Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why 'two states'?

Socialist Organiser no. 388, 9 February 1989 · scan p. 17 · about 997 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 17 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 17

O'Mahony The idea of solving the terrible national conflict by simply enfolding, intermeshing and merging as equal citizens, the hostile nations who compete for the disputed Palestinian teritory, is an attractive one — and all the more so because there is no other solution that appears to do justice to both sides.

But it is nonsense. The idea that you could integrate any other two nations -say France and Germany - in the territory occupied by one of them would be dismissed as ludicrous, even given the fading in the last decades of much of their old animosity.

In Palestine the proposal for a secular democratic state amounts to a proposal to so enfold two nations who have related to each other with the most bitter and merciless war for half a century and more. It is a utopian absurdity. National identities and conflicts will not be overcome or superseded historically in anything like that way.

More than that. It is inconceivable that the Jews would agree to dismantle their state in return for a promise of equal citizenship. So the road to the 'secular democratic state' lies inescapably through war and full-scale conquest of the Jews.

And after that what will happen? The victorious armies (of Iraq, Syria, Iran?) will gallantly establish and protect the democratic rights of the Jews as individuals (rights their own citizens do not now have) in a Palestinian Arab state?

In reality such a conquest would be resisted to the death by the Jews, and the idea of such a conquest is in practice inseparable from a proposal to drive out the Jews or massacre them.

The secular democratic state is far more attractive and internationally "saleable' than the programmme of driving the Jews into the sea' that Yasser Arafat's predecessor Ahmed Shukhairy used to advocate in the 1960s. For many people the "secular democratic state' slogan also represents a different intention and aspiration. But in practice it comes down to the same thing, because it cannot be done by agreement. It differs essentially in being a more usetul propaganda tool.

So the 'secular democratic state' is in fact a proposal to destroy the existing Jewish nation and at best to grant equal citizenship rights to those Jews who survived being conquered and wanted to remain in an Arab state.

But this is a-historical moralism: moreover it takes as its premise, as something to be taken for granted and beyond discussion, a stark denial of any national rights for the Jews in Palestine. It demands of them that they do what no other nation has ever done, and what no people extant will ever do - submit to the forced dissolution of their own national community and surrender the protection of their own state.

For the Jews this would involve additionally putting themselves into the hands of those they have been fighting for 40 years and more — people in whose own states minorities like the Kurds (or Palestinian Arabs) are habitually repressed and routinely butchered.

The reasoning one finds on much of the "Marxist' left is a series of moralistic demands cut loose from any consideration of how the world works, and addressed as an unique ultimatum to the Palestinian Jews — a series of demands that it would be impossible for serious people to make without the prior unquestionable assumption that the Jewish nation does not have the right to exist, still less the right to defend itself.

In short, in its superficially attractive "up-front' version the idea of a secular democratic state is simply a delusion. The slogan could not ever help deliver the solution it seems to promise - conciliation and equality of Jews and Arabs in a common state.

It could not unless the way politics and the relationships between peoples 'work' everywhere else in the world could somehow be replaced in Palestine - 40 years after the Israeli war of independence - by a different set of ways of functioning.

The 'secular democratic state' is either disingenuous or it is absurd. And it is worse.

If you take it at its face value the "secular democratic state' idea is an attractive utopian proposal. But we have seen that it cannot be taken at its face value. It is a political ultimatum behind which is posed a fearsome 'or else' • Immediately it is refused by Israel and the 'Zionists' it translates into a moralistic-political denunciation of those who refuse. They are 'exposed'. That 'exposure' and denunciation then become a warrant for the military destruction of the Israeli state, the subjugation and if necessary kılling of the citizens of Israel, and the forcible removal from them of national rights.

What happens if the Israeli Jews don't accept the 'secular democratic state' formula and fight? Conquer them and remove from them all power of resistance, or of self-defence.

What if they don't trust a promise that them from the charge of being or having been agents or spies for the 'Great Satan' US imperialism or of "Zionist im perialism"? That's proof beyond dispute that they are unreasonable in rejecting *secular democratic state' citizenship and deserve what they get.

What they would get would be expulsion or the right to emigrate. It is to be 1948 again, and worse — only this time the 'right' people do the uprooting and expelling.

The raising of the 'utopian secular democratic state demand as the opening political/ideological gambit produces a political and moral opiate for the left about what must inevitably follow from and is implied in the proposal to destroy the Jewish state and deprive the Palestinian Jews of national rights.

Under the influence of this opiate, the most horrendous things are then proposed to be done to the Jews of Palestine — things no socialist would advocate or tolerate for any comparable grouping.

----- pull-quotes -----

'The idea secular democratic state is simply a delusion"

the conqueror will give them equal per- sonal citizenship and absolve and protect

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 388

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →