Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

It's a ruling class, but in crisis

Socialist Organiser no. 390, 22 February 1989 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 1,724 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Barry Finger contributes to our debate on the Eastern Bloc tan Crooke (SO 386)

questions whether the ruling stratum in the Eastern Bloc can rightfully be rectly, the crux of the issue is the inability of the bureaucracy to generate an effective regulator for the supply and extraction of social labour. Failing this, it cannot master the appropriation of the surplus-product and consequently unable to fulfil its class aspirations.

This explains why the aureaucracy and the society it dominates find themselves ever more deeply into a historic 'blind alley'.

What is so problematic in this argument is that Crooke identifies that condition which under any ather mode of production would be characterised as a 'class' crises, but denies its applicability for Stalinism.

After all, a capitalist crisis, looked at from one angle, is nothing if not a failure of the pricing system to generate a sufficient level of demand for the profitable accumulation of capital. Conversely, commodities are over-produced relative to the current level of exploitation so that markets cannot be cleared at prices that preserve the existing level of capital values.

Yet it would be absurd to analyse capitalism solely during such periods of crises. For then one would have to conclude from the abservation of contracting output and declining or stagnating living standards that capital lacked a mechanism of social regulation.

Every antagonistic class society affers from problems of waste and moblems inherent to the introducion of new technology which are unique to it, including capitalism. the pricing system is incapable of seventing disproportionalities -concurrent gluts and shortages -and can detect and correct them ony ex post facto. This predominant orm of capitalist waste prevents he individual expenditure of labour ounting as social labour and is a ontinuous and unavoidable henomenon of capitalist society.

The pricing system also filters out he introduction of labour saving echnological innovations which are oo costly to be profit-enhancing. Inder crisis conditions these pronems are multiplied and thereby rought into bold relief.

So might one not apply Crooke's malysis to capitalism? By isolating apitalism under crisis conditions, vould we not be forced to conclude hat, lacking an "effective" social egulator, capitalists are incapable constituting themselves as lass?

Similarly the undeniable ristorical fact of reproduction on • expanded scale also proves the hesis untenable that Stalinism lacks a economic regulator. For what we se witnessing in the Eastern Bloc aday is not the normal -wistorically typical - workings of Stalinist system, but weakdown crisis.

Granted even this, still stagnation s not the universal current exserience of the Stalinist social ystem, merely its predominant exmession witness the East German exception.

Clearly the Stalinist social ystems have also seen prolonged seriods of dramatic economic growth. This requires the perfornance of surplus labour, its apAll those against calling ourselves propriation and its reapplication to the production process, all of which is executed however imperfectly in response to planning directives. And whether these directives are detailed commands or general guidelines the details of which are fleshed out by market forces, they are drawn up by a bureaucracy answerable neither directly nor indirectly to any other social force.

This in itself is sufficient to belie the "orthodox" Trotskyist distortion that by preserving nationalised property the bureaucracy acts as a fiduciary agent of the working class. The task for Marxists remain in working out how class conflicts within the Stalinist sytem express themselves in the acute breakdown of the bureaucratic planning mechanism.

Crooke provides a fruitful starting point for this by distinguishing between a system of bureaucratic commands and planning through socialist democracy. For the bureauracy's power lies in its ablity to circumscribe popular initiative and by so doing shape society in accordance with its own priorities.

This planning-from-above is necessarily a one-way system which, by choking off all feedback from below, precludes a continuous correction process. In this it differs from socialist planning which aims to bring into ex ante alignment production decisions with consumer demands.

Such a free association of immediate producers would effectively invoke a system of production to order. But this presupposes the fusion of economic and political power within the democratic self-governing organs of society. It is otherwise inconceivable.

The Bolshevik revolution and its soviet institutions represented the first tentative, historical steps in that direction. Because of the cultural backwardness of revolutionary Russia, labouring tragically without the fraternal assistance of a revolutionary society to its west, workers' power came to be ever more mediated through a party Devolution to There land these bureaucratic ranks — ranks whose a new ruling class. revolutionary zeal was thinned at once both by civil-war losses and their replacement with careerist intellectuals imbued with the ideals of the old society.

The revolution was therefore borne with a fatal susceptibility. When revolutionary authority was filtered through a bureaucratic sieve, the potential existed to skim so much political power from the working class as to effectively disenfranchise it. The Stalinist counterrevolution realised this potential, but not before exacting an ocean of blood.

And because revolutionary authority consists in the fusion of political with economic power, the political disenfranchisement of the working class was at the same time its economic expropriation. Class society - albeit in a historically unique mode — was forcibly reintroduced. Or more precisely, the Bolshevik attempt at class abolition was subverted and a new form of class exploitation created.

Corresponding to this system of "bureaucratic collectivism" is a specific class dynamic. Production maximisation conflicts with the conditions of exploitation because, as was stated, feedback is lacking. Planning takes the form of ukase, while plan fulfillment becomes a shell game.

As a result disproportionalities cannot be detected until large, multiple bottlenecks jam up the system. But the rate at which the economy can grow is critically dependent, in the final analysis, upon the mass of surplus-labour which can be productively reapplied. Without an effective feedback system, bureaucratic planning lacks the sensitivity to anticipate and locate potential distruptions.

Offsetting this requires an enormous reserve ot spare parts, inventories, intermediate goods and semi-finished products, in shorta colossal tie-up of necessary labour in social overhead before an hour of surplus-labour can actually be expended. This is reflected in the hypertrophic growth of the producer goods sector.

Bourgeois economists attribute this to some misguided ideological attachment to Marxian theory, while the "state capitalist" school fancies itself to have discovered the dynamic of capital accumulation at play. Both conceptions are nonsense. The former because it attributes the inner logic of bureaucratic collectivism to an ideological quirk, the latter because the resemblance is purely superficial.

Accumulation under capitalism, it is true, necessitates an increase in capital-intensity or the organic composition of capital. Capitalists find it profitable to invest ever greater amounts of value in new, labour-saving technology as long as the savings in labour costs exceed the additional expenditure of constant capital. This occurs both to obtain the temporary monopoly profits of the innovator or to preserve the value of the capital already invested by meeting the innovator's challenge.

But the key point is this. The increase in the organic composition of value is the way in which increased productivity expresses itself under capitalism. Its result is the shortening of the necessary part of the working day and the increase of surplus-labour.

The increase in the "capital intensity" (for lack of a more appropriate term) under bureaucratic collectivism bears no necessary correlation to productivity gains. It has little to do with the investment in more expensive technological improvements.

On the contrary, the mere multiplication of production spheres, even simple expanded reproduction, multiplies the points of potential disruption. For even this process to proceed smoothly requires an increase in the offsettng 'capital" reserves per hour of productive labour worked.

This furthermore means that every actual percentage increase in productivity that does occur results in a smaller increment in final output than would be the case under capitalism, owing to the difference held as reserves.

Multiply this problem by the substandard, even unusable, quality of much of the output, as well as the lgr economically exhausting demands of the arms race, and the enormous potential for stagnation becomes readily apparent.

The bureaucracy has historically sought indemnification of this through increases in the intensity of labour and in the length of the collective working year. But bad housing, shoddy consumer goods and inadequate living conditions place definite limits on the productivity of the working class.

Under Gorbachev, piece work and incentive pay — throwbacks to the Stalin era — are again the order of the day. Yet as the bureaucrats are well aware, without a dramatic improvement in the welfare of the working class such proposals have meagre potential.

To this end limited openings for private initiative in personal services, and agriculture as well as major steps to economise on labour-time and producer goods through the employment of market rationing are being undertaken. Managers are being retrained to shed their "bureaucratic mentalities" and read market signals so that they can respond rapidly to a coherent set of prices. Workers are being asked to submit to the whip of unemployment - and this without the elementary leagal and welfare provisions which are in place under modern capitalism - for the promise of better living standards.

How far this can proceed without challenging the supremacy of the Party in economic and social life is as yet unknown. The experiments in Eastern Europe represent so many national laboratories to test the limits of reform. For this reason they will be allowed to continue under microscopic scrutiny in advance of the USSR.

This has already opened an opportunity not only for the restoration of capitalism, but also for revolutionary working class upheavals. Bureaucratic collectivism is walking a tightrope. For this reason I would rephrase Stan Crooke's question.

The issue is not whether the class aspirations of the bureaucracy are attainable, but whether its class hegemony is sustainable. lite eis per peten

Scan page 9

Wednesday 22 February Adam Keller tour meeting: 'The struggle for Palestinian-israeli peace' , Brighton Thursday 23 February. Balsall Heath/Sparkhill Against tr Poll Tax. Speakers include Cate phy. St Paul's School Hall, 7.00 Contact the campaign c/o 448 Stratford Rd, Birmingham Thursday 23 February York SO meeting: 'South Africa: a workers' party!!. Speaker Tom Rigby. York University SU, 1.15

----- pull-quotes -----

characterised as a ruling class. If I understand his argument cor-

ACTIMISTS DIARY

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 390

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →