Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Yes, the bureaucrat are a ruling class

Socialist Organiser no. 388, 9 February 1989 · scan p. 7 · about 725 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

epoch. Trotsky added that since this 2917 - but much. System was about to collapse; Local i capitalism. it'a 'new class society' watcone Stan's theory that It is true to say that clan Where system, and has no others say 'not class class isn'tever at best, theore earth-shattering. But the objection i headedness. of motion of a system before yuu not? Does struggle e can call it a class system at all, is sil- workers and the b Clive Bradley replies to Stan Crooke on the TUSSR tan Crooke proves 386). Arguing that there A Russian factory manager raised his al Ah, but, Stan insists, - the bureaucracies are "unstable" , the so on; they are not class societies: working class is "atomised" Yet his analysis raises very profound questions: if the bureaucracy (unstable) has no control over a surplus produced by entirely atomised workers, do any classes exist in the USSR? Does the working class itself exist?

Hillel Ticktin, if I have understood him correctly, argues no working class exists in the USSR, either. Surely if this is so, it is a bit rich to criticise all us closet Shachtmanites who are writing off the perspective of socialist revolution.

It seems to me that Stan, like Ticktin, has theorised himself into a corner. The objection to the description of the USSR bureaucracy as a ruling class, as opposed to a 'caste' or an 'elite' , rests on two basic arguments which Stan reiterates.

(a) If the bureaucracy is a ruling class, what is the nature of the class system it rules? What are its laws of motion? To affix a label to the bureaucracy is to say almost (b) If this class society is not capitalism, where does it stand un relation to the transition from capitalism to socialism? If its mE, hotwoon the twn socialism heel genda for a whole that you have to specity all the laws Recent Marxist research has indicated that there were quite a variety of pre-capitalist modes of production. Whether the theories of these modes are valid or not, it seems pretty certain that European feudalism was very unlike the Arab empire, the Ottoman empire, medieval China or Inca Peru. Marx thought so too, and coined the term "Asiatic" mode of production to describe India.

Maybe I underesti doubt if Stan has a out theory of the di toman Turkey. Or pi Saharan Africa. Or Did a ruling class toman empire? It i very peculiar ruling of its members were But how was the traction" , in Stan's phrase, regulated? ciently. Nor did in much control over t And the Ottoma stagnant in a far m than today's USSR I The non-existenc class would have cor shock to generatio though, I think.

So Stan's definitic row. Just as variou some more dynami existed alongside a feudalism, so the USSR exists alongsid That it is so simi respects to ordinary example, there is a that goes on strike : tifies with socialism) the theory that it is c sonally I tend to the not capitalism, but or less the relation that the Ottoman s DUVENIREE reudansin. I s-d sus capitalism, and by a Is the working cla not? If this is not then what is it? A st sections of the wol struggle between ato fused individuals w decide where the si went? A seance, ma! ghost of the surplus reluctant regulators?

Surely, there is a c workers against th Arguments otherwi vince me. mate him, but! i fully workedynamics of Otre-colonial subthe Aztecs. exist in the Otvas certainly a class, as many slaves. "supply and ex; rather dental Not very effidividuals_have he surplus. in empire was ore exact sense is. e of a ruling ne as a bit of a ns of Sultans, ins are too nars class systems, c than others, nd parallel to system in the de capitalism. lar in so many capitalism (for working class and often idenlends weight to capitalism. Pertheory that it's stands in more to capitalism ystem stood to. te revolution of much closer to. it is not a class ruling class, is. tical blockiss exploited or kist between the ureaucracy. or class struggle, ruggle between rking class? A mised and conho can't quite urplus product ybe, to find the product and its lass struggle, of leir exploiters. se don't con-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 388

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →