Trotsky's summary
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-03-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Marxists "should always strive not only to renew the top leadership of the trade unions, boldly and resolutely in critical moments advancin new militant leaders in place of routine functionaries and careerists, but also to create in all possible instances independent militant organisations corresponding more closely to the tasks of mass struggle against bourgeois society; and, if necessary, not flinching even in the face of a direct break with the conservative apparatus of the trade "If it be criminal to turn one's back on mass organisations for the sake of fostering sectarian factions, it is no less so passively to tolerate subordination of the revolutionary mass movement to the control of openly reactionary or disguised conservative ('progressive') bureaucratic cliques. Trade unions are not ends in themselves; they are but means along the road to proletarian revolution."
Leon Trotsky, 'The Transitional Programme' It was involved in full scale collaboration with the government and with the state in World War 2.
In 1947 the National Dock Labour Board was set-up. It was an agency to employ dockers. Dockers were employed directly by the Board which then hired them out on a half day basis to the employers who would put them to work. If there were no employer the Board would be responsible for paying a minimum wage to the docker provided he turned up and got his book stamped.
The Dock Labour Board was 50% employers, 50% union representatives.
The TGWU had a closed shop and it was a half-share employer of the workers it was supposed to be representing. Highly bureaucratised, the job it base in London and was recognised by the employers there for negotiations, the Stevedores Union (NASD). The TGWU was known as the white union and the Stevedores as the blue union because of the colour of their cards.
The 16,000 dockers attempted to join the blue union'. They described this as "The biggest prison break in history'. But they failed. They struck for recognition for six weeks.
On the docks you had to negotiate pay according to the condition of each job, from day to day. Recognition was crucial to the whole business. You couldn't have a union that wasn't recognised.
The Dock Labour Board stuck to its mates, the T&G, fought a bitter struggle against the breakaway and refused to recognise it.
Scan page 7
e Communist Party, after its away from being ultra-left in 20s and '30s, had begun to › into the union bureaucracy. T&G in the late '40s had ugh the black circular' sed a ban on the CP members ng positions, a ban which held ace until 1970. But in London CP had the leadership of the ers. Their policy was to work way into the bureaucracy and ing favour by being good orters of the bureaucracy. So scabbed on the recognition indon didn't come out. The Blue Union to tried to expel. ockers who had joined it in the hern ports. The dockers tried ay in by taking the union to t. The blue union was lately expelled by the TUC in as the breakaway right or ig? In retrospect it was a fiasco. d to a split in the docks and a certain amount of nonnism, though not enougn tc ermine militancy. Many skyist groups opposed the kaway. The Grantites (now tant) condemned it, the ites (now the SWP) condemned The Healyites (later SLL-WRP) le central to the whole elopment. They acted as the link veen various ports. They had e dockers in Liverpool who red a leading role in the kaway. Bob Pennington, a lyite became a full-timer of the : union in Liverpool. think the Healyites were right. t sort of prison break - a rement of militant workers ch challenges the bureaucracy s a good thing.
The movement was defeated. After a defeat it is easy to say that you shouldn't have fought. But then when would you ever fight? You never have a guarantee of victory - the dockers could not have known in advance that they would be defeated.
In any case it was not a full scalle defeat. It liberated the militants and it helped change the TGWU. Arthur Deakin, the T&G autocratic right-wing General Secretary, died in 1954. His right-wing successor, Tiffin, soon died too, and a left-winger, Frank Cousins, became general secretary.
Frank Cousins was shaped not just by the bureaucracy but also by the breakaway and a big bus strike in the late '50s.
Unity is a good thing — but not the unity of the graveyard and of the apparatchiks. We have to analyse each situation concretely.
In any big struggle against the trade union bureaucracy there is a logic of split — just as in a big fight in the Labour Party. There is nothing that tells you that the antibureaucrats are going to get a majority, or that the union bureaucracy will be easily ousted. Faced with being defeated it can split the union. If that threat always makes us climb down and retreat, then we're paralysed.
As Rosa Luxemburg put it, the union doesn't create militancy, militancy creates the union. The union exists for the working class or it exists for nothing at all. We go by the interests of the working class, not by the interests of the union officials' shopkeeping.
From a speech at the receni Socialist Organiser indi istrial school. Mick Ackersley reviews the new fil about the Profur OU Affair, 'Scandal"
Scandal" is political movie from which the essential politics have been removed - a sort of decaffeinated political thriller about the 'Profumo Affair' In 1959 the Tory party won its third General Election in a row, with an increased majority. Within three years things started to go wrong. In 1963 the Profumo scandal took away what credibility the Government had left. The ailing Prime Minister, Harold Macmillan, resigned. A year later Labour won its first General Election in 13 years.
John Profumo was a very rich Tory, and Minister for War. (Euphemisms were not as all-pervasive then as now). The press discovered that he had slept with a woman, a prostitute or semiprostitute, Christine Keeler, when she was also sleeping with an attache at the Russian Embassy, Ivanov.
The scandal broke in the press when Keeler disappeared when she was due to give evidence in court against a boyfriend who had gone berserk, threatening her with a gun. Bit by bit, in an atmosphere of prurience, hypocrisy, and outrage, a series of surprising social links were uncovered.
Keeler was close to Stephen Ward, an osteopathic doctor and portrait-painter to the upper class, including members of the Royal Family. She also had underworld connections, such as John Edgecombe, the man who wanted to shoot her. And she, like her friend Mandy Rice-Davies, had been sexually involved with a notórious rackrenting slum landlord, Peter Rachman, who had as recently died. • And there Profumo — and Ivanov.
The affair brought to public notice the corrupt world of the rich and privileged. The discovery that some of the rich did not obey the rules of public morality which they preached was socially traumatic.
Rumours of sado-masochistic orgies, perhaps involving a member of the Royal Family, fed the prurience of press and public. People were a lot more easily shocked then than today; and the mainstream media did not criticise members of the Royal Family -not at all.
The Establishment tried to put out the fires of rumour and speculation by putting Stephen Ward on trial and framing him for allegedly living off the earnings of prostitution. This was done. apparently, on the personal instructions of Home Secretary Henry Brooke.
Keeler appeared against Ward, as did others. None of Ward's highlyplaced friends would so much as come to court to give him a character reference. Ward, snobby outsider, was cast in the role of scapegoat, a public sacrifice to public outrage.
He killed himself the night before a jury found him guilty of living off immoral earnings"
Minister of War John Profumo made a statement in the House of Commons- denying any 'impropriety in his relations with Christine Keeler. Soon afterwards he said he had lied, and resigned. Macmillan soon resigned too.
Perhaps decisive in this saga was the role of the Labour Party. Harold Wilson had taken over as Labour leader at the beginning of 1963, on the unexpected death of his predecessor, Hugh Gaitskell.
Wilson and his team went after the Tories with vigour and skill. They hammered away at the supposed 'security' implications of the Profumo-Keeler-Ivanov chain. They agitated on the theme of corruption in high society.
They used the scandal to expose the rackrenting system, and made Peter Rachman's name a synonym for slum landlordism.
Wilson was no socialist, and in office he was a disgrace to the labour movement. But in 1963 he wanted to drive the Tories from office, and he knew how to seize his chance.
"Scandal' tells the story, but with everything sifted. With a soundtrack of songs from the early '60s (and, surprisingly, one from the early '50s), much of it is a sort of 'Travellers in Time' trip back to the decadence of London's high and low society just on the eve of the birth of the "permissive society"
It presents the story as a romantic tale of doomed love between Stephen Ward and Keeler. Quite untruly as far as 1 know, it has Ward objecting in court, for example, when his barrister gets a bit rough with Keeler in the cross-examination.
Most of the political issues are blurred. If you didn't already know who and what Peter Rachman was, you wouldn't learn from this movie. The party-political side of it is played down to near invisibility.
Dealing with a story that could have been from Zola or Balzac, throwing a sharp light on early-'60s British society, the movie simply doesn't seem to have a point of view.
It is blunt where it could be sharp - soft-focused, like a TV ad.
Essentially, it's an exploitation movie. Even the soundtrack is likely to be a money-spinner in the nostalgia market.
On balance, though, I think it's worth seeing. Joanne Whalley as Christine Keeler is only halfconvincing. Bridget Fonda is far better as Mandy Rice-Davies, suggesting John Hurt is - inevitably - 8ood - g000 as Ward, even though the script makes the character and his motivations unclear.
Scan page 8
pen letter to Socialist Outlool Wall dividing Protestant and Catholic workers: do Socialist Outlook want to make sectarian divisions worse? Photo Dear Comrades, A Meeting of the Labour t the recent Annual General Committee on Ireland, you were the main force behind a motion calling, not for British troops, but British unions to leave Ireland. Although many of you were plainly embarrassed by the proposal, you voted for it as a body.
This bizarre episode in Irish 'solidarity work shows you to be completely disoriented on the Irish question - so disoriented you cannot stand by elementary working class internationalist politics. And this from a group which, more than any other, insists that it is part of an international movement.
At stake is the relationship between socialism and nationalism. Where we support nationalist demands, and demands for the break-up of forced imperialist links between nations, we do so to further international working class unity and voluntary working class links between nations. If such voluntary working class links already exist - if working class organisations already exist that span the national division - the last thing we want is to break them up. On the contrary, we want more international union orgnisation.
Don't we? Your proposal for British anions out' calls into question the entire international socialist programme.
The theoretical underpinning for such a position must be the 'imperialist' character of British-Irish relations. Ireland is a colony, or semi-colony, of Britain. This fact overrides all other considerations, including those of class politics. Consciously or not, any British intervention into Ireland reflects this imperialism. British unions form part of the imperialist structure of power. We must insist on 'Brits out' — all 'Brits', troops and trade unionists alike.
James Connolly and Jim Larkin both arrived in Ireland as labour organisers from Britain - Larkin as the agent of a based unions — notably the TGWU, MSF, UCATT, AEU, NGA and NUJ. In Northern Ireland, fully 78% of organised workers are in British-based unions.
The bigger representation of British-based unions in the North is partly due to the fact that British public-sector employers — the National Health Service, for example - operate in the North.
Tens of thousands of Catholic, nationalist, Republican workers belong to British-based unions. There is, however, a bias making Protestant workers more likely to join British-based unions.
Between 1944 and 1959 the Irish trade union movement was split. The official reason why many (not all) of the Irishbased unions split away to form the Congress of Irish Unions was that the Irish TUC joined the "communistdominated" World Federation of Trade Unions. But the real reason was national/communal tension, aggravated by southern Ireland's neutrality and Britain's engagement in World War 2. The CIU insisted on Irish-based unions only.
Until now all Marxists had considered the reunification of Irish labour a step forward. Those who objected were the Protestant bigots of Northern Ireland, who have picketed all-Ireland trade union conferences and demanded a separate Ulster TUC. Now you come forward as the mirror image of the ultra-Loyalists!
At least the CIU sought to persuade Irish workers to leave British unions. But you have not proposed - though it would be weird enough - that Irish socialists start a membership war between Irish and British-based unions. (Presumably you are in favour of it, and we await with interest your explanation of the possible consequences of such a policy should anyone be brain-fried enough to adopt it).
By voting for a British-based organisation to campaign for 'British unions out', you give the nationalist worker-splitting drive a new twist: the call is for British unions to get rid of Andrew Moore (Reflex) vince them, you want to boycott them. It sounds pretty imperialist to us!
British trade union presence in Ireland is not merely an aspect of imperialist domination. It is a result of the long historical inter-relationship between the working class movements of the two countries. And it is linked to the division within the working class in Ireland, along communal lines, which lies at the core of the Irish problem' Britain has used, shaped and exacerdestroyed in the fires of revolution? Perhaps you believe that they are — superficial appearances notwithstanding — not really workers at all — just a "labour aristocracy' or an elite caste?
Perhaps you believe, therefore, that the Irish revolution will not only not require the participation of Protestant workers, but will be against them? That the Protestant working class will remain reactionary because its conviction that it easily join an 'anti-imperialist' one instead) don't really deserve unions at all, do they?
This is the opposite of a socialist approach. Most Protestant workers are reactionary. But a socialist approach is not a bureaucratic appeal to British unions to wreak 'anti-imperialist" vengeance on them. It is to build unity at rank and file level between Protestant and Catholic workers.
That unity should include British