Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The victin viewpoint

Socialist Organiser no. 391, 1 March 1989 · scan p. 10 · about 1,072 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

reviews 'The Accused' young woman walks into A a bar. The way she is dressed is what would be called 'sexy' - short skirt, high heels, skimpy top.

She drinks, she smokes a joint, she dances sexily and flirts with several men. It's all a bit of fun, a pit of a laugh, Then she is thrown on top of a pinball machine and gang-raped -surrounded by shouting, clapping and cheering men. Did she ask for *The Accused" is an apt title. Three men are accused of raping Sarah Tobias (played by Jodie Foster). The men in the bar are accused of inciting the rape. But Tobias herself is accused — accused of being a woman who drinks, has a drugs conviction, overtly displays her sexuality, and is working class.

She is by no means the ideal rape victim - as her woman lawyer wastes no time in telling her. She is a 'bad witness' - remember, in rape cases the victim is only a witness.

Her well groomed successoriented lawyer believes Sarah has been raped - her behaviour and her injuries speak for themselves but does not believe she has a case.

So, without even consulting Sarah, she indulges in a spot of "plea bargaining' with the rapist's lawyers. The men are put inside -but for 'reckless endangerment' not rape. Sarah does not even get the chance to tell her story in court.

Her lawyer, Kathryn Murphy, rejoices in a job well done. Meanwhile Sarah hears how she has been sold down the river from the TV.

One of the most powerful scenes in the film is when Sarah bursts into Murphy's yuppie flat, interrupting a dinner party and tells her exactly what she thinks, of her. Murphy is sufficiently shamed to try to make amends.

After ploughing through legal textbooks she finds a way - she takes the onlookers to court on the charge of inciting a rape. A victory on this would prove that a rape had in fact taken place. Sarah would be vindicated.

This film is strong and realistic in that it refuses to show any fake sisterhood between the women characters. Sarah is poor, streetwise, 'vulgar' - Kathryn is succesful and middle class. Their worlds will never meet and the film never pretends otherwise.

They do develop some natural trust and affection, but slowly and not without ups and downs - no trouble-free female bonding here.

Sarah's best friend is a waitress at the bar where the rape took place. She knew it was going on but did nothing. She ran away from it, just didn't want to know. No oversimplification there either.

There are lots of small but very telling scenes in the film. Sarah's boyfriend can't or won't cope. He gets angry - he just wants everything back to normal. Why doesn't she want sex with him -it's all over isn't it?

After the confrontation at Murphy's apartment, Sarah goes home and hacks off her own hair. She tells her stunned boyfriend she "felt like a change" . It's not possible to explain the significance of this — but I felt it, and I'm sure most other women will too.

The rape itself is only shown at the end of the film, and is shown from Sarah's point of view. It's long, nasty and thoroughly draining.

We see, from Sarah's viewpoint, the animals in the bar cheering, egging the rapists on, chanting "One, two, three, tour, poke that pussy till its sore" . We see the distorted, ugly faces of the rapists as they ejaculate.

Some feminists in the US have objected to the inclusion of this scene on the grounds that the Jodie Foster as rape victim Sarah Tobias graphic depiction of rape could titillate some men. No way! is sc No-one, woman or man, could in th endure this scene without feeling anger, horror, and disgust. It smashes the myth that rape is anything to do with sex, or even solely to do with relationships between women and men - the relationship between the men themselves are just as important -the need to compete, to prove themselves in front of their mates.

At the end of the film, two statistics appear on the screen. In the USA, a rape happens every 6 minutes. A quarter of these involve two or more men.

The poster for the film states rape is "the only crime in which the victim has to prove her innocence" A big step forward - after all, the film comes not from a small independent film maker but from Paramount.

Jodie Foster is marvellous as Sarah Tobias. It must have been heartbreaking role, but she plays with vitality and a strange dignity. Sarah is never just a pathetic victim. "Th Nak shoi /hat sticks in my mind though, ›mething before I even set toot le cinema. Next to the poster for = Accused' was one for *The red Gun', the other film wing.

Cheung Siu Ming reviews 'Red Sorghum' and Sweet' Led Sorghum' starts with the narrator claiming that a lot of people do not believe his story.

His grandma was a young peasant girl married off by her parents for the price of a mule. Her rich husband-to-be, a rotting leper who owns a winery, was mysteriously murdered. Many thought it was done by the narrator's grandpa, There were small pictures of each of the main characters. One of Priscilla Presley carried the caption, "The Blonde. Like a drugstore, she was open all hours", We've still got a long way to go. one of the winery's hired hands.

The winery is in the middle of a vast field of wild red sorghum (a kind of Chinese millet). It is in a harsh, windswept part of North China where the peasants struggle hard to survive.

The girl abandons her new role as owner of the winery and persuades the former hired hands to work as a cooperative. They managed to make the winery a flourishing success - until the -Japanese army arrives to build a road right through the field of red sorghum.

This might sound just what the Party ordered - the Bad Old Days before the Revolution and the People's Resistance against the Japanese occupation.

This film indeed had to satisfy political requirements. It manages to do so while still conveying in a sensitive and silent way, the dignity of the poor peasants' lives, their celebration of

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 391

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →