Too quick to condemn
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-02-09Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
really don't understand Liam Conway's letter about Salman Rushdie (SO 387). Liam says that Rushdie sees all white people as incurably racist, and that this is undemocratic.
It's not a very thought-out analysis, obviously; but to go on effectively to align Rushdie with the local government left' antidemocratic culture on the evidence of two inconclusive quotations from New Society is not very fair. It wouldn't convince an open-minded lawyer, anyway.
On the evidence of Rushdie's books, Liam's judgement is unreasonable *Midnightis Children' climaxes with an indictment of Indira Gandhi; 'Shame' ridicules Ali Bhutto; and the *Jaguar Smile' at least criticises the Sandinistas on grounds of democracy. I haven't read 'Satanic Verses' yet, but I doubt that it's much comfort to Bernie Grant et al (who want it banned, after all).
Rushdie's general sentiments seem to be for democracy, indeed verging on liberalism (he is a signatory of Charter 88).
It is a bit off to condemn him outright on the basis of what, to put it mildly, doesn't seem much more than loose talking.
Clive Bradley defeat.
The leftist supporters of Charter 88 place their hopes on a revival of *citizenship' and some participants in the 'Chesterfield movement' look to the formation of a new, radical purity outside the labour movement which is seen as too reprehensibly Labourist (not to mention white and male) to break the log jam.
This is the politics of despair. There are no short cuts arond making our labour movement take up the issues. Charter 88 represents an attempt by the Democrats and their fellow travellers to play on the desire of radical leftists for quick, broad success.
The logic of Charter 88 is coalitions. We shouldn't allow ourselves to be hoodwinked by it.
Kate O'Leary, Dulwich.
G3103 TO
Scan page 5
DOI