Why 'Russians out' was right
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-03-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Marxist as Eric Heffer!
Cliff attacked Heffer by name. He grossly misrepresented him too: an MP who — for example — calls on the labour movement to defy the law as Heffer did to help the embattled seamen last year, deserves better treatment than Cliff gave Heffer in his introduction to the book about the Bolsheviks in the Tzarist "Parliament' Why shouldn't Eric Heffer point out the absurdities and the contradictions in such an attack on him by an organisation which has always had a high proportion of rich and sometimes very rich people in it and in its leadership, and most of whose members are middlé class?
When I was on the National Committee of Cliff's organisation c. 1970, that committee contained at least half a dozen very rich men, some of them probably millionaires.
It is to the great credit of such people that they find their way to the socialist movement and devote time, energy and money to the cause of liberating the proletariat Socialist Organiser has not, as Frank Anthony alleges (SO 391), just "woken up to how reactionary the Afghan muslims are". We never doubted that the mullahs (though I'm not so sure about every single muslim!) were reactionary.
What we opposed was the notion that the USSR's army of occupation could be a progressive alternative to those mullahs — or, to be more precise, to the majority of the Afghan people.
Take an analogy or two. We are opposed to the regime in Iran, which is made up of pretty reactionary mullahs. But we would oppose a Russian invasion of Iran — even if Iranian leftists were crazy enough to call for such an invasion.
We would have opposed a USSR invasion of Pakistan under Zia — another regime claiming to base itself on Islam, also reactionary.
The alternative to a reactionary regime in Kabul is not Russian occupation. First,_Russian occupation proved unsuccessful in quelling the Afghan rebels: to be successful it would have needed to be more brutal, more extensive, even than it was. Frank Anthony and co-thinkers should face up to this fact. If you want the Russians to deal with the mullahs you want more or less to depopulate Afghanistan, either by mass murder or by driving refugees across the border.
Second, the political results of the USSR's occupation has been precisely to strengthen the most reactionary elements of Afghan society.
How anyone can believe the USSR's balance sheet in Afghanistan has proved 'progressive" is beyond me.
So it is not the case that "effective" defence of the Afghan cities logically requires the presence of Russian troops. Every day the Russian troops remained in Afghanistan strengthened the hand of the rebels. And the political cost - to socialism throughout the regime — would be greater than the benefit.
Clive Bradley Peckham