The bigot and the
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-02-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
Winnie Mandela, wife of leader Nelson Manseek to use the issue as anti-ANC, and indeed, anti-black propaganda.
Groups of young men who terrorise local communities are not unique to South Africa. They are most common in the most downtrodden and deprived societies. The most dangerous places to live are working class type of organisation to township struggles. Moses is now on trial for his role in the Action Committee.
Mayekiso said of the Alexandra experience: "We do not believe in corporal punishment...If the person listens then we don't need to implement any punishment. We have snob rictoria Gillick will no doubt one day get elected as a Tory MP, and we will be subjected to regular outbursts of such venomous reaction as to make Edwina Currie seem sensible, enlightened and shrewd. Her appearance on The Late Show last week was like a premonition.
The discussion concerned the £500 fine imposed on Canadian artist Rick Gibson for his sculpture Human Earrings, which consists of a mannequin's head bearing a dried human foetus dangling from each earlobe.
Gillick, of course, was all for doing much worse than fining the man, while those rushing to the defence, if not of his artistic merit, at least of his right to be a weirdo, included the extraordinarly conceited Jonathon Miller.
Gillick's case rested upon the assertion that if anyone bothered to ask someone standing in a bus queue, they would certainly consider a human injection of a fatal serum Tne least punishment deserved by the filthy degenerate artist (though "artist" would be a word that people in the street, like Mrs Gillick, would have to spit out in snarling amazement.)
Jonathon Miller, who cannot open his mouth without unleashing a long list of names nobody (including the unfortunate Mrs Gillick, who responded with an uncomprehending sneer throughout his discourse) has ever heard of, argued that whilst indeed the sculpture was possessed of no artistic merit whatever and was justified by means of entirely fatuous argument, Mr Gibson had a perfect right to be a lousy sculptor without being financially penalised.
Important questions are at stake here, including artistic freedom and the issue of "public decency"
Presumably the artist's point is that foetuses are treated like commodities in our society, though the sensationalist method he chose to express this apparently typical of his style. Outrage at the use of actual human foetuses is understandable, and even justified up to a point. But undoubtedly the objection rests on a psychological link with the issue of abortion certainly in the mind of Mrs Gillick. Arguably, in fact, the work itself is anti-abortionist; but for extreme anti-abortionists like Gillick, whose general argument rests on the alleged humanity of a fertilised egg, the use of human foetuses is no different to the use of a shrunken skull.
Miller, quick off the mark, pointed out that an Egyptian mummy is also a dead person, but no one minds ogling at them in the British Museum, and Mrs Gillick here lost the argument resoundingly with her apparent conviction that someone dead for a long time is less human than someone who was never independently alive in the tirst place.
She also stupidly allowed herself to be sidetracked into an argument about What Is Art, which Miller was able to win with his hands tied behind his back, whilst preparing a monologue for future use on What Is Science, and without even needing to check the pronunciation of various French authorities on either subject.
These two thoroughly obnoxious people, the one personifying breathtakingly arrogant stupidity, the other breathtakingly arrogant erudition, were not in fact the only ones present in the debate, but I doubt if either one listened to anyone else.
Miller, inevitably, was right. Whether Gibson's weirdoism is artistically worth small parking offence, BEC VOT mind E500, or not, laws invoking "public decency" are certainly reactionary (and in parucular, though this is immediately relevant, are used against homosexuals). And artists should have the right to sculpt, paint, write or say what they like.