without a coherent and consistent description of this metaphysical being, faith, apart from being justified, is also unintelligible.

In feudal Europe the Catholic Chruch had a monopoly of intellectuals and ruled with the nobility, exploiting the peasantry.

The alliance of Church and State began to break down in the 16th and 17th centuries with the rise of capitalism and the Church split in the process. Criticism surfaced within the Church as Biblical authority was undermined. By attacking superstitious religious dogmas the Enlightenment helped the bourgeoisie to wrest power from the feudal monarchy.

In the wake of theories like Darwin's Theory of Evolution the Bible went through a period of reinterpretation' and 'revision' and found to be compatible all along with these changes.

Today "Creationists' and 'Islamic Fundamentalists' still don't recognise the validity of Darwin's theory. And Islam's Koran did not go through the same sustained criticism as the Bible and is more often defended as literally true.

Religion has survived under capitalism because it serves the new capitalist class and provides an outlet for the bewildered and miserable - "the heart of a heartless world" : as Marx put it. "The meek shall inherit the earth," said oil magnate Paul Getty, "but I'll still own the mineral rights." Despite the rhetoric of the mullahs, there is nothing clearly anticapitalist in the Koran.

Religion thrives upon ignorance and fear of the unknown. Leon Trotsky wrote that heaven is the only fortified prison for military operations against the philosophy of Marxism. On the one side, faith in unknowable first causes, and hope for reward in the afterlife for submission in this world; on the other, the search for knowledge of real causes and effects, and the fight to win. a better life in this world.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 393

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →