Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The class struggle in Parliament Parliament

Socialist Organiser no. 390, 22 February 1989 · scan p. 7 · about 1,588 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

Lenin argued for the Bolsheviks to work inside the Duma istakes. We were a group of sung people who did not know ow to organise a political party. stead of working together with ade unions we went into cabinet ghts against the older group that tas around Lipski, and it took a lot f time before we realised we eren't doing anything.

Now we bring together people ho are active, and we have a real ossibility to do something. Our eak point is that we have not got a rogramme.

We are now the biggest enemy of ther opposition groups, and will e in the future — especially if they ly we are on the left but they use peral arguments and want a comromise with the totalitarian stem, if they talk about getting cher and richer without speaking pout the poorest levels of society. They start to forget their big une who helped them to exist on the ublic level. That big uncle is the ade union Solidarnosc. They want • use that big uncle to get some ower and then they can make a big urn and fight against the union. Working alongside trade nionists, fighting for workers' emands together, we can build an ternative power to those liberals ho have become stronger over the st months.

People know very well what the ammunists call real socialism. hey also know capitalism from lovies and travel to the West. Of purse they prefer capitalism, ecause they see people live better tere than they do here.

That does not mean, that when they reach that world, and maybe they will live in better houses than now and have more money, they won't see the distance between the best houses and their better houses may be bigger than before. They will realise that they are again nobody - in another system.

Probably the whole of society will go to the right and then go back to the left. I think the best way is to make a mixture of the two systems - a mixture of the socialist system, taking care of poor people and so on, and the Western free-market system. In the West, capitalism started with children and old people working for 16 hours a day and became richer and richer over the years. We have not got the time to do that, and we cannot go back to the 19th century.

The structure of modern factories are completely different, so that when we change the system we will stop building big monpolies and rather atomise the structure into small pieces, going back to the mixture of capitalism and socialism, the beginnings of which we had before the Second World War, when there was a strong trade union movement and a strong PPS and they worked together.

There is a big problem with our factories. Most of our factories produce emptiness, which means 90% should just be closed. But who owns those factories? Who will close them? The most powerful people in Poland are the working class, a 19th century-type working class that no longer exists in the West. Eric Heffer MP reviews 'Bolsheviks in introduction by Tony Cliff. (Bookmarks, €5.95)

first read this book many years ago, and it is as interesting as ever. The introduction by Tony cil is, however, a travesty.

I am sorry to say this because I have always felt a liking for Tony Cliff, but his distortion of my own political position in his introduction of the book is unforgiveable. For example, he writes on page 11 that, "If, for a left Labour MP like Heffer, the struggle in Parliament appears as all important, whilst the class struggle of workers merits only a footnote, for right-wing Labour leaders the industrial struggle appears nonsense, and if on a large scale, may impede electoral success."

At no time have I ever said that the struggle in Parliament was all important. I said and argued in my book "The Class Struggle in Parliament' that the fight and struggle in Parliament were reflections of the class struggle outside. If the struggle outside was really tough, strong and widespread, then the struggle in Parliament would more vigorous, because it would force the fainthearts to make a more determined stand.

I was, in fact, in the book, writing about Parliament. That was where I was and it was there that I helped co-ordinate the attack from the Front Bench against the Tories' legislation and before that, the right-wing of the Labour Party and those like Barbara Castle and Harold Wilson who, by 'In Place of Strife', had helped pave the way for the Tory legislation. That is all explained in my book, but it is clear that Cliff only wants to quote that out of context) which helps his case.

In any case, I think it is ridiculous for Cliff to compare my book with Badayev's. There is no comparison. The situation was quite different and Britain under Wilson, or Heath for that matter, was very different from the situation under the Czar.

Unlike Cliff, I spent years of my life on the shopfloor, in the shipyards and on large construction sites. I was involved in, and helped lead, huge strikes involving many thousands of workers.

To me strikes were not and never have been academic questions. They are real, they are the true struggle of the workers and a great deal of suffering of varying kinds takes place.

To sit in the ivory tower of the SWP is somewhat different to the actual experience of the struggle at the grass roots.

Cliff visited my home and stayed with me when I was on the shopfloor and he knows I was never tied to the Parliamentary concept. In fact I had to be persuaded to stand for Parliament.

I entered Parliament only because the workers in the Labour Party and trade unions wanted me to do so, not because I was looking for opportunistic preferment. In fact some of those in the SWP earned more in a day as bourgeois journalists, etc. than I earned in a monI have always regarded and continue to regard the industrial and political struggle outside Parliament as the real struggle. Parliamentary struggle has only ever been a reflection of that struggle.

Certainly, Labour governments can and do bring in legislation that benefits workers. Legislation for example, which today is being destroyed by the Tory government on behalf of the capitalist class.

My experience, for what it is worth, is that when the struggle outside Parliament heightens the consciousness of workers, that is reflected in votes for the Labour Party at local and general elections. When the struggle outside Parliament is quiescent, then the votes go down. Recent experience has shown that in places like Liverpool, the coalfields and Scotland. The votes increased because of the workers struggles in such areas.

With regard to Badayev's book itself, one has to remember the historical circumstances under which it was written. Russia under the Czar was not at any time like Britain under the bourgeois democracy of Lloyd George, Disraeli or Gladstone. The democratic right to have elections, votes for the workers, constituencies or more or less equal size, and payment of MPs, had been part of the working class struggle, but such rights had not been really established in Czarist Russia.

As Badayev says on page 32, *The electoral law, passed by the government prior to the elections of the First Duma, was so drafted as to secure a majority for the bourgeoisie and the landlords. The voting was not direct but by a system of stages." Yet despite this fact, the First and Second Dumas despite its deeply anti-democratic nature had majorities against ment.

Badayev says: *After the dissolution of the Second Duma on 3rd June 1907, a new electoral law was passed which still further curtailed the suffrage, and excluded large groups of the population. Special attention was paid to the workers and the number of workers' curias was greatly reduced."

With regard to the work of the Social-Democratic faction in the Fourth Duma, it is interesting to note, despite the fact that the Bolsheviks had a revolutionary position and the Tribunites and Campaign Groupers have basically a reformist position, just how similar they were in their activities.

The Bolsheviks held "surgeries' and meetings with trade unionists and workers involved in strikes and various other struggles. I found all that absolutely fascinating. I read the book before going to Parliament, and having been in Parliament for 24 years, it makes even more interesting reading.

One of the most interesting parts of the book is that concerned with the role of Malinovsky, who was found to be a police spy. He was, however, a good speaker. Badayev says: "Malinovsky's oratorical powers made him one of the frequent speakers of our faction. But a careful analysis of his speeches reveals the fact that the blunt revolutionary content characteristic of the speeches of our workers' deputies was absent." How that could be said for some of the most glib speakers in the Labour Group in the House of Commons!

This is a book which should be read by all left-wing Labour MPs. But it must be read critically and in the historical context. To translate a situation automatically to a situation in Britain is wrong, even though a great deal of what is said in the book is applicable under both circumstances.

----- pull-quotes -----

the Tsarist Duma', by A.Y. Badayev, with an

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 390

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →