Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A policy, not just a person, at fault

Socialist Organiser no. 390, 22 February 1989 · scan p. 5 · about 1,424 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

W cament worsens by the innie Mandela's prediday. Members of her personal bodyguard, the Mandela United Football Club', have now been charged with abducting four young men from a church refuge in Soweto, assaulting all of them and murdering one of them, Stompie Seipei.

Stompie was found dead in a ditch, severely beaten and with his throat cut. One of the youths who later escaped says that Mrs Mandela herself presided over and participated in the beating.

Mrs Mandela denied any knowledge of the murder and claimed that the kids had been 'rescued' from the mission. Her explanation was that they had been engaged in 'homosexual practices' with the priests and that such behaviour was not acceptable 'in our culture?.

Two further members of her bodyguard have subsequently been charged with shooting dead a doctor who examined the kidnapped youths. Police investigations are going on into further killings and disappearances.

One of Winnie Mandela's team has recently been charged with the murder of another member who said in his defence that his fellow bodyguard had tried to slit his throat. He appeared in court with a knife wound across his neck from ear to ear.

While little credence can be put on the reports of the South African A shop steward from the giant South African metalworkers' union NUMSA explained how he and many other workers in Soweto see the Winnie Mandela scandal.

"It is rank and file trade unionists along with many progressive organisations who have taken the initiative to demand an apology for the way Winnie Mandela and her inside the_Soweto community equally bad.

It was not helped by her building a large and expensive mansion 'fit for a president' in Soweto. Things came to a head when school students destroyed her original home in revenge for the rape of a fellow student by members of her retinue.

Now the United Democratic Front (the half-legal pro-ANC mass organisation), the Congress of South African Trade Unions, the Weekly Mail (a left liberal, generally pro-ANC newspaper) and Mrs Mandela's own lawyer (her main contact with Nelson) have all disassociated themselves from her.

Oliver Tambo, the president of the ANC - strangely out of line with the response inside the country - has reiterated his support for Mrs Mandela.

What does all this mean?

First, it is important to discover the truth. We cannot trust the apartheid courts, not least because most black people would refuse to testify on behalf of the apartheid government. What is needed, therefore, is an inquiry by the democratic movement into what was done and how the situation got so out of hand.

Second, I think it is important not to turn Mrs Mandela into a scapegoat for what went wrong with the struggle for people's power' in 1984-5.

The ANC raised such slogans as "make the townships ungovernable' , and no education before liberation'. . The aim was to create such chaos and mayhem as would force the government to negotiate with the ANC.

But who were the victims of the chaos? As the left wing academic journal Work in Progress' put it at ry needed supporters have handled the situation. People are seeking a democratic inquiry into the allegations against her.

"Enough evidence exists fo all progressive organisations to have distanced themselves from her.

"It is expected that she will revert to using her maiden name in order not to harm name of Mandela. Winnie Mandela the time: "Undisciplined comrades, often acting with no organisational basis or mandate, have divided communities, setting workers against the unemployed, children against parents, trade unions against community groups.

"Some of the rent boycotts have been enforced with a high degree of anti-democratic authoritarianism. The youth have often acted without the organisations structure necessary for democratic decision making, and without adequate mandate or consultation. Recourse to 'discipline' - 'necklacings" beatings and other punishments.has come too easily to a group which often lacks a mandate to act on behalf of a constituency."

Mrs Mandela was a vocal champion of the 'necklace' and of the rather injudicious use of 'people's justice' - She delivered political statements without any mandate and 'called upon the people' to follow certain lines of struggle with little concern for the norms of democratic decision making. Her elitism certainly alienated many trade unionists accustomed to the ideas of accountability and participation.

When she spoke at a number of trade union congresses advocating adoption of the Freedom Charter (the ANC's basic programme) and at the miners' conference advocating a united front between the mine owners and the mineworkers against the state, many workers were resentful.

Mrs Mandela was only following the policies of the AN at the time. She is a strong and articulate woman, the wife of the man whom the ANC has elevated as the personification of the struggle, and she seemed by then to have won a certain level of immunity from police repression. Of course she was a particularly important representative for the ANC inside the country.

Today the failure of the ANC's strategy is clear enough and so is a certain degree of popular discontent with the excesses to which it led. But ANC policy has remained in a state of limbo, offering no formal change of direction and no formal assessment of what went wrong.

Now a number of kites are being flown about the need for the democratic movement to reconsider its whole approach to non-participation and 'people's power' Archie Gumede and a number of intellectuals have floated the need for participating in elections.

The South African Communist Party, which is highly influential within the ANC, is under pressure to adapt to the new spirit of reform and detente in Russia and to Gorbachev's diplomacy in Southern Africa.

So the UDF's condemnation of Winnie Mandela may signal the beginnings of a change in line by the ANC's CP axis, with some individuals trailing behind the new consensus. A critical honest review of the mistakes made in the past is certainly welcome, but it will only shortcut this much-needed process if the woman previously named 'mother of the nation' is turned into the individual embodiment of the sins of the past.

or us here in the solidarity novement the tal of Mrs Mandel. should be a timely reminder of where uncritical admiration of leaders may lead, particularly when these leaders are unelected. Our solidarity with the liberation movement should not blind us to the fact that working class people in Southern Africa have the same interest in, and need for, democracy as do working class people here.

Democracy is not a 'western concept' — it is a universal requirement of the working class. workers here, at home, and internationally that we will win this trial and get the liberation of workers from exploitation and oppression.

"An injury to one is an injury to all!

As you may have heard, we have been released on bail under very strict, severe and restrictive bail conditions.

It is difficult and impossible to do the union work because of these conditions. We cannot attend any meetings, we cannot be with more than 10 people at a time. We can't talk to the press. We must remain in the Witwatersrand area.

We are not allowed to go to Alexandra township, our residential area, and we must report daily to the police.

I remain yours in the struggle."

Moses Mayekiso General Secretary National Union of Metalworkers of South Africa Moses Mayekiso, general secretary of the giant South Afrien metal workers union, NUMSA, is now on trial for treason for organising working class people into street committees in the black township of Alexandra, near Johannesburg.

To raise support for Moses and the other four defendants on trial alongside him, Khola Mayekiso (Moses' wife) is to visit the UK next month.

Khola Mayekiso's tour is organised jointly by NUMSA and the TUC. 1 Regional TUC's will be organising events on the following timetable:

5 March: arrive London 6 March: address TUC international committee 6-10 March: TUC North West region including. TUC Women's Conference (Blackpool, 9 March)

11-13 March: Glasgow (anmd STUC international forum, Edinburgh)

14-15 March: Newcastle upon Tyne. TUC North region 16-17 March: TUC Yorkshire and Humberside region 18-19 March: TUC Midlands region 20-21. March: TUC Midlands region 22-23 March: TUC East region 24-25 March: NUT Conference 27-29 March: Wales and South West TUC regions 29 March-1 April: London (South Eastern region TUC)

2 April: Depart for USA Ireland

----- pull-quotes -----

police, Mrs Mandela's reputation Democratic inq

Khola Mayekiso tours Britain

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 390

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →