Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[Can unity be achieved by coercing the protestants?…]

Socialist Organiser no. 391, 1 March 1989 · scan p. 8 · about 1,477 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Can unity be achieved by coercing the protestants? VI activists are ore labour movement interested in Ireland and in combatting British repression there. But there is political chaos at the heart of the activity:

Membership of the Labour Committee on Ireland has grown from 300 to 700 over the last two years. But 100 activists meeting at the movement's AGM last weekend (25-26 February) nearly voted to commit it to campaign for British trade unions to get out of Ireland.

Most of the votes for this crackbrain proposal were from supporters of Socialist Outlook and Briefing.

"How can we call for British troops out of Ireland when we have British trade unions still in Ireland?" said Chris Erswell, moving the proposal. The main speakers against were supporters of Socialist Organiser.

Patrick Murphy said that the underlying idea seemed to be a bureaucratic solution to a political problem to deal with the conservative influence in British unions of Northern Ireland Protestant members not by convincing those workers but by expelling them!

If such a drive to get British unions out of Ireland ever developed, it would be no less than union-busting and sabotage of what limited workers' unity still exists in Northern Ireland.

In reality there was no chance of it; but the debate was important as a test of the political viability and credibility of the Labour Committee on Ireland.

Jim Denham pointed out that the proposal would mean that when CPSA members in Northern Ireland, Protestant and Catholic together, struck against sectarian violence, their union should have expelled them! When NUPE and CoHSE members in Northern Ireland's hospitals, Protestant and Service action, their unions should boot them out!

About 15% of trade unionists in Southern Ireland are in British-based unions - notably the TGWU, AEU, MSF, and UCATT. In Northerh Ireland British-based public service unions are strong, and British-based unions account for 78% of all organised workers.

Redmond O'Neill of Socialist Action also spoke against 'British unions out and it was very narrowly defeated by an unusual united front of Socialist Organiser, Workers' Power, and Socialist Action. (Last week's SO was wrong to attribute the 'British unions out' proposal to Workers' Power in fact they opposed it).

No-one from Socialist Outlook took the floor of the conference to argue for 'British unions out'; in individual discussion, some Socialist Outlook people argued that the presence of British unions in Ireland was "imperialist" , others were embarrassed and would have preferred to vote against the proposal. Nevertheless they voted in a body for 'British unions out'. It Is an important, startling and damning mark on this tendency's political record.

Most of the conference was taken up with a conflict over campaign strategy between Socialist Action and Socialist Outlook, the two tendencies with the greatest initiatives and the success of the Intermediate-range Nuclear Force -g-ticti- make Labour's policy of removing nuclear weapons from our land, sea and air more relevant and practical than ever before, We are also convinced that changes in British public opinion have opened up the opportunity for Labour to go on the political offensive in favour of accelerating the process of deaudearising the defence of Britain.

Labour's own polls indicated that unilateralism has contributed only a marginal loss of votes in previous elections, taking only third or fourth place among the reasons given by those who did not vote Labour in 1987.

Only a tiny minority of the British people now think that there is a serious military threat from the Soviet Union. It is also clear that the demand for the removal of American nuclear weapons from this country remains popular.

We therefore reiterate our support for Labour's continued commitment to unilateral nuclear disarmament as part of a comprehensite defence strategy, based on the principles of nonprovocative defence and the Simultaneous pursuit of initiatives and negotiations towards European common security.

Our policy could contribute to but in no way diminishes the necessity to seek ways of avoiding proliferation of nuclear capability which threatens not only i trJ*t action but also the negotiated super-power moves to lessen the threat of nuclear war.

We invite all those who share our belief to join us by supporting the statement and by working to ensure that Labour policy continues to contribute to peace and disarmament.

Wednesday 1 March SO-SWP debate on Socialists and the Labour Party. Speakers include Ray Ferris (SO). Dorset Inst. Higher Education. 1.00 Saturday 4 March 'Women in Black' mass picket at Martins in the Field, 3.00-4.00. Please wear black. To demand recognition of PLO and self-determination for Palestine Monday 6 March London SO education series: 'The General Strike of 1926'. Speaker Vicki Morris, 7.00 Monday 6 March Manchester SO meeting: numbers there. Socialist Action argued for a focus on building "Time to Go' , a broad movement launched last November at a 600-strong conference. Socialist Outlook did not reject "Time to Go' , but emphasised more united action with the Troops Out Movement and the Irish in Britain Representation Group.

The conference was very finely balanced, and numerous resolutions covered broadly the same issues, so both sides of the debate came out with resolutions (narrowly) passed which encapsulated their strategies. On the whole Socialist Action had slightly the better of it.

Socialist Outlook argued that they were mounting the left-wing resistance to Socialist Action's efforts to pull the campaign to the right. They were insisting on the sharp, clear slogans of Troops Out and Self-Determination «dump Socialist Action wanted to the old slogans" and dissolve into the vagueness of "Time to Go"

But what did Socialist Outlook mean by self-determination for Ireland? There is no alternative to the status quo supported by a majority in Ireland. A majority probably wants a united Ireland as a future ideal - but even among Northern Catholics there is, according to polls, only a smallish minority for a united Ireland as an immediate solution.

What Socialist Outlook seemed to mean by self-determination for Ireland was unity by coercion of the Protestants. But certainly 90 per cent of the Irish people are against inal course; so wilo is Goales) determining here?

Even if a majority were for unity by coercion would coercion of the minority be a democratic solution?

before safety'. Speaker Julia Coulton. Millstone pub, Thomas 7.30 Thursday 9 March Merseyside SO meeting:

Afghanistan: Russia's Vietnam. Speaker Tom Rigby. Wallasey Unemployed Centre, 7.30. Saturday 18 March Campaign Against Massacres in Iran, Iraq and Turkey. Picket atTurkish Airways, 11 Hanover St, W1. 1.00 Monday 20 March London SO education series: 'Early years of the British CP'. Speaker Tom Rigby, 7.00 Wednesday 22 March South London SO. 'Socialists and Ireland': speakers Martin Collins (TTG) and Martin Thomas. Walwor Town Hall, SE17. 7.30 Saturday 25 March Campaign Against Massacres Would it be progressive to replace coercion of half-a-million Northern Catholics by coercion of one million Protestants?

In any case, is unity by coercion possible? The Protestants are a compact majority in a substantial area; they are heavily-armed. Wouldn't an attempt at unity by coercion actually lead to sectarian civil war and repartition?

Don't we need some programme to establish the rights of both the Irish majority and the minority? A programme to establish some unity of the Irish people and thus make "self-determination of the Irish people as a whole" a meaningful possibility? Isn't a federal united Ireland, with regional autonomy for the mainly-Protestant area, an outline of such a programme?

Socialist Organiser raised these questions repeatedly, but we got only two answers. One, that civil war is an unavoidable part of revolution. Two, that British socialists have no right to propose any programme for Ireland.

All that was the downside. It leaves the Labour Committee Ireland mouthing slogans Troops Out, Self-Determination which to it mean a united Ireland and the liberation of the oppressed Northern Catholics but which in reality (and to most people listening) mean something very different or nothing at all.

The upside is the larger number of people becoming interested in Ireland, and the possibility of a less sloganistic debate in the emerging 'Time to Go" movement. "Time to Go" plans a weekend conference OLE 10-10 June, and mass 16 12 Tuna and macc demonstration on 12 August. We should build for these events and make sure the arguments are heard there.

Iran, Iraq and Turkey, Picket at United Nations Info Centre, 20 Buckingham Gate, London SW1 1.00 Saturday 8 April Gorbachev and the European Left Conference (two days). ULU, Mal St, London WC1. Contact Gus Fagan, 30 Bridge St, Oxford QX2 OBA Saturday 29 April CLPs Conference on Democracy Sunday 14 May Lutte Ouvriere fete near Paris Saturday 17 June Socialist Conference Third Conference (two days). Octagon Centre, Sheffield Saturday 8 July Workers' Liberty Summer School (two days), London Saturday 11 November Socialist Conference 'Building _eft in the Unions, Sheffield

----- pull-quotes -----

ACTIMISTS DIARY

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 391

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →