A compromise for peace
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-02-02Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
errin #Israeli or Palestinian workers.
The problem with most of the Israeli left is its inability to relate to the working class. Whilst the Palestinian question rightly oc-cupies the centre of Israeli politics, this need not exclude a class perspective.
Most socialists tend to focus on the position of Palestinian labour -vithin the Israeli economy, but the mistoric militancy of Israeli workers should be noted. The question is whether Israeli workers can be won o the cause of peace.
The majority of the Israeli working class is composed of Oriental -ews. Peace organisations have -eveloped in this community, chief¡ 'East for Peace' and the 'Oriental front', but the overriding tereotype is that Oriental Jews mathe the Arabs. Much of the sraeli Left has either fed or ignored mis stereotype.
Why does it exist? Oriental Jews -end to vote for the right, or the mystic religious parties, because hey have been alienated from the -istadrut and the Labour Party. In ther words, an irony is at work; in srael, Oriental Jewish workers per-eve the "labour movement' as an exploiter. The Likud has used this i several ways, one argument being at a Palestinian State would lead › Oriental Jews performing the -enial jobs previously done be salestinians.
But the Oriental Jewish response as not always been reactionary. In se 1970s, the 'Black Panther" -ovement organised in slum wighbourhoods. One of their remands was for an independent ralertinian State, and many of today's Oriental Jewish peace activists have their roots in the Black Panthers.
If the Israeli left is to be taken seriously it must gain the support of Oriental Jews by campaigning against economic exploitation and cultural discrimination.
Israel's economy is currently insevere crisis, and the government's response is another austerity programme at the expense of the workers. Many factories have closed, meeting with angry reaction.
When the "Alliance' company announced the closure of their Haifa plant, workers occupied the factory. A police raid met with brave resistance, and shouts of 'this is our intifada'!
One women, referring to her two sons in military service, commented: 'One son in the tanks, one in Golani (an elite regiment), and look what the state does to me. Needless to say, the Histadrut was an active accomplice in crushing its members.
At the moment, the future direction of Israeli workers cannot be determined. But, as unemployment rises and living standards plummet, we should bear in mind the events of eight years ago. In 1981, 13 shop stewards organised 100,000 workers outside the framework of the Histadrut in protest against attacks on jobs and wages.
As the Israeli-Palestinian conflict reaches a new, crucial stage, the Israeli left should set about recognising the huge potential of the Israeli working class.
Information taken from 'The Other Israel" and News From Within' The Israeli socialist Adam Keller will be doing a speaking to in Britain on 11-24 February. In this article - reprinted from The Other Israel he explains his views on Be - the Israeli Coun for Israeli-Palestini: - Peace - want a peac ful solution to the Israe Palestinian conflict.
This solution is to be achievi through peace negotiations betwer the Israeli government and tl Palestinian Liberation Organisatic (PLO), the withdrawal of Israt forces from the territories occupie in 1967 and the creation of Palestinian state in the West Bar and Gaza Strip, Everything, so far, is easy for n to write, though it is not at all ea:
to achieve this solution in realit There, I stand on firm moral an political ground.
But answering your mai question, regarding the Palestiniar who became refugees in 1948, is fa more difficult and painful. I wil nevertheless, try to answer it and t be as frank as I can.
I am very much aware of the far that, in the process of bein created, the state of Israel cause great harm to the Palestinia people; that the society of which am a part has displaced an destroyed another society.
The house where I live, in the Tel Aviv suburb of Holon, is new; don't know to whom this plot o Land belonged before 1948. I d know that the university where studied for my BA is located on th site of the Palestinian villag Sheikh-Munis and that th Saturdey 4 Fabrua. / Alternative Policy Review' Conference. Queen Mary College, E. Saturday 4 Februa Viraj Mendis Defence Committee Demonstration from Church of the Ascension, Royce Road, Hulme, Manchester 15, 12.30 Sunday 5 February NE London Socialist Organiser meeting: 'The state of the unions* Speaker Tom Rigby. Angel & Crow pub, Upper St, N1, 7.30 Monday 6 Fabruart Manchester SO meeting: Debate with Socialist Outlook on the Eastern Bloc. Speakers John O'Mahony, Phil Hearse, Millstone pub, 7.30 Monday 6 Fet Nottingham SO meeting: "Why PLO went for "two states'" Speaker Paul McGarry. ICC, Mansfield Rd, 7.30 Monday 6 F-trusy London SO educational series: New Unionism and the first Ma Groups, *. Bruce Robinson, Cons Hall, Red Lion Sq, WC1. 7.30 headquarters of the trade union of which I am a member is where Sumeil village used to be.
Wherever I go in Israel I encounter ruined Arab houses, or cactuses which once marked the boundary of an Arab field. When I travel on an Israeli road, I find junctions which everybody still calls by the name of a village that disappeared forty years ago.
All Israelis are, in one way or another, aware of this - even though many try to hide the knowledge from themselves. For many, guilty teelings have turned into fear and hatred. For many an Israeli the mere thought of the refugees coming back has become a nightmare, the nightmare of himself being uprooted and becoming a homeless refugee.
Many Israelis believe that peace with the Palestinians is impossible.
They perceive the conflict as a savage struggle for survival, in which one side wins and the other is destroyed; therefore, they oppose making even the slightest concession to the Palestinians. It is from deep-rooted fear that the Israeli right-wing draws its power.
I have spent nearly twenty years of my life trying to convince my fellow Israelis that we can - and must - make peace; that our government should sit down and Saturday 11 Felnia.y "ABC' student activists' weekend conference. Octagon Centre, Sheffield, 12.00. Contact Mark: 01 63! 7967 Saturday 11 Fabruary Marxism Today 'New Times, New Thinking' conference. Caxton House, St Johns Way, N19, 10.00 Sunday 12 F-t./ Socialist Student dayschool. Octagon Centre, Sheffield, 12.00. Contact Mark: 01 639 7967 Sunday 12 February Adam Keller tour meeting: "The struggle for Palestinian-Israeli peace' , Sheffield.
Sunday 12 February Cardiff SO meeting. Speaker John O'Mahony Monday 13 February Adam Keller tour meeting: 'The Struggle for Palestinian-Israeli peace'. Conway Hall, Red Lion Sq, WC1, 7.30 Wednesday 15 February Adam Keller tour meeting, Wedeesday 15 Fetruerf Adam Keller tour meeting, Thursday 16 February Adam Keller tour meeting, tie Friday 17 Fetnuary Adam Keller tour meeting, chester Satarday 18 Fet....../ Socialist Organiser Industrial weekend school (two days).
talk with the Palestinian leadership.
I think that despite all the horrors now being daily perpetrated in the occupied territories, this moment is coming nearer.
When our leaders will, at last, sit and talk, there will have to be at least a basic form of justice for those who have already lived in refugee camps for forty years.
But there will not be pure and complete justice. The best political solution which I believe could be achieved would mean that, in fact, only a few of the razed villages will be restored; that a limited number of the people now living in refugee camps will be allowed to live in the territory of the state of Israel, and — where this would not entail the uprooting of an existing Jewish community - on or near their original land; that the majority of the refugees will be offered citizenship of the Palestinian state, as a solution for their national problem, and monetary compensation - for their lost properties and for their decades of hardship.
realise that, in offering this solution to the Palestinians. 1 am asking them to make a big and painful sacrifice: to accept that the hope which they treasured for forty years was after all a dream; that the injustice which was done to them will not be undone.
Feisal Husseini stated - in the meeting with Peace Now which preceded his latest arrest - that, where the Palestinians' right to return is undebatable, the way ir which it should be impismented could be discussed. I am aware how much Husseini had to overcome before he could move in this direction.
If both the Israeli government and the PLO adopted this way of thinking. it would not remove all the pain and injustice of the past -but for a new generation of Israelis and Palestinians. such a compromise could mean future without bloodshed, in which the mutual hatred could gradually dissolves chester Poly Student Tom: 01 639 7965 Monday 20 Fab.../ Adam Keller tour meeting, Liverpool Monday 20 Fabi-lT London SO education series: 'The formation of the Labour Party'. Cathy Nugent. Conway Hall, Red Lion Sq, WC1, 7.30 Tuesday 21 Fatruary Adam Keller tour meeting.
Wadatedey 22 February Adam Keller tour meeting, Sat-dey 25 February Stop the Killings! Picket Iraqi Cultural Centre, Tottenham Ct London W1, 1.00 S-i-der 25 February Women for Socialism two-day conference. Wesley House, Wild Court, London WC2. Contact Ruth Clarke, 7 Cumberland Park, London W3; 01 992 0945 Saturday 8 April Gorbachev & the European Left conference (two days). ULU, Malet St, London WC1. Contact Gus Fagan, 30 Bridge St, Oxford OX2 S-t-Jcy 17 June Socialist Conference Third Conference (two days). Octagon Centre, Sheffield Sandey 8 July Workers' Liberty summer (two days), London
----- pull-quotes -----
the 'right of return' of the Palestinians.
ACTIVISTS DIARY