Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

T&G right on the warpath

Socialist Organiser no. 388, 9 February 1989 · scan p. 10 · about 1,289 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

HOISINI By Sleeper Have you noticed how certain I industrial and political correspondents from the national press seem to know an awful lot about what's going on inside the TGWU?

And how their stories often quote *senior officials of the union" , "well placed union sources" , and so forth? Or that the stories always contain phrases like "dissatisfaction with Ron Todd" "malpractice by the hard left" and "membership in revolt"?

Todd has certainly noticed. After last September's General Executive Council (itself enlivened by a remarkably wellpublicised walkout by 17 right-wingers - oops! -moderates) an investigation was launched into how certain journalists came to know so much about the internal goings on of the union.

A lot of activity is coming up in the TGWU. The Biennial Delegate Conference (BDC) takes place in June, both the Assistant General Secretary and Deputy General Secretary are due for election by July and Todd himself must stand for re-election by June 1990. Elections for the new executive are due at the beginning of 1990. Most important of all, a major battle is looming over the union's 30-year old commitment to unilateral nuclear disarmament - an issue where the union's block vote could be decisive at Labour Party Conference.

Todd had no sooner stepped off the plane bringing him and the rest of the Labour Party's defence delegation back from Moscow, than the latest press campaign began: "Todd faces defeat by own union on defence," proclaimed the Sunday Times, which went on to inform readers that, "leaders of a grassroots revolt against Todd's unilateralist line are confident the union's 1.25m block vote at Labour conference will ensure victory for Neil Kinnock's attempt to swing the Party's defence policy towards multilateral disarmament. of the St qUotes sources in the union" as saying that eight of the TGWU's 11 regions are backing BDC resolutions calling for a "switch from unilateralism in the light of the progress towards world disarmament." Several to change policy electoral prospect to boost Labour's resolutions apparently refer to "the need This all sounds like another off-therecord press briefing by that old team of Nicholson and Wright, the men who make Bernard Ingham look like a model of openness and accountability. Brian Nicholson was the union's President until his defeat in last February's Executive elections. Despite no longer holding any significant office in the union, he still gets an awful lot of facility time from his employers, (the Port of London Docks Authority), in which to pursue "union work" . George Wright is the Welsh Regional Secretary, defeated by Todd for the General Secretary's job in 1984. Wright and his supporters were the driving force behind moves to drop unilateralism at the last BDC.

A resolution from Region 4 (Wales) calling for a national referendum on the question of nuclear came within a whisker of being passed. It was noticeable then that the right-wing were much better organised and high profile than the so-called 'Broad Left'. Since then, the right has stepped up its activity, organising secret meetings, liaising with journalists (noticeably Tom Condon of Today and keeping in close touch with the leadership of the EETPU and the AEU, via the Mainstream organisation run by John Spellar, an EETPU research officer' The right-wing have turned a number of the union's regions into virtual no-go areas for Todd and his deputy Bill Morris. Last year, Todd was excluded from a Region 5 (Midlands) committee meeting by Regional Secretary Jim Hunt.

Meanwhile the Broad Left remains a narrow "word of mouth" organisation made up of full-time officials and people with subscriptions to the Morning Star. They hold no open meetings and have done no organising amongst the rank and file. The warning they were effectively given over unilateralism at the 1987 BDC does not seem to have sunk in. While it is not true (as the ST's "sources in the union" claim) that only London, Scotland and Northern Ireland are committed to defending unilateralism at this year's BDC (for a start Region 6 - the North West is almost certain to back the present policy), It is nonetheless a fact that the Broad Left has done no campaigning on the issue since the last BDC.

No systematic discussion has taken place at branch level and the T&G Record has scarcely mentioned the issue. Both left and right within the union have concentrated on bureaucratic manoeuvring at regional level and behind the scenes nobbling of conference delegates. The signs are, however, that the right will prove better at this game than the left.

Todd himself holds a deep personal commitment to unilateralism, as demonstrated by his famous "cordless telephone" speech at the last Labour Party Conference. But he is coming under increasing pressure from some of his own allies on the TGWU Executive and from the Tribunite wing of the Labour Party to "soften" his line. His inclusion in the defence delegation to Moscow was part of the softening up process, with even the Kremlin's General Lobov wheeled out to make pro-multilateralist noises for the benefit of Brother Todd.

Since his return from Moscow, Todd has taken to using the phrase "reciprocated unilateralism" — a form ot words that, de-coded, sounds suspiciously like "multilateralism"

Between now and June, the right's campaign to overturn existing policy will undoubtedly be stepped up, with the full backing of Brian Nicholson's friends in the press. The TGWU left needs to respond by taking the unilateralist case to the membership and by openly challenging the right wing in their own regional bastions. Secret meetings of Morning Star readers won't be enough. readers club and the SWP's sectarian meetings. This is an important task as many rank and file teachers who are genuinely pissed off with the NUT leadership see the STA as a left intellectuals' club remote to the needs of teachers.

Over the last 18 months this reaction has generated a new rank and file group known as the Campaign for a Democratic and Fighting Union (CADFU). This group is the lunar opposite to the STA — based outside London, concentrating exclusively on teachers' demands and limiting itself to the task inside the union.

Although CADFU has a crude bread and butter approach to NUT politics, its seemingly honest endeavours have attracted support from considerable numbers of classroom teachers.

Sadly, great hostility exists between CADFU and STA, fuelled by the SWP who say that CADFU shouldn't be touched and are tainted with 'new realism'.

Unfortunately, ths year's NUT conference will now see competing left resolutions and meetings. We should be seeking merger and a united front of the left.

We have always argued that the STA should actively encourage the formation of local STA groups on a non-sectarian basis, open to any teacher looking to fight the NUT leadership. Most important, such groups should not just be electoral machines but a permanent mobilising force meeting regularly and in contact with as many • union members as possible. This means working . with CADFU and any other union members who wish to take up the struggle.

The aim of all our work inside the STA is to organise the left inside the NUT and sharpen its fighting edge. The STA is the largest force inside the milieu (with over 700 individual members), but we must turn the STA both towards eventual merger with CADFU and towards a sympathetic understanding of the many independent rank and file teachers who are willing to fight.

Unfortunately many of those trade unionists are suspicious of the STA's politics and uncertain about its leadership capabilities. Our task is to make the STA worthy of trust and support at the grassroots so that it can seriously take on and defeat the Broad Left leadership.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 388

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →