Return to the Rock
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-02-02Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
N once again, to Death on o apologies for returning the Rock'. The importance of this whole affair - not least for what it tells us about the relationship between the government and the press — cannot be overstated.
The Windlesham/Rampton report overwhelmingly vindicated the programme. Windelsham, a Tory and former Northern Ireland Minister, together with Richard Rampton, a leading QC, were appointed by Thames to investigate the programme after a massive outcry in the press. They were both personally approved for the job by Home Secretary Hurd.
After painstaking four-month inquiry, Windlesham and Rampton concluded that the programme was fair, well-researched and without ulterior motives". There were three significant errors, but these "need to be set against the programme overall says the report.
The government's response was all too predictable. Mogadon Man Hurd bleated on about it being, "a report on television, by television for television" Defence Secretary Younger professed himself "absolutely astonished", etc etc. -This response not actually bothering to discuss the content of the report, but simply slagging it off as though its wrong headedness should be obvious to all reasonable folk was also the reaction of most of the press. The Sun (naturally) put it most crudely: **Thames Television can wriggle like a puff adder.
They can posture like Mick Jagger.
They can hold all the inquiries they wish into the truthfulness of witnesses and the integrity of their journalists.
But they cannot alter basic truths.
Their programme, Death on the Rock, was an irresponsible, mischievous, deeply harming episode.
It should NEVER have been made.
It should NEVER have been broadcast."
It's a bit difficult to argue against a powerful case like that, isn't it? The unanimity of the press (other than the Guardian the Independent and the usual suspects) in seeking to discredit Rampton has been remarkably similar to: their unanimity in attacking the programme when it first appeared.
much like their unanimity repeating the official government/MOD "line immediately after the shootings(the IRA people were armed, they were making threatening movements, warnings were given, there was a bomb nearby, etc etc).
The role of the Sunday Times in all of this bears further scrutiny. While the Sun and the tabloids libelled witness Carmen Proetta as "The Whore of Gib' language, and gave the campaign a respectable gloss by claiming that witness Josie Celecia and Stephen Bullock 'destroyed' Proetta's evidence.
When Bullock objected to this, ST editor Andrew Neil responded with a typically nasty campaign to smear him as well. Bullock has now issued a writ against Neil and the ST which may account for the ST's admission this week that it "did make mistakes" in its coverage.
I'll leave the last word (for now) to Richard Ingrams writing in this week's Observer. He asks the obvious question and gives the obvious answer; it's the first time I've seen it spelled out so clearly in any national paper:
... "how [did] so many newspapers come to print SO many inaccurate misleading and, in some cases, libellous stories all in support of the Government's case?
Were any inquiry to be mounted into this propaganda campaign, it is more than likely we would find the gentlemen from MIS busily engaged in spreading lies and disinformation.
----- pull-quotes -----
PRESS GANG
Murdoch's 'quality" Sunday repeated the allegations in more tasteful