A send-up of Reagan's America
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-02-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Bruce Willis doesn't hang around in "Die Hard" reviews 'Die Hard' f post-modernism means little more than a gratuitous mixing of styles, then Die Hard' is the ultimate postmodern movie.
Every conceivable movie genre has been thrown in - western, cops, thriller, romance, action, gore, disaster, war, comedy, yuppie nightmare, even a bit of TV sitcom.
Just as post-modern architecture throws out the orders behind the styles, making use of surface appearances only, this film junks the conventions. It's anarchic, chaotic, and thoroughly reprehensible.
Yet it has a crazy vitality. Despite all the gore, you come out cheering.
The plot goes beyond farfetched. New York cop John McClane comes out to Los Angeles to visit his estranged wife, Holly, for Christmas. She has become a megatycoon_ with a Japanese multinational.
When the firm's Christmas bash in its state-of-the-art skyscraper gets invaded by a band of well-organised crooks, only John stands between the hostages and certain McClane, played with considerable gusto by Bruce Willis, has more brawn than brain. He has to keep reminding himself to think. But he's game. Luckily.
The crooks are phenomenally well-organised, with an impressive weaponry arsenal, but they have one major drawback; they're Germans. As everyone knows, the Yanks beat them once before. Since McClane has little to fight this lot with, barring his gun and the desire of the scriptwriters to keep him alive, we're obviously meant to remember that.
Most of the crooks movie Germans, sadistic blonde robots. But the leader, Hans, is more interesting. His is the cool, planners brain behind the exercise. He's smart enough to know what the American police and state paranoia will be, and how best to take advantage of it.
To the American authorities, he figures, every gun-toting German will be a Baader-Meinhof extremist, so he plays on their fears. It's a sly, witty characterisation.
The building becomes the scene of a new type of guerilla war, mayhem in a high-rise. It's a new kind of jungle, with undergrowth of cables and wiring and alarms, and hideouts in litt shafts and fire stairwells.
As ever, it's hard to distinguish the enemy. Is it the bandits inside? Or the police, FBI and rescue crews outside? Their idea of saving the building is to lay siege to it and attack it, just as the Americans bombed cities in Vietnam to "save" them.
The cops outside can no longer act normally. They're all victims of TV stereotyping and Rambo movies. If they aren't "kicking ass" harder and faster than anyone else, they're terrified for their jobs.
The scene outside the building becomes a microcosm of America - masses of competing authorities, all trying to out-tough each other, but no-one's in charge.
The characters really have to work. This is value-for-money acting. Their being killed is no guarantee that they can relax over a Job well done. Like characters in "Dynasty', they have a better than even chance of coming back to life.
Alexander Godunov, who appears as a kind of relentless killing machine, survives an astonishing amount of punishment. He makes the Russian monk, Rasputin, look like a wimp. After all, Rasputin was only poisoned, shot and drowned. Peanuts!
Godunov is like the hopelessly aggressive knight in 'Monty Python and the Holy Grail'. Gushing blood from every artery, arms and legs cut off, the knight continued to harry his opponent, taunting him for cowardice.
But even Godunov pales before McClane. I've long suspected that Bruce Willis was thick skinned, but this film proves it. Not even machine gun bullets can penetrate that serene hide.
The film is terrifyingly, noisily, violent. I expected to leave the cinema drenched in blood. The gore explodes right in your face. The only quiet, thoughtful moments belong to Hans, and to Powell, the black copper on the beat who first realises something's wrong.
The movie is a prime example of overkill. The police "rescue teams" outside the building would be sufficient to wage a small war. No-one bothers to find out what the crooks really want. It's easier to kill them, as violently and messily as possible.
When the FBI finally wing their way by helicopter gunship to the top of the building, planning to "waste" a quarter of the hostages for propaganda value, you know that everything has got totally out of hand. It's a perfect send-up of the US's "big stick" foreign policy.
In this comedy-thriller, no-one with any sense of reality has a chance of being heard. Everyone else is trying to be John Wayne or Rambo, with predictably disastrous results. It's a cautionary tale.
This conversation took place in 1934 while Brecht was undergoing his first exile. I have been unable to find the poem *The Peasant and the ', it doesn't appear to be in his Collected Poems 1913-1956, edited by John Willet.
There is of course much more that could be said in defence of Brecht, his friendship with longstanding anti-Stalinists like Karl Korsch or his equally longstanding hatred of Moscow's most illustrious official scribe Georg Lukacs (who also wasn't a Stalinist, in my opınion.), his outspoken opposition to the policies of 'Socialist Realism', etc.
Certainly his action in 1953 was weak, contradictory and confused but must be seen in the context of a divided post-war Germany. This doesn't make it any more forgiveable but at least helps us to understand Brecht, which is a darn sight more than asinine labels like 'Stalinism' do!
Finally, just as a footnote, Brecht wasn't the scriptman for 'Hangmen Also Die'. He collaborated with an American writer, John Wexley, on the script, but due to various problems and disagreements, very little of Brecht's script actually remains in the film. The only film Brecht worked on which ever saw the light of day was his much earlier collaborative effort "Kuhle Wampe' made in 1932 just before he fled Germany.
Cunningham Sheffield