Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Such ich sion here

Socialist Organiser no. 388, 9 February 1989 · scan pp. 7–8 · Clive Bradley · about 452 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

are "only two possible regulators for the supply and extraction of human social labour", namely a plan or a market, he concludes that neither regulates the USSR. The bureaucracy, therefore, has no control over the surplus product, and is not a ruling But is there even a surplus product? If, literally, nothing regulates the supply and extraction of human social labour, presumably any surplus is purely random and accidental. Now there must be a surplus, or society would stagnate and disintegrate. And something must govern the allocation or reallocation of the surplus, if only inadequately. Mustn't it?

However, it Stan can concede that there is some sort of surplus, the use of which is determined somehow, he is left with a peculiar result. The USSR conforms to neither mode of regulation theoretically possible; and yet it exists.

The heart of Stan's peculiar confusion is that he insists, "There can be no plan because there is no democracy.

That there can be no socialist planning without democracy, I would agree. One of the idiocies of the theory that the USSR is a workers' state is that it deduces, from the mere existence of a five year plan, the proletarian character of the state. The workers' state theory sees Soviet economy torn between the 'logic' of the market and the logic' of the plan, Planning in the socialist sense is a "social relation' between direct producers. Clearly no such planning exists in the USSR.

But surely there are other sorts of plans. Most capitalist companies, and most capitalist governments, plan to one degree or another, sometimes to a high degree. Of course, the market frequently screws up the plan. But if their planning was always an utter waste of time they wouldn't bother spending money on it.

If a Third World capitalist. government decides to spend huge amounte of manav huildinn deton our moncy until factory, or a hydro-electric dam, or a road, come to that -it may not be very proletarian, but it cer tainly is planning after a fashiot And it is, often, using criteria which depend only indirectly on the When so much capitalist produc tion is at least partially divorced from the law of value and subordinated to planning, it seems to me perverse to the extreme to argue that production in the USSR is determined by nothing at all.

The bureaucracy has no control over the surplus? Who decides that SS20 missiles will be built? God?

If the bureaucracy literally has no control over the surplus, it would seem to me to define out of existence the bureaucracy, not only as a 'ruling class' , but as any sort of distinct social layer at all.

Scan page 8

ACTIVIS IS

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 388

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →