Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The pub bores' pub bore

Socialist Organiser no. 391, 1 March 1989 · scan p. 3 · about 785 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Have you ever read The experts' expert' feature in the Observer magazine? It's drivel they put in between the adverts.

The basic idea is simple: take eight or nine 'experts' on a particular subject or from a particular profession and ask them which of their contemporaries they admire most. Tot up the results and — hey presto! — you have The Experts' Expert, It has to be said that the final choice of experts' expert often seems pretty arbitrary and I have a suspicion that they often choose whoever is around to have a nice arty photo of themselves taken.

But when the magazine asked national newspaper columnists their opinions recently, the winner emerged with a clear majority: Keith Waterhouse. He won the votes of Katherine Whitehorn (Observer), Lynda Lee Potter (Daily Mail) and Auberon Waugh (Spectator and Sunday Telegraph), plus honourable mentions from Miles Kington (Independent) and Hugo Young (Guardian).

As it happens, Keith Waterhouse was the first columnist I read with any regularity, back in the late '60s through to the early '80s, when he wrote every Monday in the Daily Mirror. He had a lightness of touch, an eye for the ridiculous and a nose for humbug that I found irresistible. Above all, he had a sense of fair play and general decency which shone through everything he wrote.

I remember a powerful piece he did in the mid-'70s in defence of Tony Benn, who was even then being branded a "loony' by most of the press. Another one that stands out in the memory was a brilliant demolition of the hang 'em and flog 'em, law and order brigade; it closed with a footnote to the effect that discovered his car aerial had been broken off by some passing yobbo, occasioning an incandescent rage that nad very nearly caused him to completely rewrite his column.

But the best Waterhouse of all took the form of an open letter to his 18 year old daughter, just before the 1974 general election, urging her to vote Labour and explaining why. I clipped it out and carried it around in my wallet for years.

Towards the end of the "70s something began to happen to Waterhouse. His regular tirades agains: petty bureaucracy and municipal officiousness began to sound more and more like the voice of a middle class suburban Ratepayer (with a capital R). He became increasingly indignant, not about injustice and prejudice, but about such world-shattering subjects as the change in the design of Marmite labels and the fashion for calling dustmen "waste disposal operatives The GLC (whose occasional foolishness would have been the subject of some gentle ribbing in the old days) became almost an obsession with him.

By 1979 Waterhouse could only just bring himself to call for a Labour vote, with his own version of 'no illusions' He finally left the Mirror when Capt'n Bob took over, which admittedly seemed like a pretty good reason. But to join the Daily Mail! That was almost an act of betrayal.

These days, the Waterhouse column is little more than an extremely articulate and often witty mouthpiece for the typical Daily Mail readers' opinions. His one hangover from the past is a reluctant, half-hearted support for Labour at election time. Even that may not last much longer: in 1987 he warned that this could be the last time.

Katherine Whithorn (in the Observer magazine) said she preferred Waterhouse when, "his old-fashioned common sense was an antidote to the left-wing extremism of the Daily Mirror." How anyone (even an SDPsupporter like Whitehorn) could consider the Mirror, at any time, to have been guilty of "left-wing extremism" is beyond me. Quite often, in fact, Waterhouse used to defy the Mirror's editorial line from the left - as when he defended Tony Benn.

But Whitehorn's main point about that "old-fashioned common sense" is true enough: "Too many Daily Mail readers may mistake it for their own prejudices. Columnists often do best when they are writing against the grain of their own newspaper."

Waterhouse, in the same "Experts" Expert' feature (he nominated Oliver Pritchett of the Sunday Telegraph) defined a 'good columnist' as "someone who says what the man in the pub would have said if he had thought of it first." That's a pretty good description of Waterhouse himself these days: a wittier than average pub bore. But there was a time when Waterhouse would have made the man in the pub choke on his pint of Double Diamond. I'll drink to the old, younger Waterhouse.

----- pull-quotes -----

quite interesting — or seems so in comparison with the rest of the

GANIG Daily Express DAILY THE INDEPENDENT since writing the above, the author had

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 391

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →