The bureaucrats don't have control
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-03-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Be Philipp In 1985 the hideous dictatorship of President Marcos in the Philippines was overthrown by a ma: movement demandir "people's power" Corazon Aquino, a wealthy liberal opponent of Marcos, was elected president Yet poverty, inequality, violence -and huge US military bases - remain. This is the first part of an article by a Filipino socialist, Joly Macuja which looks at how the left is organising.
many ways, the problems of the Filipino people are like those of many countries in the Third World. Poverty stalks the land, with more than 50% of the population, the majority of which are industrial and rural workers, living below the poverty threshold.
The roots of the problem are not a lack of resources. Per capita the country would be classified as middle income, and it has registered a respectable growth of gross national product.
The answers are glaringly simple. Even government figures cannot ine American occupation that followed did little to alter that power structure but consolidated a ruling landed class from which capitalist interests emerged dominant.J This elite continued after independence following World War 2, controlling the political scene on the local level via the perpetuation of land owning oligarchies, and on the national level via businesses which were closely linked to the international market.
Power on the national level was shared by the rural oligarchies. The Presidency was the indivisible prize, and was rotated among the various cliques in the ruling class, all of them servile to the interests of the United States - which continues to wield political influence because of its economic interests, and •the presence of its largest military facilities outside of mainland USA - Clark and Subic.
The Philippine working class has borne the brunt of the order's inequality. It is within this context that the Philippine Left has organised and grown in both capacity and sophistication.
The movement in general is understandably / anti-imperialist in much of its sentiment and rhetoric, for such was its legacy — the revolt of the Philippine masses under the leadership of Andres Bonifacio against the Spanish; the organisation of independent trade and peasant unions to fight for better conditions while still under American colonial rule in the 1930s, revolving eventually around sympathy for the Communist Party of the Philippines of the 1920s-30s; the peasants in Central Luzon which composed the backbone of the Hukbong Bayan Laban sa Hapon (or the Huks) which proved one of the ablest guerilla movements during the Japanese occupation of the Philippines, Philippine participation in the Vietnam war, for land reform, for Filipinisation of the schools, and other issues.
It was in the '60s that the present crop of activists which make up the leadership of the Philippine left emerged.
Following the declaration of martial law in 1972, the left continued to organise clandestinely. It emerged in the open again in the leadership of the 'parliament of the streets' after the assassination of Senator Benigno S. Aquino in August 1983, when there was a massive outpouring of sentiment for the dismantling of the Marcos dictatorship (which continued in effect in spite the paper lifting of martial law in 1981).
The decision by the left in general to boycott the May 1984 legislative elections (rightly perceived to be pointless given Marcos' decreemaking powers) put it more sharply into contrast with the 'traditional (ie conservative) opposition whose agenda lay mainly in the realm of parliamentary struggle.
Participation varied in the snap presidential elections in the latter part of 1985 and the popular revolt which unfolded in February of 1986 resulting in the ousting of Marcos and the installation of Corazon C. Aquino as president.
Three years after that revolt the basic problem of the Filipino people succinctly encapsulated by the late respected bourgeois nationalist Jose W. Diokno as 'food and freedom, jobs and justice' remain. And the Philippine left has seen just cause to step up its efforts to forward its socialist alternative.
All the left's various tendencies are clearly anti-imperialist, favouring national capital versus perceived transnational domination of the economy and pledging to dismantle the US military bases. All Peter Burton continues our debat on the Eastern Bloc, replying to Clive Bradley's argument (SO 388) that the bureaucrats are classes the Soviet Union is visibly Ill disintegrating after only 70 years of existence. But why has it lasted 7 decades and who knows, perhaps even another one?
Doesn't this mean that the society has a ruling-class, that the economy has a central dynamic, and that there must be planning in the USSR, however bad?
I think the first point to note is that in those 7 decades there hasn't been one decade of stability. The system has never been out of crises, from the NEP of the '20s to the stagnation under Brezhnev in the '70s.
The scissors crisis' in the mid-'20s was followed by the agricultural Crisis in 1929; the purges of the *30s; the external crisis of war in the '40s; stagnation in the "50s; a failed attempt to reintroduce the market in the mid-'60s by Brezhnev and Kosygin; and complete stagnation in the 70s, which resulted in the K.G.B. putting a reformer into power in March 1985, in the belief that reform is better than revolution.
The bureaucrats have some control or partial control over the surplus product the Soviet Union; not no control. This results from the centre/periphery relationship in the Soviet Union, well documented by Hillel Ticktin in 'Critique'.
This relationship causes real problems of information between the central 'planners' and the enterprises. In the absence of democratic forms of organisation, i.e. workers' self-management, accurate information is only fed back to the central planners if this information coincides with the personal interests of the workers and the managers in the enterprises.
This has two consequences. The first is massive waste; the second is a limited degree of reproduction, as the centre does get some accurate information occasionally.
However to go on to describe this as planning or even bad planning is to divest the category of planning of any real meaning for Marxists. 'Organised' or 'administered' are better categories for describing how the economy is regulated.
The existence of the armaments industry and its relationship to the bureaucrats does not negate this. Military discipline is used here in a way that wouldn't be efficient if applied to the whole of the economy. Incentives to the workers in the industry are also real incentives, i.e. better quality food, cars etc.
Moreover the industry still has the same centre/periphery problems as other industries, with the product being defective in the same way tanks with no armour plating are commonplace!
The elite are not only not a ruling class because of their partial control over the surplus product, but also because they don't constitute a forms of society to prove that the Soviet Union must have a ruling class as these societies certainly had reveals a false underlying perception of the nature of the Soviet Union. Those pre-capitalist societies (the Ottoman Empire; precolonial sub-Saharan Africa etc etc were modes of production. The Soviet Union isn't one. That is the whole point.
The regime's simultaneous anti-socialist and anti-capitalist nature continues to focus the debate on one of definition, i.e. the search for a label is paramount. Historically the working class overthrew capitalism in the October Revolution but had its own dictatorship of the proletariat removed. The result was a highly contradictory society. It is in an examination of these contradictions that the debate lies.
Right now in the USSR the elite is trying desperately to turn itself into a ruling class, by attempting to marginalise and divide the working class. In May 1985, two months after Gorbachev's advent to power he raised the salaries of the intelligentsia in what can only be seen as a deliberate attempt to separate the working class from the intellectuals.
The joint ventures with the West have as their objective the creation of a skilled working class, a labour aristocracy, with higher wages.
The elite know that all attempts at partially reforming the system in the past have failed and that the society has to change as a whole. Socialism would mean the end of their privileges; the only other alternative is the introduction of the market. The introduction of the latter means dealing with that is what they are doing at present.
The elite's objective is an ideology of their own, which means being able to conceptualise in a way that they cannot do just now. They want the reproduction of educational privileges for their children without going through the barbaric process that they have to go through now: and above all they want full control of the surplus product, None of this means that there is, not exploitation in the Soviet Union, nor conflict between the workers and the elite; and certainly not that socialists shouldn't stand unequivocally with the workers against the elite in the Soviet Union; but it does mean that the focus of the debate should change to analysing what Gorbachev and the elite are trying to do, as the lessons of this for Marxists are vitally important.
Revolt against Russian Imperialism
----- pull-quotes -----
WORKERS, LIBERTY-