Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Ern Euro

Socialist Organiser no. 389, 16 February 1989 · scan p. 9 · Adam Novotny · about 1,675 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

9Я to qu ugoslavia's ruling party (the League of Communists of Yugoslavia, or LCY) has stayed in power for over 40 years, without the backing of either the Soviet Union or Sections of the western left used to talk as if somehow Yugoslavia was quite different from the other East European countries. Yugoslavia, they said had a enterprises are governed by workers' collectives.

Self-management meant something different to Yugoslav workers. The possibility of workers participating in management, let alone controlling it, was limited in two ways. Yugoslav workers have been controlled and atomised by the direct will of the ruling LCY bureaucracy and by the impersonal hand of 'market socialism' The LCY never really let power out of its own hands, throughout all the constant reforms of the constitution. The duplication of decision-making structures, and the division of the economy into eight autonomous regions, each with its own investment pattern, labour laws, environmental regulations and so on, has been incredibly wasteful. The cost of maintaining the huge army has been ruinous, but no Yugoslav Communist outside Slovenia would call for a reduction in the army's size or influence.

When Slovenian members of the League of Socialist Youth said last summer that the army was ready to intervene to stop democratisation in Slovenia, they were arrested. The army bureaucracy is the only real all-Yugoslav institution. Its Serbian trained officers have their own Communist Party organisation and newspaper. People are increasingly talking about possible martial law if the political and economic situation deteriorates.

The second reason selfmanagement is an illusion is economic. The system is supposed to work in a market economy. To earn any money, enterprises must compete with each other, and increasingly with foreign and multinational firms.

Yugoslav workers have faced the same realities as in worker cooperatives in the west - exploit yourself by working long hours, ignoring health, safety and insurance regulations, accept low take home benefits, and try to make profits like any capitalist.

Workers' enterprises in the north of Yugoslavia make more money if they contract out dirty and labour intensive work to 'workermanagers' in the underdeveloped south. The real profits are made by the self-managing collectives of specialists (lawyers, marketing people, accountants) and by the managers the workers have to "employ' if their enterprise is going to compete at all.

Not surprisingly, Yugoslav sociologists have 'discovered' time and again that workers divide society into 'us' and 'them'. They see self-management councils as a waste of time at best, and more usually as management's way of forcing up productivity:

What workers lack in the seltmanagement system 1s any representation of their collective interests as workers, as producers of the wealth of the country. There are hundreds of strikes against management and the government in Yugoslavia, but without a genuine trade union to represent them and link their grievances, workers will only improve their conditions in a piecemeal way.

Being more integrated worla economy man une rest of Hastern Europe, Yugoslavia has suffered much more from recession. The country would have gone bankrupt a long time ago if it wasn't for the money sent back by the hundreds of thousands of Yugoslavs doing the shit jobs in Germany, Austria, Holland and Sweden and the millions of tourists spending their hard currency in Dubrovnik, Porec and Bled.

Regional and national differences are magnified by the structure of the economy and the political system, with trade unions and even the Communist Party split into eight - for the six republics and the two (until recently) autonomous provinces of Serbia.

The recession has widened the gap between the north of the country, oriented to the markets of Austria and Italy and the southern republics and inland Serbia, where the state plays a similar role to the rest of Eastern Europe, subsidising huge outputs of low quality goods, and keeping the price of food, alcohol and apartments well below their market price.

As the north feels the need to reinvest in its own industry to weather the recession and keep up with its capitalist neighbours, there is a growing public resentment of the 'lazy' Moslem southerners. In Croatia in the '70s and in Slovenia today, economists and journalists suggest that the nation should cut itself adrift from Yugoslav stagnation and find a new home in western Europe.

In Serbia and Montenegro (where many people are ethnically Serbian) the nationalist distraction from economic decline and triple-digit inflation is fueled by the charismatic communist leader Slobodan Milosevic. He wants a re-centralised economy and political domination by the traditionalist Serbian Communists led by himself. His condemnation of inefficiency, bureaucracy and the selfishness of the north strikes a chord with many ordinary Serbians.

The Serbian nationalists have also stirred up traditional racist attitudes to the Moslem Albanians of southern Serbia, in the autonomous province of Kosovo. Even the liberal dissidents and university anarchists' of the '70s have accepted and repeat the claims of mass rapes of Serbian women, murder of Christian babies and so Millions dinars prestige projects in Kosovo, and in lining the pockets of Serbian and Albanian bureaucrats. People are, however, encouraged to blame Kosovo's continued underdevelopment on the Kosovars themselves and on the Albanian mafia which lies behind the harassment of Serbs in Kosovo. Kosovo Albanians working outside Kosovo report increasing racial attacks, but the press controlled by the eight Communist leagues, says nothing.

Most Albanian workers want to stay in Yugoslavia, but with the same rights as other nationalities. With the exception of the left in Slovenia, they find most Yugloslavs hostile to them. Caught between economic underdevelopment, Slav racism and super-Stalinist Albania across the border, the situation of Kosovo's people is set to get worse.

Political developments are most pronounced in Slovenia - rich by Yugoslav standards but much poorer than neighbouring Austria and Italy. The league of Slovenian Communists has a programme of economic integration with western Europe, reduced ties with the rest of Yugoslavia, and limited political pluralism. The Slovenian Communists bank on maintaining power A SOI 1i La as nationalists, as good managers.

By allowing some political pluralism they can react to discontent, without allowing a real opposition. Their plan can only work if they can produce economic prosperity compared to the rest of the country.

They have little room for manoeuvre. Opposition parties have already formed. There is a private farmers' party (and a young farmers youth organisation), and a deeper_economic integration with the west.

There is also a new left Party, mainly supported by 'alternative' circles of students and young workers and the Youth League magazine Mladina.

Finally there is the League of Slovenian Communists wth partial support from the trade union structures. A recent opinion poll in Mladina suggested that the Slovenian Communist Party would get only 10 per cent of votes in a free republican election. The army is waiting to see if the political gamble and economic restructuring will pay off.

A Socialis Organiser pamphlet.

Available from PO Box SE15 4NA, for 80p plus. 13p postage Hmans have been undreds of East Gerjailed after secret trials.

In January of last year, a number of people were arrested after attempting to join an official demonstration in memory of the German revolutionaries Rosa Luxemburg and Karl Liebknecht. For carrying placards bearing Rosa Luxemburg's words "Freedom is always the freedom of those who think differently", they were charged under Articles 215 and 217 and sentenced to six months in prison.

About 100 prisoners of conscience in East Germany are adopted by Amnesty International each Yast. Given the sweeping nature of East German legislation and the way in which the authorities interpret it, this figure probably represents only a fraction of the fuli number.

A new Amnesty International report 'Sweeping Laws, Secret. Justice', highlights some of the cases and the laws that make them possible.

Article 27 of the country's constitution declares: "There can be no freedom in an society for anti-socialist (as defined by the Government) agitation and propaganda, especially that practised by the imperialist enemy...It is a Constitutional duty to oppose all such attempts decisively. This includes the spreading of anti-socialist ideology which is practised in the name of 'freedom', ' democracy' or 'humanity'.

Contact with foreign organisations for individuals by East German citizens can be a particularly hazardous affair. Passing on information to such bodies "to the disadvantage of the interests of the GDR can be punished by two to twelve years imprisonment, declares Article 99 of the GDR Penal Code.

In 1986, Mike Wolf was sentenced to 2½ years imprisonment, after being tried in secret for phoning a friend in West Berlin and telling her he had submitted an application to emigrate. Three years earlier Wolfgang Hartmann had been. sentenced to 3½ years imprisonment after writing to the West German authorities and his sister (who lives in West Germany about his plans to emigrate.

Wolfgang Hartmann was charged under Article 214 as well as 99. After his initial application to emigrate was rejected, he protested in public with a placard bearing the words Human Rights - Also for the GDR'.

In 1983, Ines Meichsner was arrested and charged with "rowdiness" under Article 215, for demonstrating with a lighted candle next to a monument to Karl Marx. The prosecution alleged that her action constituted a "gross annoyance to the public". She was sentenced to ten months imprisonment.

Heavy penalfies are also enforced on East German citizens who attempt to cross the borders without permission. Individuals attempting to do so face a spell of two years in prison. Attempts to cross borders with others is an "aggravated" offence and punishable by up to eight years in prison.

In March of last year Heiko Grund and Carola Hoffman were arrested in Hungary, returned to East Germany and sentenced to two years imprisonment, for attempting to emigrate illegally to Austria.

"Sweeping Laws, Secret Justice' available from Easton 8DJ.

----- pull-quotes -----

democratic system - its self- management system, in which most

REFOR OR IN EASTERN EUROPE? LIST ORGANISER PAMPHLET 80 PENCI

Social Democratic party, popular with the intelligentsia, which wants

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 389

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →