An open letter to left activists
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-03-15Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Already well over 100 student activists have joined a call for left unity and for a conference to build it. Below we print an open letter to the left from Socialist Students in explaining this call.
This open letter is addressed to people who consider themselves to be part of the serious activist left in NUS. We want to talk to you about the job that faces us.
The Tories have been in power for nearly 10 years. We have had ten years of their education policy. They have cut education, closed courses and they are now increasing the pressure to keep poorer people out of post-16 education. In the future we have the Poll Tax, loans and 'voluntary membership' waiting for us.
The left in NUS faces two major problems: it is fragmented into competing factions; and that section of the left which leads the NUS has failed to provide the student movement with decent leadership. It has failed to campaign properly. It has failed to link up with the labour movement and with community organisations facing cuts and attacks.
Labour Students (NOLS) - led by the Democratic Left - has been frightened of campaigning, frightened of mass mobilisations and frightened of forming alliances with workers. They have been passive and they themselves now admit it. NOLS has been used again and again by shameless "me-first" careerists, who see political activity in NUS and NOLS as a way to get a better job after they leave student Now the Democratic Left has fractured because of the pressure of the Tories, because of the dry rot of careerism in sections of the leadership, and because of their inability to lead successful struggles.
The big question for supporters of the Democratic Left now is this: are they going to learn the lessons of their own failures? Or are they going to go on making the same mistakes?
Because the left in office has been a relative failure, a new right has developed within NUS. The pressing danger now is that these people will gain the leadership of NUS over the next year, or in the next two or three years. If that seems alarmist, look at the facts.
The Democrats, Tories and various "non-political' independents some of them probably closet Tories - have steadily gained ground in local unions and in the National Union. People like 'Cosmo' Hawkes, who began his NUS life as the perennial joke candidate, has been elected to positions in the National Union. At this NUS conference Hawkes and his supporters are pushing to gain the post of National Secretary. If they take the National Secretary post this year it will be a springboard for an attempt to take the Presidency next year when Maeve Sherlock retires.
The right could take control of the NUS this time next year, or the year after — if the left does not pull itself together. There are no grounds for complacency.
This statement originates with one of caucuses in NUSSSiN/Socialist Student.
Socialist Student believes that we nave a pretty good record in suggesting policy for NUS and student activists. We have had a lot of our ideas adopted by NUS Conferences. (Though unfortunately the NUS leaders didn't implement them).
However, SSiN has not got a monopoly on good ideas. Now that the Democratic Left has fragmented, we are the largest left caucus, but SsiN is only part of the left. We want to develop a policy for the serious left to win in NUS and NOLS. We want dialogue with others on the left.
If we are to stop the offensive of the right, stop them taking control of NUS, then the left needs to unite. Now!
But there are big differences inside the left? Of course there are. But even if, because of the sometimes important political differences which divide us, we can't unite in one single common caucus, then we must at least unite for particular objectives and find a framework for intra-lett dialogue. Too often today, important real political ditterences especially on international questions are used -and sometimes artificially emphasised - as mere factional badges and shibboleths. Dialogue is precluded. Today the NUS left exists in separate ghettoes, hurling abuse at each other over the walls. Instead of that, we need unity in action against the right, and honest dialogue about our differences.
The threat from the right inside NUS is only a -reflection of the Tory offensive against the whole NUS. The fightback against the Tories is the key task facing NUS.
Unless NUS's Labour leaders learn, and learn quickly, loans will be introduced, and NUS will be broken up by voluntary membership. We must look for allies. We must link up with the trade unions and the broader community.
This doesn't mean just at NUS HQ and TUC level. We mean at activist level too. We must support workers like the NHS workers and postal workers when they strike for better wages, etc.
Campaigns like the anti-loans campaign must not be solidly Higher Education oriented. We need policies to get all the different groups inside of NUS working together. We need to involve Further Education students too.
The NUS should adopt policies that enable a fight back to begin at the most basic level of all -campaigns against course cuts, nursery closures and for fuller access to higher education. NUS must be flexible and learn to thrive on the imagination and initiative of the college activists.
Around these ideas - roughly, and without insisting on every dot and comma - we believe it is possible to get left unity, left unity inside both the NUS and NOLS. We need to create a very broad organisation on the left which fight to turn NUS into the sort of campaigning union students need to beat the Tories. SSiN wants to discuss this with groups and individuals who broadly agree with us.
We believe that the turmoil in the Democratic Left opens up opportunities to regroup the left and regenerate and reorganise it. The threat from the right makes it imperative that this be done.
Right now we are organised in SSiN, a democratic caucus in NOLS. SSiN will continue to exist and to fight for the future of the NUS until something better is organised. We declare now, HOWEVER gives to the job of regrouping the left, that SSiN will be prepared to consider dissolving itself into a broader and more all-embracing fighting, effective left caucus, should that become a possibility. We are working to make it a possibility.
Right now the left is in flux. Seize the chance to recreate the NUS left - on a better basis!
Support, build and attend the Left Unity conference in Sheffield on 22 April.
Bring your ideas and your proposals to that conference and maybe we can forge a bigger, united NUS lett.