Was Trotsky for a Jewish state?
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-02-22Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
In Socialist Organiser No.388 9 February 1989) John O' Mahony says "At the end of his life he (Trotsky) believed that the persecution of the Jews and the effect of that persecution on the consciousness of the Jewish people had made the creation of some sort of Jewish state an inescapable necessity.
"He did not support the Palestine programme of the Zionists, or anyway not as conceived by them. But - his train of thought is clear — he was for a Jewish state nonetheless"
The quotes given for Trotsky's views are from 1937. However, Trotsky's final remarks on the subject were given in 1940. It is my contention that at the end of his life Trotsky did not favour a Jewish Trotsky state.
In a discussion between Sam Gordan and Trotsky on 15 June 1940 the following conversation took place.
Gordon: What tactical approach would you suggest (towards Jewish workers in the USA).
Trotsky: That is another thing. I am not informed well about that phase. The first thing is to give them a perspective, critcise all the past, the democratic tendency, etc. To pose for them that the socialist revolution is the only realistic solution of the Jewish question.
If the Jewish workers and peasants asked for an independent state, good - but they didn't get it under Great Britain. But if they want it, the proletariat will give it.
We are not in favour (my emphasis) but only the victorious working class can give it to them. (Discussions with Trotsky in Writings of Lena Trotsky 1939-40, Pathfinder Press, 1973 page 287).
Obviously Trotsky did not have a dogmatic view on the question of a Jewish state, as a reading of all his words on the subject will show, but John O'Mahony was clearly wrong not to provide SO readers with Trotsky's 1940 position.
Barry Buitekant, London ES crossed over the species barrier It has done in goats and dogs).
However, to say that BSE "can go on to induce dementia in people" is to state as a fact something for which there is no evidence whatsoever. It is to invite our readers to make utter fools of themselves.
It is merely a possibility that BSE can be transmitted to humans. The evidence, if anything, is against it, since scrapie does not appear to have infected people throughout thousands of years of sheep-eating.
The possibility should be