Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Satanic Verses, deep blue seà

Socialist Organiser no. 390, 22 February 1989 · scan pp. 2–3 · about 2,258 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

-GANIG Last Saturday I briefly felt a strange and disturbing emotion. I found myself agreeing with an editorial in the Sun.

Well, not exactly agreeing, perhaps: more generally I liked the spirit and tone of what I read.

The editorial, of course, was about Salman Rushdie and the Ayatollah's death threat.

The gist of it was along the lines of, What the hell are Geoffrey Howe and the British government doing pussyfooting around while a bunch of medieval crackpots threaten the life of a British citizen who's committed no crime beyond writing a controversial novel?"

Yes, i Take the gloves off. Show the bastards what we're made of.

Never mind the fact that the Sun itself roundly abused Rushdie when the Satanic Verses first appeared. Never mind the fact that these champions of free speech called for the banning of 'Death on the Rock"; never mind the editorial's evocation of Churchillian patriotism; never mind (for a brief moment anyway) the barbarity of the Sun's proposed course of action: "Tell the mad mullah, touch Rushdie and face our bomber.

Sanity did return, thankfully, and memories of Reagan's murderous raid on Libya soon eclipsed the attractions of gun-boat diplomacy, but I'm sure I have not been the only good leftie to experience such perverse reactions as this bizarre affair has unfolded.

Perhaps even some of those who cheered on the Iranian side in the genocidal Gulf War are now having second thoughts about Khomeini's 'antiimperialism' The paradoxes of the situation were not lost on Peregrine Worsthorne, the high-Tory editor of the Sunday Telegraph. Behind his usual mask of solemnity, Worsthorne could scarcely contain his glee. In a way I don't blame him: he has a certain logic on his side.

*What is sad...is that it should take a threat to one of their own for Britain's liberals to start taking terrorism seriously...so long as terrorists killed noncreative people, their eloquent voices were always raised, counselling governments to turn the other cheek. Only when blood-curdling threats are made to an intellectual do they start losing their cool and start calling for retaliation in kind."

Worsthorne rather spoils his case with that last bit. As far as I know, no *liberal intellectuals' have yet called for "retaliation in kind', (unless you consider the Sun a liberal intellectual" organ).

But, still, he has a point. There is a certain element on the left that tends to come over as just a trifle indifferent to ordinary civilian casualties of what are generally termed terrorist" attacks. That some of the same people now hold up their hands in horror at the threat to an individual leftist intellectual does

Scan page 3

For nine years, the army and air force of the bureaucratic ruling class of the Soviet Union waged a brutal war of conquest against the peoples of Afghanistan.

They napalmed villages and burned the crops in the fields. They devastated the countryside, wrecked the primitive economy, and drove as many as five million refugees — one quarter of the entire population - over the borders into Pakistan and Iran.

Yet they never even came near conquering the people. Western military experts calculated that a full conquest would have taken at least three times as many as the 100,000 soldiers and flyers whom the Brezhnev regime committed to Afghanistan. They would have had to slaughter a large part of the population and terrorise the rest.

Unprepared for an imperialist operation on that scale, the Kremlin made murderous but inconclusive war for a decade. Now it withdraws its army and air force.

Why? Essentially because Gorbachev wants to concentrate resources for the drive to modernise the economy. The new ruler, the reforming Tsar, wants to liquidate the costly blunder made by his predecessor, and he can even admit that it was a 'mistake'. Pulling out the USSR's army is also a useful gesture in USSR.US dinlomacy.

But the withdrawal of the Russian army leaves the native Afghan forces of progress and modernisation in dire straits.

Those fighting the Russian occupation were always backwardlooking and reactionary. The fact that the big majority of the people of Afghanistan are medieval in their thinking does not cancel out their right to self-determination. It could not justify the Russian invasion, nor make progressive the When the Russians invaded Afghanistan in December 1979, almost every 'orthodox Trotskyist' group in the world supported them, or at any rate refused to call for their withdrawal.

Some were wildly enthusiastic for a while. A big part of the so-called 'United Secretariat of the Fourth International, grouped around the Socialist Workers' Party of the USA, hailed the Russians as going to the aid of the Afghan revolution '. Even those who had a more balanced view refused to call for the Russians to get out.

Over the years most of the Trotskyists changed their minds and started to call for withdrawal. Militant was an exception. Socialist Organiser was very much in the minority when it insisted at the beginning that socialists should call for immediate Russian withdrawal.

The tragedy, as yet unfinished, that engulfed Afghanistan, shows who was right; and it would have been a worse tragedy, in its human consequences, if The emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction of sex or race"

Karl Marx Socialist Organiser PO Box 823, London 4NA. Phone 01-639 7965. date for reports: first Monday or by phone Monday evening. bureaucratic state-monopoly system they fought to establish. When the overwhelming majority of the people of Afghanistan fought to drive out the Russians, they were entitled to the support of all socialists.

Now that the Russians have gone, the question is posed differently. The question now is what attitude we take to a civil war in Afghanistan — a civil war which is likely to be in large part a war between the cities and the countryside, between the men and women of the towns, with their relatively modern outlook, and the viciously reactionary and medieval forces which have been the main organisers of Afghan resistance to Russian imperialism. The question has to be posed like that, because no working class exists Afghanistan strong enough to transform the situation.

A similar civil war predated the Russian invasion. It was subsumed into the conflict between the USSR and the people of Afghanistan.

In April 1978, the Afghan Stalinist party, the PDP, took power by way of a military coup. The Afghan airforce and army officers who formed the core of the PDP believed that it was their mission to drag Afghanistan into the twentieth century.

Army officers in many underdeveloped countries have undertaken the same mission. The difference in Afghanistan was that the air force and army officers had, from the mid '50s, been trained and educated in the USSR. They took the USSR as their model of development, The PDP was essentially an urban middle-class movement -and a movement of a middle class trying to turn itself into a statemonopoly bureaucracy. It could make a coup; lacking mass support, it could not make a revolution.

When the government passed progressive laws against usurers and landlords and in favour of women, the landlords and the Muslim priests roused a large part of the the Russians had decided to commit themselves to full-scale conquest.

Those, like Militant, who supported the Kussians need to give an honest account of themselves on this question. They looked to the Russian bureaucracy to 'make a revolution' — against the entire population of Afghanistan. Logically they should now denounce the Russians for betraying that revolution. So far they have tried to square their circle by claiming that the Russians are withdrawing from Afghanistan victorious — but how long can that delusion last?

Militant won't give an account of themselves. The reason why they repeat the self-same errors over and over again is that they don't want to learn.

Delusions are more comfortable than the bitter truth. Nevertheless, Trotsky was right when he wrote: "To face reality squarely; not to seek the line of least resistance; to call things by their right names; to speak the truth to the masses, no matter how bitter it may be; to be true in little things as in big ones... these are the rules" of Marxist revolutionaries, ypesetting: Upstream Ltd (TU). 01-358 1344.

Published by Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

Printed by Press Link International (UK) Ltd (TU). Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office. Signed articles do not necessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser Women queue for bread in Kabul. civil war all women will be forced countryside against them. Similar things had happened in Europe at the time of the French Revolution, with the Catholic countryside roused against the Jacobin towns in Belgium and France — except that in Europe the forces of progress were strong, and in Afghanistan the Stalinist middle class was feeble.

The PDP regime responded with savage violence against the people of the countryside. The air force was dropping napalm on rebel villages within weeks of the coup.

In the subsequent 20 months the reactionary opposition to the regime grew and spread. At the same time the PDP tore itself apart in faction-fighting. By December 1979 the Russians became convinced that their client regime would be overthrown unless they intervened.

The Russians invaded, purged the PDP, and set out to conquer the country. They failed. Muslim reaction became much stronger. At the end the Russians had a grip only on the towns, and that an insecure one. They leave a native government in power which, though well-armed, is far weaker than its predecessor which the Russians replaced in December play jus compie Seipei may have been murdered by winnie Mandela's bodyguards. The South African government, which has killed, maimed, tortured and terrorised thousands upon thousands of black youth, must be cackling with glee.

Now these racists can play at being the lawgivers, the protectors of the weak, the guardians of impartial law and order, Over the weekend of 18-19 February the police picked up four members of the bodyguard. More arrests are likely. The South African police are making an elaborate show of proper proceedure. Racist politicians are talkIf the reactionaries to wear the veil 1979.

The Muslim reactionaries have been subjected for over a decade to the napalming war of the Russians and their Afghan allies. They have good reason to be vindictive. Largescale massacres of the townspeople are certain if the Mujahedeen conquer the cities.

One issue alone is sufficient to indicate that socialists should take sides in this horror, and tell us which side we should take: the position of women. In the towns some - middle-class - women have escaped the inhuman bondage decreed for women by Islamic fundamentalism. They will be slaughtered, and all women in Afghanistan thrown back to the Dark Ages, if the Mujahedeen win.

Before the Russian invasion - as we wrote in 1980 — socialists in Afghanistan would have had to give critical support to specific measures of the regime, though in no sense could they have supported the regime as such, It would have been necessary to fight for the class independence of the tiny working class; to fight to dismantle and destroy the state apparatus; to criticise and expose the brutal military-bureaucratic ing about how "black on black' violence shows that black people are somehow incapable of democratic self-rule.

But white minority rule in South Africa means: • The detention without trial of tens of thousands of people (including many small children). • The systematic and terrifying torture of thousands of detainees using electric shocks, beatings, suffocating, rape, ramming nails through testicles, sustained isolation ete etc. • The operation of Latin American style death-squads against political activists, striking people down across the globe from Port Elizabeth to Paris. • The occupation methods of the regime gas both counter-productive in relation to the reforms and expressive of the class character of the regime.

Socialists would have faced the repression of the one-party PDPArmy regime. But they would have directed their fire against the reaction; and in that sense only would have 'supported' the PDPArmy regime, while maintaining pontical and it possible military independence trom it and striving to overthrow it.

Now that the Russians have gone, the same basic arguments hold. The main enemy is the Muslim-landlord reaction.

Tragically, it looks very much as if the result of the decade of Russian occupation is to make certain the victory of the Islamic medievalists. The years of the Russian-conducted bloodbath are likely to be crowned by the slaughter of most of the people who form the elements of a modern society in Afghanistan.

There is little or nothing that socialists in the West can do about it - except understand the unfolding tragedy, and tell ourselves the truth about the why and how of it. the laying waste of whole areas, of neighbouring countries such as Angola and Mozambique. When invading South African soldiers cross the border into South Angola their officers traditionally tell them that "rape and pillage is the only way to deal with the locals." • The sponsoring of vicious groups of 'vigilantes' of "Witdoeke' -black collaborators and youngsters who terrify the workers in the townships on a scale which makes. the "Mandela United football team" look very petty indeed, Winnie Mandela and her bodyguards stand accused on two accounts. First, the killing of Stompie Seipei; and, second, giving the murderous apartheid state a chance to cover up its bloody record.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 390

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →