Why I love Pope watching
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-02-09Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
WOME Hope watching may seem a rather esoteric pastime. However, even socialists have to have some leisure pursuits, and I have to admit that papal pronouncements do hold quite an interest for me.
Imagine my astonishment then, when I came across a report saying that the Pope had expressed an agreement with certain 'feminist beliefs' . Pig might fly, I hear you say, but as the Catholic faith is based on even more unlikely occurrences, it did seem worth reading on.
Maybe the Virgin Mary herself had appeared to JPIl in a flurry of angels to set the record straight, and to transform Catholicism into a matriarchal cult.
Of course not. did say was the women should not be treated as sex objects. All well and good, but I suspect this stems rather more from an oppositon to sex than a commitment to the right of women to a self-determined sexuality.
Indeed, the rest of the papal encyclical, as you would expect, continued with the sort of slimy soft-soaping that we've come to expect not just from the Vatican but from all defenders of the sexist status quo.
Some of the demands of the women's movement are positively damaging to women. Women achieve full dignity by... yes, you've guessed it, performing the ultimately fulfilling and central role of the loyal wife and doting mother.
Yes girls, let's take the Virgin Mary as our guide, and not only will we gain true, pure satisfaction in this world, but garlands of flowers in the next. All the trials and tribulations of motherhood under Thatcher will, or course, pale into insignificance when we think of the poor housing, lack of state benefits and completely non-existent maternity care which Mary had to endure. What a shining example us all!
Mind you, it's not just the zealots of the Church of Rome that use these arguments. All the time we are told 'behind every great man there's a woman', that motherhood is an important job, nay even a career.
We get patted on the head and told to get on with the wonderful job we're doing. Why should we want to do anything else when we have such a precious task entrusted to us anyway?
Sadly, the Pope probably has more in common with some feminists than he thinks. A couple of months ago, I was asked along to a college women's group to speak about Women and the family' As the women's movement of the "70s based itself on a radical critique of the family, indeed saw women's role in the home as the fundamental lynchpin of our oppression, I thought there would be much common ground.
Most of the women there did reject the idea that the ultimate fulfilment for us is childbearing, cooking, cleaning and generally nurturing. But some women there,