Both sides are equally bad in Afghanistan
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-03-15Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
AFGHANISTAN: USSR troops out!
Marxists and Afghanistan: the debate in detail. 50p plus 22p postage from PO Box 823, Londor SE 15 4NA.
dug adi ni T cities' (SO 391) is wrong he slogan Defend This slogan can only mean advocating a bloc with the Stalinist PDP to defend the . cities militarily against the Mujahedeen. This proposal comes after years of Socialist Organiser opposing the war carried out by the PDP and the Russian army against the people of Afghanistan: The call for "Russian troops out" was right because their VE COCHICC Was Ene presenal sea determicter obstacle to Some people on the left claimed that the Russian occupation did not mean national oppression because the troops were invited by and/or came to the aid of the PDP government. SO rightly rejected this line of argument, pointing to the fact that the PDP had feeble support outside the army.
The Russian occupation could claim no legitimacy from its "invite" from the Kabul government. The PDP regime was not the legitimate representative of the people of Afghanistan. The Russian invasion was an attempt at artificially propping up an unpopular regime. As a result of the lack of support for the PDP the conflict became a war against the people of Afghanistan and degenerated into naplaming.
Now the Russian troops have gone the PDP regime remains a government forced on the people of Afghanistan by the army. The regime never broadened its base beyond the army and other state functionaries. criticised populist army! In other conflicts SO officers for has rightly nazinEgiO taileice?
being rolled on and off the political arena. But in Afghanistan there was never any possibility of stage army tactics, as the Kabul regime soon found itself pitted against the vast majority off the population.
So, why should socialists *Defend the cities" ie defend the last areas under the control of an unpopular, hated Stalinist regime?
The editorial in SO no.399 points to the progressive measures the regime implemented. Particular attention is drawn to the position of women.
Socialists critically support such measures but in no way should we support the regime. By calling for the defence of the cities and not just for the defence of the social gains, the editorial sides too closely with the Najibullah regime.
In this discussion on a hated regime carrying out socially progressive measures recall Trotsky's reference to people not liking missionaries with bayonets. He stated: "It is impossible to impose revolutionary ideas and institutions on other people through military violence." Such actions "must correspond to the desires of the toiling masses"
The tragedy of the situation is that the progressive measures implemented by the PDP were carried out as dictates by an isolated government backed solely by the army.
The attempt to bring "enlightenment" on the end of a bayonet pushed the masses into the arms of reactionary mullahs. This is the lesson in what happens when a military short-cut is sought. To implement democratic measures mass support is essential, Today in Afghanistan, the conflict is between two equally reactionary and counter-revolutionary sides.
The Mujahedeen have the backing of the majority of the population. They carried out a successful fight to force the Russian army of occupation to flee dominated by warlords and reactionary country. However, -they are bigots and are opposed to the progressive measures brought in by the PDP.
The Kabul regime is a Stalinist clique raised to power by an army coup, has feeble public support and has spent most of its existence at war with the people of Afghanistan. However, government decrees have attempted to drag the country into the 20th century.
The "Defend the cities" slogan should be dropped. Instead the following points should be the basis of a socialist position.
1. Support neither side in the civil war - both sides are equally reactionary.
2. Support calls for a ceasefire and for a peaceful negotiated settlement.
3. Politically defend the social gains introduced by the PDP.
4. Defend the right of the people of Afghanistan to determine their own future.
S. For Constituent Tony Dalle Manchester
----- pull-quotes -----
the issues