For Jewish and Arab wol Unravelling
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-02-09Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 16 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 16
tga takes a look at Dok the Africa It is a very popular idea on the left that Israel is the same sort of state as South Africa. Israel and South Africa are said to be similar 'settler states', and a common political programme is advocated for both: smash the settler state.
But even if the 'settler state" tag fits both South Africa and Israel, these societies are so vastly different that the tag alone is inadequately concrete to base any political conclusions on. What differentiates Israel and South Africa is more important than the common nametag.
In Israel there is not a ruling Jewish caste exploiting Arab helots. There is a comprehensive Jewish society organised in a Jewish nation state. This is not the same sort of society as South Africa.
"Smash the settler state' in South Africa or colonial Algeria means: abolish the monopoly of power and the caste privileges of the white minority: let the majority rule.
But what does 'smash the settler state' mean for Israel? It is a state which is extremely democratic for its Jewish majority. Its army is pretty close to being a citizen army. For an external force to "smash the state' is not a matter of destroying a repressive apparatus, or defeating it in war, but of overrunning Israel and forcibly destroying the Jewish nation. It could only be done by slaugher, expropriation and terror - and pretty much for certain, the driving out of large parts of the population.
Put starkly, the far left's programme for Palestine is that Israel must be destroyed'.
Now this is a unique programme: the destruction of a state and the radical alteration of the population of that state's core area. From this everything else follows.
The programme is made to appear not unique by identifying Israel with South Africa. But that Is an utterly false comparison of an organic society made up of all classes and not essentially dependent on exploiting a submerged population on one side, and on the other a society in which the white population are an exploiting caste dependent for what they have on the submergence and helotry of a numerically much bigger black population.
Whatever similarity in politicalmilitary techniques there may be between South Africa and Israel, they are radically different societies. Israel was given its character by the Zionists' resolute refusal to exploit Arab labour and their drive instead to replace it.
Whatever one thinks of the left Zionist colonists' •Jewish labour only' policy, it was the opposite of that mass exploitation on which modern South Africa was built. The exploitation of Arab labour from the occupied territories since 1967 has not fundamentally altered the character of Israel in this respect.
The Israeli workers A quarter of a million Israelis — in British population terms, it would be six million people -demonstrated in protest at the massacre carried out by Lebanese Christians in the Palestinian refugee camps of Sabra and Chatila, in an area under Israeli army control.
Within Israel, there is a strong peace movement pushing for compromise with the Arabs and opposing any Israeli expansion. There is now a big campaign in Israel to oppose the Jewish racist Meir Kehane and his followers.
Despite all this, many on the left refuse to see any good in any Israelis. Israeli socialists and Israeli workers are good only if they first agree that Israel should dissolve itself. The only good Israeli Jew is the one prepared to become an honorary Arab, or willing to emigrate.
At the root of the inability to see any good in any Israeli is the refusal to recognise that the Israeli nation is a legitimate nation and that it has national rights. If you don't recognise the right of the nation to exist in the area, you can hardly see any role for its working class.
Why a Palestinian Arab state?
The Palestinian Arabs are a defeated people who have suffered the consequences of the JewishArab war of 1948. The root problem of the Palestinian Arabs is their dispossession by the Israeli Jews, but the condition of the Palestinian Arabs today is not just Israeli's responsibility.
The fact that they continue as refugees is also to be explained by intra-Arab politics, and by the desire of various Arab states to have them as a living indictment of Arab states have discriminated against Palestinians and often slaughtered them. The remnant of Palestine allotted to the Arabs by the UN in 1947 was not unilaterally taken over by Israel, but divided by agreement between Jordan and Today the Palestinian Arabs are a nation without a homeland. The nearest thing they have to a homeland — the West Bank, where they are the great majority - Is occupied by Israel.
About 600,000 Palestinians live in Israel; about 800,000 in the West Bank, and 500,000 in the Gaza Strip; over a million in Jordan; almost half a million in Saudi Arabia and the Gulf; and more than a million scattered round Lebanon, Syria, other Arab states, and the rest of the world.
Everywhere they are insecure and second-class citizens.
The Palestinians desperately need to establish their own state. For practical purposes the PLO has given up the notion of replacing Israel with an Arab-controlled "secular democratic state' - Its aim is an independent Palestinian state in the territories occupied by Israel.
That is the only path to a solution. Israel will not easily agree to it. But while the secular democratic state is impossible, an independent Palestinian state can be won by struggle. Those who want to help the Palestinians should argue for it.
Is socialism answer?
Yes, socialism is the answer. But this phrase is sometimes used to evade the issues.
Socialism can only be made by the working class. And the working class can make socialism only if the workers of different nations can find an answer to national conflicts. Socialism will not dissolve national conflicts.
The Russian revolutionaries in 1917 had a policy for resolving the national conflicts that rent the Russian Empire: self-determination. Wherever a people or a fragment of a people was oppressed or feared oppression, the socialist policy was for the workers of all nations concerned to unite on the basis of the right of all peoples and fragments of peoples to join whatever neighbouring state they liked or have their own state.
Such a policy is needed, as well as the direct socialist programme, in the Middle East. We propose a free socialist federation of the Middle East with national rights for all non-Arab minorities, including the Jews.
How was Israel created?
The myth is that there was some sort of international conspiracy by rich and powerful Jews and US imperialism.
The fact is that the Jewish settlers were first Zionist enthusiasts, many of them socialists, and then, in the '30s and '40s, survivors and early Zionist settlements. In the '20s and '30s reactionaries commonly denounced the left-wing Zionists as allies of Bolshevism.
In fact, of course, they were Jewish nationalists, determined to develop a Jewish nation in Palestine. They used the protection of British imperialism — which ruled Palestine from 1917 to 1947 but they clashed with Britain too.
Within the Zionist camp there were many strands of thought about how to relate to the Arabs. There were advocates of a joint Jewish-Arab state as well as advocates of a brutal 'realpolitik' acceptance of the inevitability of all-out bloody conflict with the Arabs.
The Jews alone did not determine relations between themselves and the Palestinian Arabs. As the Jewish colony grew, so also the Arab peasants were increasingly driven off the land and pauperised. Mostly they were driven off the land by Arab landlords, not by Jewish settlers. But the landlords successfully directed the peasants' anger at the Jews.
From 1919 onwards there were regular clashes between Jews and Arabs. The Arabs attacked for a mixture of reasons - resentment, fear, bigotry. In the 1930s the Palestinian Arab leaders looked to the Nazis to help them drive out British imperialism and the Jewish colonists. Hadj Amin al-Husseini proposed to form a Muslim army to fight for Germany. The Zionists, vastly strengthened by refugees from Nazism, allied uneasily with Britain against the Arabs.
Under Arab pressure, Britain imposed severe limits on Jewish immigration at the end of the '30s, just as the great slaughter of European Jews by the Nazis was about to begin. Conflict between Britain and Jews followed, and exploded at the end of World War 2.
Britain wanted to get out. In 1947 it asked the United Nations for a decision on the future of Palestine. The UN proposed partition. Britain began to withdraw. Palestinian Arabs began guerilla war against the Jews. This simmering war gave way to all-out war when the Britishofficered armies of the Arab states invaded.
The Jews might have been defeated in 1948. There was nothing inevitable about their victory. Israel depended for arms on the goodwill the USSR and its puppet Czechoslovakia. Stalin thought he saw a chance to strike a blow against the British empire. Soon Israel and the USSR would fall out.
Backs to the wall, with nowhere to go but maybe the displaced persons' camps of Europe, the Israeli Jews outfought the mercenary Arab armies and consolidated the Israeli state. The Palestinian Arabs were the main losers. It might have been the Jews.
Nazi-Zionist collaboration For decades the memory of the Nazi slaughter of six million Jews acted as a bulwark against anti-semitism. Anti-semitism became something to be ashamed of.
Today that bulwark is under attack from two directions. Rightwingers and fascists deny that the Continued Palestinian refugees cross the Jordar the
----- pull-quotes -----
refugees from fascism. The left- wing Zionists were the core of the