Gorbachev in trouble
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-03-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
ORGANISER Restructuring will conquer" declares Mikhail Gorbachev. But with even his own economic advisers sounding increasingly ill at ease, not to say bewildered, by the state of the Soviet economy, his assurances are unconvincing.
Indeed, it is difficult to believe that Gorbachev convinces himself. Perestroika so far seems to have produced nothing but more muddle and conflict. For sure, neither for the government nor Russian workers has perestroika delivered.
Gorbachev's supporters have taken to blaming failures on circumstances beyond their control. For some the collapse in the prices of oil and gas — two of the USSR's major exports — has not helped. Nor have the massive bills for the Chernobyl clean-up and the Armenian earthquake operation.
But economists in the Soviet Union admit that the real problem is the form perestroika itself is taking - the piecemeal marketoriented reforms of the bureaucratic economy are often producing perverse results, or no results at all.
The cooperatives which were flavour of the month with the government last summer are now Facing newly-imposed restrictions on their activities.
Shortages of goods in official shops drove workers to the co-ops. The new Soviet entrepreneurs took the main chance and charged well over the odds. The result - angry. workers demanding that the government do something about the cooperative 'extortionists".
Attempts to improve productivity in agriculture have also floundered. 50 year leases were offered to farmworkers as an incentive - but hardly anyone took them up. Strikes have begun to occur again, over inflation and shortages. Perestroika has done nothing to put good in the shops, or to do away with queuing as a fact of life. Inflation is running at over five percent.
The reformers want the market rather than the ministries to determine prices. Subsidies — 70 roubles a year — on food would have to go.
The result of this would be higher inflation and reduced living standards, leading to more popular discontent. Not surprisingly, Gorbachev has put off any discussion of price reform until 1991.
Moreover, the Soviet Union's budget deficit is now judged to be not the officially-claimed 35 billion roubles, but 100 billion. One motive behind Gorbachev's muchThe Campaign for Israeli-Palestinian Peace has been founded in solidarity with the Israeli Council for Israeli-Palestinian Peace. Formed in 1976, ICCIPP is active in the wider Israeli Peace Movement and has consistently advocate talks between Israel and the P on the basis of a two state publicised arms and troops reductions was to help reduce the deficit.
Other strategies include halting major capital investment projects, and ending subsidies to loss-making enterprises.
But how can industry be modernised if investment is cut? And workers will resist job losses caused by factory closures.
Gorbachev may make confident noises about perestroika. But a look at Hungary, where the marketsocialist experiment has been in solution to the conflict.
CIPP aims to promote the ideas and aims of ICCIPP in Britain, and to make solidarity with both the Palestinians and the Israeli left.
Contact Ben Cohen, 91 Granville Road, Fallowfield, Manchester M14 6AD. progress for 20 years shows the of the problems.
The Hungarian leadership are now edging closer to a full market economy, with political pluralism. In the USSR Gorbachev has constantly ruled out anything of that sort. If anything, an attempt to clamp down again looks more likely.
Gorbachev's reforms are an improvement on the old Stalinist order. But there's no room for blind faith or illusions.
I don't remember thousands of people turning out on the streets or the left wing press going for the throats of the Coal Board and lan MacGregor.
It seems to me that two rank and file trade unionists getting the sack for putting their ideas into print can quite easily be forgotten whereas we have to make this great hoo-hah about this middle class intellectual who's written a book about religion — albeit knocking it, but about religion.
It seems to me that if you look at it in that context then perhaps you can get some of the understanding of the idea that I was trying to get across last week. I'm not condemning the principle of free expression but condemning the way the argument is carried through and about whom.
Trade unionists get trampled into the mud and very little is said. Middle class intellectual liberals publish some book about religion and straight away it's a massive persecution and people are screaming blue murder.
We should keep it in context.
Paul Whetton is a member of Manton NUM, South Yorkshire.