Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A bad market is not no market S that the Eastern Bloc bureau

Socialist Organiser no. 389, 16 February 1989 · scan p. 4 · about 700 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

Saturday 25 & Sunday 26 February enary with Martha Osamor, SWAPO representative, Bernadette McAliskey with Martha Osamor, SWAPO representative, Bernadette Betty Heathfield and other labour movement speakers Vorkshops on the themes of: Women & the Family; Welfare State;

and Work; Internationalism; Education & Culture Sunday: Launching Women for Socialism Discussions on: producing a newsletter; developing regional and national on: producing a newsletter; developing regional and details contact: Ruth Clarke, 7 For more social, help with Saturday: Starts 10.45am structures; and much more Cumberland Park, London W3 6SY tan Crooke (SO 386) argued cracies are not ruling classes, because their societies have no economic regulator, nothing but waste and chaos.

Clive Bradley (SO 388) replied that bad planning is not the same as no planning; and he's right, I think. I would add that bad markets are not the same as no markets.

Stan declared that *there is no market in these states" . Untrue! Workers in the Eastern Bloc sell their labour power, receive wages, and buy what they consume. They are not slaves, serfs, sharecroppers, or peons, but wage-workers.

Yes, the prices of labour power and consumer goods are set by the state, and often do not equate supply and demand.

Sorry!

would just like ti correct an inaccuracy in n ly report in last week's Socialist Organiser about the Socialist Teachers Alliance.

This mistake may give a misleading and unhelpful message to readers. It was not my intention to (i) imply that the IMG strand inside the ST4 have deliberațely failBut the Western academic economists who spend their lives studying markets would be startled indeed by the idea that any market which does not 'clear' is no market at all.

Obviously the free play of the market plays a qualitatively bigger role in a country like Britain than in the Eastern Bloc; but that's not the same as saying that there are no markets in the East.

Are all the prices in the East fictitious and arbitrary, and workers' living standards in fact set by the volume of consumer goods allowed for in the plan? No. Excess purchasing power flows out of the official markets into the black markets and legal free markets which play a big role everywhere in the Eastern bloc. This fact, and political pressure generated by long queues, forces the bureaucrats to adjust consumer production → badly → to consumer demand. ed to build the STA nationally or (ii) that they have actively opposed' setting up local and regional structures. Although other groups have underestimated the significance of basic grassroots mobilisation, the criticisms above should be levelled at the Socialist Workers Party alone.

Liam Conway Nottinghan The vehement protests sparked off -as in Poland in 1980 - when the bureaucrats increase prices of basic goods are conclusive evidence that those prices do mean something.

The State is the only employer - or, at least, the only major employer - in the Eastern bloc, and in many countries wage rates are set by central government. But this does not mean that there is no labour market.

Firstly, a market with only one buyer is still a market. Secondly, it is no more than half-true to say that there is only one buyer. Individual enterprises use bonuses, piece-rates, and fringe benefits to attract more skilled and reliable workers. It is worth the worker's while to 'shop around from enterprise to enterprise. Indeed the USSR has long had a much bigger turnover of labour than the West.

If the official wage rates are too low, then labour will drain out of the official economy into illegal or (in some Eastern Bloc countries) legal private enterprise.

o sum it up: there was and is a qualitative economic difference between wage-workers in the USSR and labourcamp workers. There was vague speculation in the early '30s about replacing wages in the USSR by rationtickets: it is an economically significant fact that that was never done and never could be done.

It is not just a historical accident that the working class in the Eastern bloc acts like a wage-working class, using the same forms of struggle, raising the same sort of demands. It is a wage-working Martin Thomas, Islington.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 389

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →