Brecht wasn't a Stalinist
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-02-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
In recent years SO has been in the forefront of a movement to debunk the various Stalinist mythologies which permeated the British left and labour movement - something not only very welcome but also long overdue.
It's a shame, therefore, that Mick Ackersley spoilt his very good article 'Joking about Nazism (SO 383, 5 January) with the oftrepeated, yet unsubstantiated, claim that the German dramatist and poet Bertolt Brecht was a "Stalinist' Perhaps Mick Ackersley could tell your readers (and me) where he gets this notion from?
Now I wouldn't suggest for a minute that Brecht's ideas about Stalin or the Soviet Union are a model of clear thinking and sharp political analysis. On the contrary, he is often confused and confusing. However I hardly think this makes him a Stalinist.
If someone who is an internationally acclaimed playwright (let's leave aside the poetry for a minute is labelled a Stalinist then it would follow, logically, that elements of this Stalinism would manifest itself in his/her plays. But where, for example, in "Mother Courage' "Galileo', "The Caucasian Chalk Circle', "Threepenny Opera', "The Resistable Rise of Arturo Ui can such traces be found? I don't know of any — does anyone else?
But perhaps Mick Ackersley has erected a Chinese Wall between the artist's work and his personal life a somewhat dubious separation at best). Brecht lived and worked in East Germany for about nine years — from his return in exile in 1947 to his death in 1956. In this time he received the Stalin Peace Price (1955) and wrote a much publicised letter supporting the government of Walter Ulbrecht on the occasion of the 17 June 1953 working class riots in Berlin.
The letter (as printed) was briet, merely stating: "I feel, it necessary to write to you and express my association with the SED (German Communist Party). Yours, Bertolt Brecht." Not as much publicity was given to later statements by Brecht where he drastically qualified his support for the SED:
"The SED has made mistakes which weigh heavily on a Socialist Party and have turned workers against it. I am not a member, but I respect many of its historic achievements..."
In a letter to an East German newspaper Brecht was also to speak of the workers' "justifiable discontent" and of "mistakes on all sides". Brecht, it seems, was concerned that the riots and disturbances would provide a pretext for fascist elements to re-assert themselves and he was also worried about the possibilities of Western intervention and another war.
Stalin died in March 1953 and Brecht wrote an obituary notice which was published in an East German cultural magazine. He said: "The hearts of all who are oppressed throughout the five continents, of all who have already found their freedom, of all who are fighting for world peace, must have missed a beat when they heard the news, Stalin is dead.
"He was the embodiment of their hopes. But the spiritual and material weapons he made are there, and so also is the teaching to make new ones."
Fulsome as this praise is, it has to be contrasted with the mountains of sycophantic drivel that accompanied the death of the Butcher of the Revolution. It is also noticeable that Brecht is not talking about his own feelings but what he perceives as the feelings of others.
Apart from this there are two references to Stalin in his whole body of poems, in one Stalin is described as " ...the great leader of the harvest" and in the other his name is coupled with Mao Tse Tung.
In his prose work 'Me-Ti or the Book of Changes' Stalin is both criticised and praised. In this work Stalin is given the name Ni-en which itself signifies "no" and in a passage on the Moscow Trials Brecht has this to say of Ni-en:
"...trying them without proof he harmed the people. He should have taught the people to insist on having proof, particularly from him, who is in general so useful."
There is of course much that could be said, both good and bad, about this kind of double-edged praise and criticism, but, as I've said before, it hardly makes Brecht a Stalinist.
Further evidence of Brecht's contradictory attitudes are evidenced by this account (from his close friend, the German literary critic and philosopher, Walter Benjamin):
*Brecht came over to my place to read me his Stalin poem, which is entitled "The Peasant to the Ox'. At first I did not get its meaning completely, and when a moment later the thought of Stalin passed through my head, I did not dare entertain it.
*This was more or less the effect Brecht intended, and he explained what he meant in the conversation which followed...he emphasised, among other things, the positive aspects of the poem. It was in fact a poem in honour of Stalin, who in his opinion has immense merit.
"But Stalin is not yet dead...He (Brecht) is following the writings of Trotsky. These prove that there exists a suspicion — a justifiable one - demanding a sceptical appraisal of Soviet affairs.
"Such scepticism is in the spirit of the Marxist classics. Should the suspicion prove correct one day, then it will become necessary io fight the regime and publicly."