Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

8 THE MINORITY MOVEMENT When British Marxists led one mill

Socialist Organiser no. 387, 2 February 1989 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 3,560 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Socialists trade unior A Socialist Organiser 1924-5, like today, was a paried of setbacks for the E-ling class. The angine ting worker had been teady defatad in a lock-out in 1921-2. Trade union car harship was falling- Yet the then-revolutionary ET Tit Party manage 1 to s-gmniss rank-a-d-fle cat-k, the Minority Maur 1 which at its peak had the affiliations of one-quarter of all the trade misrists in Britain. David Black tells the story, in the first of a series of ba grand articles for Sarialist O-guirer's Indust-ial #hool on 18-19 The Minority Morome was fu in August 1924 after almost two years of considerable preparations by the a Party: mart, the new rise in labour willey, and in the -gaid if of writing silem -grt the cilitat Despite having taken a principled i stand in the struggles of the ama in 1922, the Communist * Party had found the ground cut from beneath its feet by reverses which it had been ples to prevent.

The actual conditions of NUPE still says Stop the and the weekend school Saturday and Sunday February 18/19 Manchester Polytechnic Students Union Oxford Rood, Manchester contact Tom on 01 639 7965 o 1 Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

To march in the 1920s inside the trade unions became increasingly difficult. The defeats of 1921-2 where the employer had taken on the working class section by section and won, had created massive demoralisation and lengthened the dole queues to 2½ millions.

Under the pressure of these defeats, the Party leadership adapted to the prevalent moods in the working class and tended to dismiss the positility of creating a real working class base in the next round of struggles.

This too-pestic approach was reflected in the speech of !! COTT Murphy, a Central -member of the CP at the Fourth Congress of the Ca Communist Lemmel: "In England we have rad a powerful Shop Stewurus and. But it can and only does exist given cale -i These necessury =1 at the moment in England do not exist... You cannot build factory organisations in empty and depleted workshops, while you have a great reservoir of unempicyed workers".

By early 1924, the Communist Party had become so infected with defeatism on the industrial front, that the Red International of Labour Unions (RILU) intervened directly. The work of the British section of the RILU was severely criticised for its sectarianism at a time when the class was beginning to recover from the demoralisation of the defeats of 1921-2.

The Executive of the RILU pinpointed the defects of the Party's apprach when it stated: ". the work of the British Bureau does not keep pace with the red#irements and possibilities of the present labour movement of Britain". short the Cr —in Party was idle in the face of new and sharo developments in the class struggle. The transformation of the old purely propagandist groups which had united under the name of the - Party in 1920 and into a real Co- → Part! actively involved in the everyday struggles of the working class, had still to take place.

Consequently the Executive of the RILU fought fiercely for a rapid re-organisatium of the industria vork of the Communist Party. Th main emphasis of the fight was placed on the urgent necessity of constructing revolutionary minority groups in all sections of industry -and with these groups, a strong national leadership.

William Gallacher, a former leading Clydeside shop steward, was set the task of convening a national conference to forge these minority movements into a unified body of national character.

The success of these new departures was of prime importance to the struggle against the right wing inside the TUC whose treachery had paved the way for the massive defeats of 1921-2. The new wave of class struggles afforded tremendous opportunities to the revolutionary wing inside the unions. With the correct tactics, the Communist Party would be able to win around it those dedicated fighters and working class militants who had not rallied to it previously, laying broad folations for a struggle to replace the burcaucracy of the trade union movement with an organised rank and file revolutionary leadership.

This crucial tactical turn towards the mass of militants inside the unions was not, however, met with unqualified in the leadership of he is a Party. William Allan, a leading CP member, described the reception given to the new policy: "...at the beginning of the National Minority Movement, considerable time was spended to fight down the belief that there was no room for a movement dealing with and 'narrow' ecommie issues, that it was a reformist conception, and that such an orgarion would stand in front of and hide the face of the party from the workers. Sneering descriptions of the NMM were given in the Party as being an attempt to dress a red man in a pink cloak". . This sort of attitude caused the delays in callng a national conference to launch the movement.

More through the efforts of Party rank and filers and trade union militants than anything else, a national = * formed a Miners Minority Morement in January 1924, after a series of district conferences in all the coalfields. The conference decisions reflected the growing determination of the working class to join battle once more with the — It resolved that district were to be set up in South Wales, Durham, Lancs, Cheshire, Yorkshire, Nottingham and Scotland.

On 16th February 1924 the Miners' Minority Movement launched a newspaper, the Mineworker, whose Campaigning focal point was the call for the transformation of the Miners Federation into a national industrial union, the United Mineworkers Union, affiliated to the Red International of Labour Unions. Other demands included the six-hour day and or real wages to be equivaleni to the real wage in 1914J The biggest achievement of the Miners' section, however, occurred soon after the establishment of the movement. Frank Hodges, the right wing Secretary of the Miners' Federation, resigned to take a post in the Labour Government and the left winger AJ Cook was elected secretary by a majority of 15,000. This development was also intimately connected with the recovery of the miners from the defeat of 'Black Friday' Elsewhere, however, the progress of the movement was somewhat slower. Proposals for broad agitation in the engincaring union were uttered but largely not 4. Only at the end of May had sufficient preparations been made to organise local conferences, of which one took place in Manchester and one in Edinburgh.

The support for the Conferences enabled the CP's Central Industrial Committee to launch immediately a Metal Workers Minority Movement. Despite this early success, the pace of deal tman was still slow. Conferences were planned for other districts but did not take paice.

These temporary difficulties did not deter the CP, which sought to draw out the lessons of the workers' struggles to date. The Sixth Party Congress of May 1924 assessed the situation thus: "The bankruptcy of the burcuucracy has brought into existence fighting groups of workers in all parts of the country, all battling for a fighting policy for the Trade Union morement. These groups are gradually being coordinated into what has become chown as The Minority Movement the new anc encouraging sign of the spirit that will one day overwrite all sade in the path of working class emancipution... The O Party has on all occasions assisted in the development of this movement, and will continue to do so, but at the same time warns those active workers who port pat in it, that only a revolutionary Communior struggle can serve to achieve the object they have in view".

By August 1924, the stage was set for the first national confercuce of the Minority Movement, which was held in London. The gathering was attended by 270 c==galea. representing almost 200,000 workers, and united the individual rank and file movements, formulated a programme of action and arranged for the election of an executive committee and a general scurciary.

The conference was parteelery timely in that the Labour governnent of McDonald. had had 8 mon hs of goverument and wide sec tions of the working class were moving into conflict with it. Also, it was a genuine attempt on the part of the CP to break from the sterile In TyPe sectarianism that had plagued so much of its earlier industrial work, creating the opportunity for its transformation from a tiny prep ganda group, into potentially a mass party with deep roots in the working class.

The struggle to build strong national unofficial movements around Immediate demands was a step towards this mass revolutionary paty, as well as an organiser of the immediate working class struggle.

The lessons of Black Friday and the collapse of the Triple Alliance of railmen, miners and transport workers, had bitten deep in the minds of the militants, who felt the need for a movement which could provide an instrument of combat against the right wing inside the trade union leadership.

Hence, the first Conference focussed much of its attention on the battle for rank and file control over the union leaderships, in general, and the TUC General Council in particular.

The Minority Movement's Programme of Action minored this concern by calling for the setting up of workshop and factory committees, for representation of these committees on the Trades Council, for industrial unionism. and for the immediate affiliation of the National Unemployed Workers' Committee Muvement to the TUC These demands were designed to assert the strength of the rank and file in the unions and to make the union leaderships directly responsi ble to the rank and file.

The maugural conference also called for a strengthening of the General Council of the TUC, *to mobilise and concentrate all the forces of the working class movement for the purpose of opposing a united class front to the united class enemy."

This

Scan page 9

trade unionist MONDAY HA Striking dockers, East London 1926 formal contradiction to the stress which the Conference laid on fighting the right wing. Far from it! The delegates were fully aware of the urgency of a parallel growth of rank and file control over the General Council. This was implicit in the statement that "The reactionaries desire a General Council which will check and dissipate all advances by the workers. We of the Minority Movement desire a General Council which will bring into being a bold and audacious. General Staff of the trade union movement... We can guard against the General Council becoming a machine of the capitalists... by, in the first place and fundamentally, developing a revolutionary class consciousness among the trade union membership and, in the second place, by so altering the constitution of the General Council as to ensure that those elected thereon have the closest contact with the workers"] On these firm foundations the Movement experienced initial successes. Trade union activity was on the upswing, there was a partial economic recovery from the slump of 1921 to 1923 and unemployment fell slightly, all providing an impetus to the class struggle, with key sections moving into action to recoup the losses they had suffered at the hands of the employers in the past period.

Railmen, engineers, shipyard workers and dockers all filed new wage claims. Into this fray stepped the Minority Movement.

Substantial successes were gained and new affiliations were secured. March 1926 saw some 957,000 trade unionists organised in the Minority Movement. It was especially powerful in the coal industry, shortly to be the scene of major class conflict. By August 1925 Minority Movement branches had been formed in the mining areas and 16 miners' Lodges had affiliated.

Similar developments took place in the engineering industry. In fact, there were 153 engineering delegates at the next Minority Movement Conference. Further support was derived from substantial membership of the Movement among the East London tailoring and furniture trade workers, who were largely Jewish refugees from Tsarist oppression.

Given basis, was able to exercise considerable influence on the course of the class struggle. Under its pressure, the Miners' Federation of Great Britain leadership began to investigate the possibilities of a new Industrial Alliance between the members of the old Triple Alliance.

The Movement also achieved a partial success when the TUC Congress of 1925 accepted a resolution empowering the General Council to organise support for stoppages. However, the resolution - framed by the 'left' union leader, Hicks -was so vaguely worded as to be meaningless. Understandably the Minority Movement was dissatisfied with it and stepped up its campaign to urge the TUC leaders to prepare for the coming fight.

Right through to the General Strike, the Minority Movement commanded increasing support, forcing union leaders leftwards and succeeding in having parts of the Programme of Action adopted as union policy. The strength of the Minority Movement was demonsrated by the fact that in July 1925, the TUC was forced to ally itself to the miners and make the • Tory government retreat on 'Red Friday' Get at this crucial point, when the Communist Party was clothing the fight for a revolutionary working class leadership in real flesh and blood, the tactics of the Minority Movement began to change.

This change owed its origin to the first manifestations of the growing tendency of the incipient Stalinist regime in Russia to put the programme of world revolution in second place, subordinationg it to a reliance on "progressive forces" whose task was to 'neutralise' the hostility of imperialism to the young workers' state in Russia, In Britain, this change found its expression in the Anglo-Kussian Trade Union Committee, which would supposedly offset the vicious anti-Soviet outlook of the British capitalist class. All the bold warriors - Purcell, Hicks and Swales - who were to be instrumental in betraying the General Stike, were to be found under the canopy of the Anglo-Russian Committee. They exploited a cheap and empty 'left' (pro-Soviet) image in foreign policy to cover a rightist and bureaucratic trade union policy at home, where it meant something in practice. And it was to this wing of the trade union bureaucracy that the Minority Movment was tied.

In return for the dubious friendship of bureaucrats towards the USSR, the CP and Minority Movment began to sacrifice their political independence. The depth of the change is best signified by reference to two statements from leaders of the Communist Party.

1924: "It would be a suicidal policy ... for the CP and MM to place too much reliance on what we have called the official left-wing". JR Campbell in Communist 1925: "The left trade union leaders occupy at present the posttion not only of the workers in the immediate crisis, but also of the spokesmen of the working class elements in the CP... and alternative political leadership" (Palme-Dutt in "Inprecor').

The fight to prepare the rank and file in the local areas was muted and limited by the exigencies of the alliance, and the activity of the MM was directed towards presenting the "lefts' as a leadership that could smash the capitalist offensive. On the eve of the General Strike, then the revolutionary movement was effectively paralysed and the independence of the revolutionary workers' party heavily compromis ed.

This was the tragedy of 1926, and everything the Movement did prior to the strike, during the strike and after it was coloured by this policy. The Councils of Action, built up ir the previous period and designed to co-ordinate the rank and file against the bureaucracy were turned over to this policy, being transformed into ginger-groups instead of embryonic organs of working class The CP and the MM failed to play an independent revolutionary role in the strike, despite the courageous efforts of party members in some districts. Possessed by the idea that it was not on the cards to challenge the domination of the TUC leadership, it raised the preposterous slogan "All Power to the TUC" . That is, to the uncontrolled bureaucracy that was blantantly selling out the strike.

Even the betrayal did not shake the Party leaders off this course. Only a few weeks after the end of the General Strike the Central Committee sought to head off great criticism in the ranks with the warning that "There will be a reaction within our Party against working with left wing leaders. We must right down this natural feeling and get better contact with these leaders and more mass pressure on them." In other words, not only dig your own grave, but pay for the use of the shovel!

Throughout the period of continuing ferment after the end of the strike the barcaucrats benefitted enormously from the restraint of the CP and MM and the left cover they provided. When they had ridden out the storm, they then broke up — in late 1927 — the Anglo Russian Committee, and launched a ferocious witch-hunt against the Minority Movement.

The refusal to learn from the bankrupt policy of pressurising the sham Lefts marked the beginning of the end for the Minority Moment and the Communist Party) as a revolutionary force.

This policy was taken to extraordinary lengths by the Communist Party leaders so that when the TUC General Council instructed trades councils to disaffiliate from the Minority Movement at the end of 1927 the CP advised them to obey! The policy, together with the demoralisation and defeat which descended on the working class led to a sharp decline in the Minority Movement.

The sharp turn left of the world Communist movement was to kill the Minority Movement stone dead. Having subordinated to the union bureaucrats in a period when the working class could have pushed them aside, the CP after mid-1929 suddenly appeared to go mad. Not only the bureaucrats were now declared bankrupt — but the trade unions too!

Already weakened by its incapacity to assimilate the lessons of 1926, the Minority Movement indulged in the idiotic antics of the Stalinst ultra-left Third Period, attempting to set up 'pure' revolutionary breakaway unions (eg the United Mineworkers of Scotland), and describing everything outside these bodies a "social-fascist - thus writing off the majority the class who were concentrated the reformist unions.

This period was adequately summed up by Brian Pearce in his 1959 article "Some Past Rank and File Movements": "Characteristic of the 1929-31 period was a growing disparity between slogans and achievements. During the Bradford: wollen strike of 1930, for instance, the Minority Movement shouted to bewildered workers about "The Struggle for Power" — but proved incapable of setting up a single independent mill committee. The shouting to workers to come to be led, with a general strike as 'the next step, grew louder and shriller...

Admist this 'growing disparity between slogans and achievements", the Minority Movement was allowed to die slowly up to 1932, when it was finally buried When after about 1934-5 the Communist Party emerged from the ultra-left binge of the Third period its trade union policy rapidly became one of blatant subordination to the union machines and bureaucrats, its prime goal the capture of union office and positions. Rank and file direct action to smash bureaucratic control of the unions was forgotten in favour of gaining positions within the bureaucracy.

development was the model revolutionary opposition movement in the unions. Led by communists; but having no formal connection with the Party, it was able to win hundreds of thousands to its revolutionary policies of struggle against both the ruling class and its. bureaucratic mainstays in the trade union movement. This broad front of militants could - given the leadership of a powerful communist party, capable of ruthless self-criticism - have created the basis for the mass revolutionary workers' party. The very growth of the movement pointed to the fact that. key sections of workers were breaking from the road of reformism. But when they looked for leadership it was not forthcoming.

Today's tasks bear close similarity to those of 1925. A nationally organised mass rank and file movement is a vital necessity at a time when the TUC leaders left' and "right' are in headlong retreat before the Tories.

In building such a movement we must learn from the Minority movement.

There are tremendous possibilities for such a movement today. However, militants must be clear on one thing: that pressure politics alone are useless. This is the lesson which we must learn from the Minorty Movement. Any pressure we put on today's union leaders must be backed up by the most detailed preparations to remove them and replace them by a militant leadership and socialist policies. Without this, pressure politics can only play into the hands of the bureaucracy.

Our attitude to 'our leaders' must be firmly based on the central conception of the Minority Movement in its early days: that we ally with those leaders only as long as they identify themselves with the militants and actively fight the right wing. Or as TA Jackson an early Communist Party leader put it: we may take them by the hand in order (if they retreat) to take them by the throat. Only this way can we carve out the path to victory over the enemy class once and for all First published in Workers' Fight no. 11, 23 July 1972.

----- pull-quotes -----

he Minority Movement I in the early stages of det

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 387

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →