Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

For Jewish and Arab work Unravelling the issues

Socialist Organiser no. 388, 9 February 1989 · scan p. 18 · about 1,334 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 18 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 18

From page Nazis killed Jews. That is to be expected. But the other attack is from Some left-wingers argue that although the Jews were killed, they died because their leaders 'collaborated'. Where Jewish leaders whose communities were _under the complete physical control of the Nazis tried desperately to make whatever deals they could, this is cited as evidence of ZionistNazi collaboration.

The deliberate implication is that Israel is thereby tainted with some sort of responsibility for the Nazi slaugher of the Jews. See for example Lenni Brenner's book Zionism in the Age of the Dictators', and Jim Allen's play 'Perdition' This is to blame the victims for their own slaughter, and to smear the survivors of the communities slated for annihilation by the Nazis with the responsibility for those who died.

This obscenity is nothing less than a 'left-wing' equivalent of the ancient Christian anti-semitic "blood libel, which alleged that Jews used the blood of Christian children in religious ceremonies.

But the whole contrived argument is a double-edged weapon. For it was not the Zionists who voluntarily collaborated with the Nazis, but the leaders of the Palestinian Arabs.

Those old links of the Palestinians' reactionary leaders with the Nazis can have no weight with socialists and democrats in relation to the rights of the Palestinians today. But they show up the shoddiness of those who would try to bolster their case for the destruction of the Israeli Jewish nation with allegations about Jewish leaders 'collaborating' with Hitler.

Jews The Israeli state for many years maintained the unity of world Jewry behind its actions. 'Real politik' — doing what was necessary to protect the state — dragged Israeli politicians and their supporters to the right. To a certain extent the Israeli invasion of Lebanon cracked that unity. But it needs to crack more. Anti-Zionism There have been many antisemitisms in history. The root antisemitism in our society is that of Christianity. It is embedded in the Bible, with its myth about the Jews killing Christ.

Later the Jews became the universal scapegoat within capitalist society. Later still, the zoological mumbo-jumbo of 19th century racism targeted the Jews as an inferior species.

The left, too, has indulged in anti-semitism — not Christian antisemitism, nor racist anti-semitism, but that 'socialism of idiots' which denounced 'rich Jews" in an attempt to cash in on popular anti-semitism. Stalinism also developed a virulent form of disguised anti-semitism during its "anti-Zionist' campaigns of the '40s and '50s.

Today there is a powerful stream of left-wing anti-semitism. The demand that the Jewish state should cease to exist, and that the Jewish nation should instead dissolve into an Arab state, is inescapably antisemitic. It implies hostility to the Israeli Jews, and hostility to all those Jews worldwide - 'Zionists' - who instinctively identify with the Israeli Jews.

It is not necessarily a matter of being personally prejudiced against individual Jews, or of being a racist. But, whatever their good intentions, the proposal to destroy the Israeli Jewish nation inevitably leads many left-wingers into a comprehensive hostility to all pro-Israeli Jews — that is, almost all Jews.

Where does the left's Zionophobia come from?

Left Zionist groups levels are unknown.

Public figures are astoundingFrom 1978 to 1982 Israel received 48% of all US military aid and 35% of US economic aid.

In Financial Year 1983, the US Administration requested $2.5 billion for Israel out of a total aid budget of $8.1 billion. $500 million was outright grants.

In turn, one third of Israeli manufactured exports are arms for example to South American dic tatorships. in the USSR until 1927 — six years after all opposition parties were banned. There was a Zionist unit in the Red Army. Left-wing Zionists were represented at the Second Congress of the Communist International. In the '20s and "30s, reactionaries bracketed the left Zionists with the communists. The Labour left was particularly friendly. to Zionism until well into the "70s.

How, then, did Zionophobia come to dominate the left? Much of the Labour left's affection for Zionism was based on the false premise that Israel is socialist. That delusion long ago became hard to sustain.

More importantly, the colonial regime that Israel has run in the West Bank and Gaza since 1967 has progressively alienated left-wing sympathy. In a world where the 'new' left was formed in response to events such as the Vietnamese war, Israel seemed very unattractive.

But that is only part of the story. There has been a powerful source of anti-Zionism in the left quite independent of these events and considerations - the Stalinist movement, and the USSR and East European Stalinist states.

From 1949 onwards, Stalin, the Russian dictator, turned against Israel. In 1948 he launched a full-scale purge of "Zionists' - especially in the East European Communist Parties which Stalin's army had placed in power.

Leading Jewish CPers, like Rudolph Slansky in Czechoslovakia, were given the main parts in a series of spectacular show trials. They were charged, among other things, with being Zionists. It was a thinly disguised purge of Jews.

The 'anti-Zionist" crusade spread throughout the CPs of the world. There were good Jews still. But 'the Zionists' were bad Jews, and by now that meant that most Jews were bad Jews. Over the years there was a slow exodus of Jewish CP Joined by some 370,000 more Jews from Europe and about 400,000 Jews from Arab countries.

The long-established and sizeable Jewish communities in the Arab countries were driven out. There were full-scale pogroms in Morocco and Libya after 1948.

The Palestinians have not only ZA Mediterranean Sea Port Said CAIRO St uez River members.

In 1953 Stalin was set to stage a show trial of the Kremlin's own doctors, most of them Jews, in what would very likely have been the prelude to a large-scale anti-Jewish purge in the Soviet Union. Stalin died before the scheduled trial, and his successors called it off.

Stalin's 'ant-Zionist' campaign had merged with existing currents of anti-semitism in the USSR. Antisemitism had been very powerful in the later Tsarist Empire. As early as the "20s Stalin had used antisemitism against the Trotskyist Left Opposition. In the 1930s Trotsky had pointed to the unmistakable evidence of rampant anti-semitism in Stalin's Russia.

Anti-semitism is still a force in the Stalinist states. In 1968-9 there was a full-scale purge of the pitiful remnants of Poland's Jewish community, especially those who were members of the ruling party.

Stalinism is the prime source of JN Partition Plan Jewish state, 1947 Territories seized by in 1948 and 1949 Territories seized by in June 1967 BEIRUT Sidon SYRIA FALES Tel Aviv Amyran Gaza erusal JORDAN •River Jordan Gulf of Agaba SAUDI ARADIA Zionophobia — a Zionophobia in which traditional East European and Russian anti-semitism mingled with the anti-Israeli and pro-Arab foreign policy considerations of the Against this background it was easy enough for the left that took shape in the '60s in solidarity with Third World struggles to line up solidly with the left-talking and vociferously 'anti-imperialist' Arab bourgeois regimes which saw Israel as the main enemy.

Instead of independent working class politics, the left adopted the politics of demonologising Israel and identifying Arab nationalism as the revolutionary force in the area. The left thus broke with the basic ideas of Lenin: where there is national conflict, socialists advocate working class unity as the first principle, and conciliation of the national conflicts as the means to promote working class unity across the national divisions.

used to control their activities.

Arab history and language is ignorec in education. Arab villages and towns are starved of funding for ecoromic and social development, while nearby Jewish kibbutzim might be highly prosperous. Rights that are only due to those who have undergone military service are denied to Arabs who obviously won't join the Israeli Army.

Pro-PLO political parties are illegal. Arab political newspapers face frequent censorship and banning. The West

----- pull-quotes -----

The Arab states and Palestine

Gulf of Sure GuIt SirE

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 388

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →