We need to unite left teachers
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-02-09Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Socialists
trade unions A Socialist Organiser Lian Conway takes a critical look at the recent history of the left in the NUT.
he Socialist Alliance was in 1976. Varic stablished s political Tom on NUPE still says Stop the and the weekend school Saturday and Sunday February 18/19 Manchester Polytechnic Students Union Oxford Road, Manchester tendencies were involved, most notably the IMG (now Socialist Action and Socialist Outlook). The Socialist Workers Party (IS) were not in at the beginning. They were the motivating force behind another teachers' group, Rank and File.
SWP and File despite considerable opposition_ from Rank and File members who were not in the SWP. The SWP were admitted to the STA in 1985.
The STA is now bigger and more influential than ever, gaining considerable support at National Union of Teachers conference for its resolutions and establishing significant strength on the NUT National Executive. However, its strength is partly due to widespread disillusion with the Broad Left (soft left union leadership, and STA will need to sharpen its cutting edge if it is to overturn the Broad Left permanently.
So what's up with it now? Three broad strands are noticeable STA.
The first is the IMG strand. It is split into many different viewpoints and contains many people who have nothing except their politics in common with the old IMG. They share namely a tendency towards suspicion of the membership, a certain intellectual elitism, and a preoccupation with Third World They see their role in educating the membership not just about how to fight the BL and the Tories, but also how to fight the wars in Ireland, Palestine, South Africa, Nicaragua, etc, etc. They have been closely associated with the politics of anti-racist education and were strong supporters of Brent Council's suspension from employment of a head teacher, Maureen McGoldrick, on dubious charges of racism.
This strand has singularly failed to build the Socialist Teachers Alliance into a national rank and file opposition to the current leadership. Alongside the SWP, the exIMG have actively opposed the setting up of local and regional STA structures and the inclusion of nonLondon members on the executive committee of the STA.
Recently the STA executive decided to hold the main STA meeting at NUT conference in March on Ireland. Incredibly the following executive voted not to recommend local associations of the NUT to prioritise the STA's own motion on Ireland. The STA is therefore in the ludicrous position of holding its major meeting on a subject it doesn't think is urgent enough to discuss on conference floor.
The second strand was the SWP. They were prime movers of the Ireland meeting and are often at home with the leaders of the exIMG strand.
The SWP have shown little or no interest in rank and file STA groups unless, (i) they are big and growing (unlikely at the moment), and ii) the SWP can dominate the group and pick up new SWP members.
The SWP rant about the dangers of 'new realism' at the head of the union but oppose any attempts to organise the STA at a low level, linked up by the national organisation.
The SWP were also ready to shout 'sell-out' at every turn. When Haringey NUT - under strong leftwing leadership - dropped their "no cover' action (the refusal of teachers to take the lessons of absent colleagues) in return for official backing for strike action, the SWP denounced them. A few weeks later the Inner London Teachers Association (ILTA) was faced with the same choice. The SWP did an about-turn and dropped their demand for 'no cover' action to be maintained.
Were they influenced by the fact that some ILTA officials were SWP members? No - I think their ILTA decision was based on sound tactical reasoning. It's a pity they didn't give the same benefit to the Haringey officers.
Generally the SWP are difficult to predict. They like to pose as the "hardest' militants, warning against any united front with non-STA rank and file teachers.
But the SWP have considerable credibility inside the STA, and this has a negative effect on rank and file teachers. Moreover, the IMG strand fear a split inside the STA and rely on alliances with the SWP.
The third strand in the STA includes Breting supporters, a handful of Militant supporters, independent lefts and ourselves. Until recently we have failed to take on the SWP politically.
For Socialist Organiser teachers our basic problem is small numbers. Nevertheless, we have successfully moved the STA towards a more rank and file orientation and away from both the IMG's magazine