[LIVING AN DIRT FAI ahe National Union mass…]
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-03-15Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
LIVING AN DIRT FAI ahe National Union mass opposition to loans has allowed other people's arguments to dominate public discussion of student financial support. Reported arguments against loans are more often those of the banks, protesting at lack of profit in the loans scheme - rather the voices of students demanding a decent grant for all.
The Committee of Vice-Chancellors and Principals (CVCP) have come out in favour of a "graduate tax' - a form of loans inst order ther than going into debt In order to study, they think students should pay extra tax after graduation. This iS loans administered through the Inland Revenue rather than the banks. SDP students have pushed the same idea within NUS. Now former Labour Higher Education spokesperson Giles Radice MP has started arguing for a graduate tax. It is a possibility that this will be adopted as Labour Party policy. Where do NOLS stand?
Radice's argument turns on the expense that would be involved in a decent level of grant in an expanded education system. "The cost" he argues "would be prohibitive". "IF higher education is to be expanded and student support reformed and extended, additional sources of finance must be found".
The sources of finance he favours? "The direct beneficiaries of higher education should make a financial contribution". He also favours employer contributions through higher National Insurance contributions for employees who are graduates.
Of course companies should be made to pay up to fund a decent education system! Of course the rich should be taxed to pay for our grants! But should a nurse with a degree (or who's failed one) pay more tax than one without? Should our National Insurance contributions be higher if we've been to college?
Radice has accepted the Tory logic unal students should have to pay for their own education. But it's not just Radice, but NOLS have got some explaining to do • on three counts:
• Giles Radice's proposal looks like a possibility become Labour Party policy. What are NOLS saying about that? What will they say if it does? They have sold us OLL over the poll tax (opposing non-implementation, not because they don't think it's necessary but because they don't want NUS to take a position in conflict with their friends on Labour Coucils who are implementing the tax). These people put their careers before the needs of NUS campaigning. Will they sell us out on graduate tax?
Why have they allowed the banks and the CVP to dominate opposition to loans, doing more to seek alliances with back-bench Tories, than to mobilise students? Their strategy is to blame if graduate tax becomes Labour's - or anyone else's - alternative.
• Can't they see that such an outcome IS the logic of their, and their 'communist' friends, strategy of 'popular frontism'. Building campaign against loans not on the basis of student anger, but of seeking common front with 'influential' people who might oppose the present loans proposal - banks, soft Tories, and so on - - means gaining a common front on the terms of those other forces, letting their arguments dominate.
For NUS, passivity and 'popular frontism' will mean loans going through nothing better than modification to satisfy the banks. It's the banks that are using us to get what they want, not the other way round!
Socialist student wants a fight for grants not loans, full grants for all in post-16 education! Build loans campaign based on student action and linked to the labour movement and community. You can't fight loans with chats over dinner with bankers and Tory MPs.