Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Rushdie and principles

Socialist Organiser no. 387, 2 February 1989 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 1,590 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Men thousand Muslims marched through London on Saturday 28 January demanding the banning of Salman Rushdie's 'Satanic Verses'.

His publishers, Penguin, have been doing a roaring trade since the controversy struck, and are unlikely to pay much attention. Financial motives notwithstanding, it is good if Penguin resist such pressure. The banning (still worse, the burning) of books is the sign of a repressive society.

The emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all human beinys without distinction of sex or race' Karl Marx Socialist Organiser PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. Phone 01-639 7965.

atest date for reports: first post Monday or by phone Monday evening.

It would be wrong to believe for a. moment that intellectual intolerance is the preserve of Muslims. Various newspapers have: lamented the peculiarly bigoted character of Islam, while the London Evening Standard contrasted Islam with the "inherently' more enlightened Christian religion. A current TV series, "The Triumph of the West', , echoes this theme, defining Christianity as 'intrinsically self-critical".

This is a strange verdict on the history of Christianity — a religion which dominates the West because it was adopted by the notoriously intolerant Roman Empire, and later Typasatting: Upstream Ltd (TU), 01-358 1344.

Published by Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

Printed by Press Link International (UK) Ltd (TU). Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office. Signed articles do not necessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser inspired such historical episodes as the Crusades and the Spanish Inquisition.

More recently, Christianity and the charge of "blasphemy' have led to the refusal by several local authorities, and TV channels, to permit the showing of of Monty Python's 'Life of Brian'; to Mary Whitehouse's successful prosecution of Gay Times for blasphemous libel; and to the Rushdie-esque controversy over Martin Scorcese's "Last Temptation of Christ'.

This should be born in mind when the press and the right-wing more generally point to Islamic intolerance of "The Satanic Verses' as an example of Asian barbarism interfering with 'our' normally civilised behaviour. The call for Asians to go back to Asia where they can burn books with impunity has already been raised explicitly by Tory MPs.

Our opposition to book burning must not give aid to this kind of racism.

But defend free speech we must. So it is depressing to see several Labour politicians, including Bernie Grant and Jack Straw, join the call for Rushdie's book to be banned. One Labour MP has called for "blasphemous libel' to be extended to non-Christian religions.

Such a move would not be for religious freedom. | The blasphemy laws are themselves an outrageous leftover from the days when Church and State were closely linked: they are a feudal relic. Religious freedom is the right to practise any or no religion without hindrance; it is not the right to impose religious codes on society -for Muslims or any other religious group.

If Muslims are offended by Rushdie's book, that is regrettable. But they don't have to read it, any more than Christians have to go to "The Last Temptation' Rushdie's book is not an incitement to race hatred or religious bigotry. It is not, despite what one Bradford councillor has claimed, comparable to anti-semitic propaganda.

Rushdie has a perfect right to write a book critical of islam, treating Mohammed as a historical figure, or whatever. If the left joins the clamour to silence him, it will not be long before we too get our mouths shut for us.

An anti-democratic drift in socialist political culture has paved the way for the position taken by Bernie Grant and others under pressure of vote-catching opportunism. The left needs to stand up for free speech, and for secular laws.

Scan page 4

try thought control and imposition racist societies is pure ignorance, debacles in Brent and at Burnage and my right to say he's talking Rushdie's views are pessimistic racists will start to recognise that In official Labour Party A press release arrived on our desk this morning. *Labour warns of potential 1992 nightmare" screams the headline.

What could it be that has provoked the Labour leadership to such hysteria.

Tore sarea don. Lie the lader Neil Kinnock is on Monday to unveil shock new research on plans to scrap borders between European Community coun tries by 1992..." Oh, so that's what strikes horror into the hearts of Neil and his cronies.

Funny how petty little Englandism terests.

Last weekend saw the inaugural meeting in Moscow of the 'Memorial Movement': -The "Memorial Movement' is com mitted to commemorating the victims of Stalinism. They want a museum built and archives establish ed on Stalin's terior. Gorbachev is committed to this, but wants the project to be controlled by the Ministry of Culture. The 'Memorial Movement' activists want more democratic control.

The 500-strong delegate meeting at the weekend also demanded the freeing of the jailed Karabakh Com mittee, and the restoration of full citizenship to dissident novelist Alexander Solzhenitsyn. - These demands are far from likely to go down well with Mikhail Gor-c bachev.

The first issue of the movement's newspaper, which was due to contain an article on Solzhenitsyn, had= its print run summarily reduced from 30,000 to 5,000 and the Solzhenitsyn article censored.

There are also reports of a Memorial Movement' demonstration in Minsk having been broken up with teargas.

The meeting had an exhibition about Leon Trotsky, describing him as a victim of Stalinism. Trotsky is still officially a 'non-person' in the Prime is on the increase in China - and conservatives in the Party are blaming it on reform policies.

Last year, according to official figures, serious crime rose by 66% and crime overall by 45%. Around 80% of for a wide range of offences.

The government's reform programme allows freer movement of labour. Around 50 million 'transients" are on the move in China, picking up -casual work where and when they can.

China's conservative bureaucrats are -blaming the crime increase on these itinerant workers, in order to discredit the reform programme. The cause though is far more likely to be found "in social dislocation and grinding poverty:

British Rail have just announced a new plan improving 'customer care.

In the wake of reports on severe overcrowding on trains, and of lapses in safety procedures, maybe these are the areas to be targeted?

No. This radical new measure is.a ban on rail workers wearing trade union badges! This will apparently drastically improve the quality of 'customer care' and also be far more in line with BR's friendly new corporate image. - So the next time you're unable to get a seat in a train, and end up standing for two hours in the guard's van, you can rest assured that at least your sensibilities won't be offended by the sight of an NUR badge. T James Pickles, well known he notorious Judge for his ability to find excuses for sex-offenders, has done it again.

A man who admitted getting into bed with a six year old girl he was babysitting, and sexually assaulting her, was given two years probation by W family from Small ithin the past week a Heath in Birmingham has taken sactury in Birmingham Central Mosque. This is a desperate attempt by Amir Kabul Khan, his wife, Zahtoon, and their children, live Bradley (SO 385) and Eric Heffer (SO 386) are right to defend Salman Rushdie's 'Satanic Verses' from any undemocratic attempt to ban or burn it. It's a pity that Rushdie has not been such a consistent democrat himself when it comes to fighting racism.

A Rushdie article in New Society (December 1982) entitled "The New Empire Within Britain' is considered very good coin by many anti-racist educationalists. According to Rushdie, "400 years of conquest" and "being told you are superior to...the wogs" has left its stain on "all" white people in Britain. Whilst other countries, like Germany, have made valiant attempts to combat racism, Rushdie believes that "the British may be the only people on earth who feel nostalgic for pillage and conquest and war" irrespective of their general attitudes or social class. Worse still, says Rushdie, "It is possible that this blindness (racism) is incurable."

Such views are widely held among, original sin approachand not surprisingly leads to undemocratic practices.

If white people are all incurable racists, what's the point of open democratic persuasion? Why not d for Arzoo (4) and Ramiz (2) to stay together against the attempts of the immigration authorities to seize Amir Kabul and deport him.

The couple were married in 1983 when Amir made a visit to this country. Amir returned with his wife to Pakistan where they lived together for a year.

Zahtoon came back to England to give birth to her daughter, and Amir applied to join them. He was Demonstration against 'Satanic Verses"

instead? Sadly, many did, hence the High School. and undemocratic, but mostly they right. are grossly inaccurate. To single out Britain as unique in a world full of refused on the grounds that the 'primary purpose' of his marriage was to gain settlement in the UK.

In 1986 Amir was again refused a visitor's visa but was allowed to enter the country on a temporary basis.

Please write to the Home Secretary at Queen Annes Gate, London. Quote the Home Office Reference No. TH/133314.

Amir Kabul Defence Committee, 723 Coventry Rd, Birmingham 10 I defend Rushdie's right to speak nonsense. I hope heland other antiLiam Conway N-tti=gham

----- pull-quotes -----

comes far more naturally to Labour's. leadership than defending workers in

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 387

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →