Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

No votes please, I'm Kinnock

Socialist Organiser no. 387, 2 February 1989 · scan p. 12 · about 547 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

• amendments to the Reports should be amended 'in the STOR Gerry Bates amendments to the Labour leadership's Policy Review documents will be allowed at this year's Party Conference:

Last year, too, amendments were not allowed; and some resolutions seeking to change key elements in the documents were ruled out of order. We were told that the membership would have its day in 1989.

Last week, Labour's National Executive Committee (NEC) defeated by 12 votes to 4 a proposal from Ken Livingstone that Party members and affiliated organisations should have the right to amend the final drafts of the Policy Review.

For the Kinnock leadership Party Conference is at best a media event, at worse an inconvenient necessity. They have said openly that they regard its decisions as "consultative' , not sovereign. Such was Neil Kinnock's reaction to the 1988 Party Conference vote reaffirming unilateral nuclear disarmament.

The NEC even heard a proposal that the Policy Review Reports should have priority over composite resolutions passed at Party Conference on the same issue. The soft left baulked at this, and the move was defeated 11-4. By then Neil Kinnock and several rightwingers had left the meeting.

The following procedure was adopted. After this year's ng Conference, the Policy Review amended ught of any icsoldilons carried ar the Conference. In addition, the "Campaign document', , to be drawn up by a joint meeting of the NEC and Labour's Shadow Cabinet and printed in early 1990, should "reflect" both successful Policy Reports and resolutions.

This procedure is not quite what the Labour leadership wanted -they will now have to justify preferring the Policy Review Reports over contrary Conference resolutions. Nevertheless, it is still very far from the idea of Conference sovereignty and democratic procedure.l Phrases like amending "in the light of and "reflecting" are a bureaucratic dream. And it is clear that it won't be Conference making the final decision. If the 1989 Party Conference decides for unilateralism but also carries a Policy Review Report which fudges on the question - and it may well do so - then it takes little imagination to work out on which side the solidly pro-Kinnockite NEC and Shadow Cabinet will come down.

The procedure is undemocratic. Constituency Labour Parties should send resolutions to Walworth Road and the NEC demanding the right to amend the Policy Review Reports, and insisting on the basic democratic right that Party members, through Party Conference, should determine Party policy. handed down from on high? It's a very igh? It's a very disturbing prospect and not just going not just going Him Howells, the research officer for the South Wales NUM, has been selected as Labour candidate for the Pontypridd by-election.

The NUM's gain becomes the Labour: Party's liability.

I've never seen eye to eye with Kim Howells, I have a suspicion that Kim Howells was one of those instrumental in organising a return to work without a settlement. I may be banging an old drum, but 1 am firmly convinced that we could have won that strike. If the NUM had stood firm then the entire political scene of this country would have been significantly altered.

But certain individuals panicked. Supposedly we finished up with a draw, but in reality we lost.

Paul Whetton is Manton NUM.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 387

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →