Should v write off Israeli workers?
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-02-02Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Israeli society has been profoundly shaken by the impact of the intifada.
In the past year, the myth of a maintainable status quo in the Occupied Territories has been shattered, the uneasy National Unity government has won another term and the PLO has recognised Israel's right to exist. The political situation is one which constantly accumulates contradictions, and the hope in Washington, Moscow, Jerusalen and Tunis is that the diplomatic process will iron these out.
However, the respective parties involved have a different idea of what this diplomatic process actually constitutes.
Where is the Israeli left in all this? On 24 December Peace Now held a 20,000 strong demonstration in Tel Aviv calling on the government to open a dialogue with the PLO. This marked an important new stage in the development of the Israeli Peace Movement; for the first time, a mainstream organisation raised a demand which had previously been the preserve of groups further to the left (in Israel, 'right' and 'left' is determined by where you stand on the Palestinian question).
It also displyaco im casing: divisions within the Israeli Labour Party. Among those addressing the Peace Now rally were senior Labour Party figures disillusioned with the "softly, softly" appruach of the Peres leadership.
There is, then, a new configuration in Israeli politics which socialists need to assess. I will begin by looking at the positions of various groups on the left vis-a-vis the Palestinians, at the same time analysing some wider issues in relaWHERE WE STAND Socialist Organicer stands for workera liberty East and West.
We aim to help c-y- the left wing in the Labour Party and trade unions to fight to replace capitaliem with working class =-i-liWe want public ownership of the major enterprise and a Get Socialist Organiser delivered to your door by post. Rates (UK) £8.50 for six months, £16 for year.
Address.
Please send me 6/12 months sub. I enclose £.. .. Send to: Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA tion to the Israeli working class.
By far, the biggest parliamentary organisation in what we can broadly call the Israeli left is the Labour Party (Mapai). Mapai and its percursors were the dominant current in the Zionist movement until 1977, when the right wing Likud, under Menachem Begin, won the general A member of the Socialist InterZionism. In reality, Mapai is far from being a workers' party. Rather, it represents the interests of the bureaucracy controlling the Histadrut (Israeli Labour Federation), which is also the country's largest employer. Mapai favours "territorial compromise' as a solution to the Palestinian issue, but this stops short of talking to the PLO and of recognising the Palestinian right to an independent state alongside Israel.
Further left is Mapam,. the United Workers' Party. It is also heavily involved in the Histadrut, but Mapam's record of defending workers in disputes that conflict with the interests of the Histadrut bourgeoisie is better than that of Mapai.
Mapam is vocal in the Peace Movement and advocates talks with the PLO. Yair Tsaban, a Mapam Knesset Member, recently met with PLO officials in Paris in defiance of the 1986 law forbidding contact with an 'enemy organisation'.
Close to Mapam is Ratz (Citizens' Rights Movement). Ratz campaigns vigorously against religious coercion, promotes women's rights and favours a twostate solution with the PLO as a partner in dialogue. However, Ratz supports the 'liberalisation' of the Israeli economy and voted in favour of the 1985 austerity programme IGmocracy much fuller thai her control. We wan the present Westminster system - a workers' democracy, with elected ---- I at any time, and an end to bureaucrats' and - = privileges.
c--i-li- can never be built in one country alone. The workers in every country have i other somes than with their own capitalist or sticis rulers. We support national liberation struggles and workers' struggles worldwide, including the struggle of SOCIALIST 613181518 anchora, Tel Aviv attacked wage levels and subsidies, e other two leftist parties in the iet are the Democratic Front eace and equality and the Prowurkers and pressed nationalities the Stalinist states against their own anti-socialist bureaucracies.
We stand:
For full it for women. and social provision to free women from the burden of -k. For a mass working class-based women's movement.
Againet racism, and against deportatione and all immigra tion contele.
For equality for Ett and gays.
For a united and free Ireland, with some federal system to protect the rights of the Protestant minority.
For left unity in action; clariy in debate and sir or a labour mc--- ac cessible to the most oppressed, ass-Hlc to its rank and file, and militant against eria-f-m We want Labour Party and trade union -f-. who support our basic ideas to become suffice of the paper - to take a bundle of papers to sell each week and pay a small contribution to help meet the paper's deficit. Our policy is demonadeally contelled by our supporters through Annual General Meetings and an elected National Editorial Board. gressive List for Peace. The DFPE is a coalition of groups, the main current being the Israeli Communist Party (Chadash).
Chadash has traditionally been an agent of Soviet directives and is highly sectarian, especially when it comes to the PLP. The Party supports two states, recognises the PLO as the legitimate representatives of the Palestinians and picks up most of its support from Israeli Arabs.
Far healthier is the PLP, a joint Jewish Arab party which is a coalition of Jews from the 'Alternativa' group and Arabs from the Peace Movement.
The PLP supports two states and holds regular contact with the PLO. It is close to the Israeli Council for Israeli-Palestinian Peace, which publishes the radical newsletter "The Other Israel'.
There is a myriad of peace organisations in Israel. The largest and most influential peace group is Peace Now.
Formed in 1978, Peace Now grew rapidly in the wake of the 1982 Israeli invasion of Lebanon. After the massacres in the Palestinian refugee camps of Sabra and Chatilla, Peace Now organised a huge domonstration of 400,000 -in relative terms, the equivalent to the whole of London attending a demonstration.
Whilst always cautious about talking to the PLO, Peace Now have called for direct negotiations following the PLO's Algiers Declaration. This is very important, since it frees the organisation. to a great extent, from its appearance as an appendage of the Labour Party.
Thre are, sizeable groups to the left of Peace Now, such as Dai La Kibbush (Stop the Occupation).
In the Israeli peace camp, there is a distinction between groups who specify borders between Israel and a Palestinian state and those who leave the question of territory open, mobilising simply against the Occupation for the immediate time. Dai La Kibbush and Hala ha Kibbush represent the former and latter trends respectively.
Many of the groups icprcount sectional interests. "Women in Black' is a women's group modelled on the Argentinian Organisation 'Mothers of Silence'. They hold weekly demonstrations in Jerusalem and Tel Aviv, and face frequent harrassment from Meir Kahane's racist "Kach' party.
Another sectional group is 'Yesh Gul' (There's a Limit) which organises soldiers who refuse to serve in the West Bank and Gaza Strip. Both support a two state solution.
An idea gaining currency amongst the liberal intelligensia is that of 'confederation'. This means a federated Israel and Palestine run along the same lines as Benelux, or the EC after 1992. It is something socialists should be wary of. None of the advocates of this solution have addressed the question of trade union organisation or the general issue of working class rights, although this isn't surprisSuch a framework would gruarantee the untrammelled manouevres of capital outside the boundaries of the nation-state, and although the Histadrut bureaucracy would on occasion conflict with private capital, neither group could be relied upon to defend either
----- pull-quotes -----
planned economy under -SUBSCRIBEE
national, the party's platform ostensibly synthesises socialism and
Britains death E penDst exposed!