There's no ruling class in USSR
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-01-25Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Stan Crooke takes issue with one element of our recent arguments on the Eastern Bloc, contending that the bureaucrats are not a ruling class. (Part 3 of Vladimir Derer's article has been delayed and will appear next week.)
Marxist analysis of A society proceeds from, and in fact is, an analysis of the means whereby surplus labour is extracted from the immediate producer.
Marx spelt it our in Das Kapital': "The specific economic form in which unpaid surplus labour is pumped out of direct producers determines the relationship of rulers and ruled, as it grows directly out of production itself and, in turn, reacts upon it as a determining clement...
It is always the direct relationship of the owners of the conditions of production to the direct producers... which reveals the innermost secret, the hidden basis of the entire social structure, and with it the political form of the relationship of sovereignty and dependence, in short, the corresponding political form of the There can be only two possible regulators for the supply and extraction of human social labour: direct social regulation (either "customary' as in feudalism, or conscious as in communism) or the blind workings of the price-form (ie. where the product of social labour has the commodity form and is an exchange value, as in capitalism). In relation to the Eastern Bloc states the problem — both for those attempting an analysis and also for the bureaucracies attempting to rule -is that neither of these two possible regulators operates.
The former (direct social regulation) could operate only on the basis of socialist democracy. Conscious regulation of human labour (ie. planning) is possible only in a situation of free association of the immediate producers. Such circumstances manifestly do not pertain in the Eastern Bloc states. Hence the impossibility of such a IR A SOCIALIST ORGANISER PAMPHLET 80 PENCI regulator functioning in these states.
The latter (the blind workings of the price-form) could operate only where labour power is a commodity. But for the labour power to be a commodity in the Soviet Union (or anywhere else) it would have to be bought and sold on a • labour market, and the wage paid would have to be in return for labour-time.
Such circumstances manifestly do not pertain in the Soviet Union and other Eastern Bloc countries. Workers can move around the country, within limits, but this is not the same as the existence of a labour market; and what the worker receives in the pay packet might be a "wage" in name, but in reality, given the secondary and limited role played by money in the Soviet economy, it is more akin to a ration card for withdrawing from the net product produced.
In other words, and put more plainly:
a) Production in the Eastern Bloc states does not take place on the basis of a plan. There cannot be a plan because there is no democracy. (It is true that orders are given, and that some are partially obeyed, after a fashion. But giving commands about production is something different from the planning of production).
b) Production in the Eastern Bloc states is not governed by the workings of the capitalist "free market". This cannot be the case because there is no market (or any other of the categories of capitalism) in these states.
This explains inuch about the features of the Eastern Bloc states - the atomisation of the working class, the acute instability of the bureaucracies, the low quality of Eastern Bloc products, the constant failure to meet the "plan" targets, the inherent problems in the in troduction of new technology, etc., etc. However, the point at issue here is what the above means with regard to the existence or otherwise of a "ruling class" in the Eastern Bloc states.
Just as the defining feature of society is how unpaid surplus labour is pumped out of the direct producer, SO too, it logically follows, the defining feature of a ruling class (ie. what makes a group of people a ruling class in reality and not just in name) is control over the surplus product.
It is control over the surplus product which is the crucial category, A Socialis Organiser pamphlet.
Available
from PO Box SE15 4NA, for 80p plus 13p postage. Gorbachev: no control over surpiu: not oppressiveness (all ruling classes are oppressive; but oppressiveness in itself does not make the agents of oppression a "ruling class") nor "ownership of the means of production" (the belief that "ownership of the means of production" is the criterion of a "ruling class" is a Stalinist invention; Marx himself never said any such thing).
Given that the Stalinist bureaucracy does not, and cannot, exercise control over the surplus product, it cannot be a "ruling class" in any Marxist sense. The individuals who constitute the bureaucracy have no control over the surplus product as individuals. Nor does the bureaucracy collectively have control over the surplus product.
The individual capitalist has control over a share of the surplus produce of society because, by definition, he/she disposes of capital. The situation of the individual bureaucrat in the Eastern Bloc states is quite different. He/she cannot dispose of state property for their own immediate gain because it is not theirs to dispose of. He/she cannot decide what a particular enterprise will produce because (at least nominally) this is decided upon by the "plan"
He/she cannot even act in line with the "plan" because of the fictional nature of the latter. As an individual bureaucrat (in contrast to the position of the individual capitalist) he/she therefore exercises no control over the surplus product.
But the bureaucracy collectively does not exercise control over the surplus product either. As explained above, neither of the two possible regulators for the supply and extraction of human labour function in the Eastern Bloc states. The "plan" does not give them control of the surplus product because, in the absence of democracy, there is no plan.
Nor can the bureaucracy exercise control over the surplus product through market mechanisms, given that these are absent - at least at the moment - from the Eastern Bloc states, and given that the function of money in the Eastern Bloc states, insofar as it has a function at all, is different from its function in capitalism.
In the "system" in the Eastern Bloc states as it exists at present, there is no way that the bureaucracy could gain control over the surplus product:
a) Planning could be introduced only at the expense of the very existence of the power and privileges product of the bureaucracy, and is thus incompatible with the existing set-up.
b) Sheer terror might have allowed for a certain primitive and lowlevel industrialisation to take place in the Soviet Union, but, in contemporary more technologically advanced society, could not enable the bureaucracy to gain control over the surplus product.
c) Offering "incentives" to the worktorce is no solution either; otfering more pay to workers in a society where money has little or no meaning is no "incentive" at all; offering more consumer products to workers in a society where such products are virtually guaranteed not to work properly is likewise no "incentive"
The "system in the Eastern Bloc states is therefore a historical blind alley. It is a historical blind alley in which the ruling stratum, whilst striving to become a ruling class, can never actually become one, because the "system" over which it presides is one which precludes the possibility of it ever achieving that control over the surplus product which is the criterion of a ruling Only in a vulgarised and pseudo-Marxist sense could the Stalinist bureaucracy be termed a "ruling class". . Exemplary of this vulgarised and impressionistic approach are the "bureaucratic collectivist" theories of, amongst others, Rizzi and Burnham.
For Rizzi, the bureaucracy was a "ruling class" because it controlled the means of production and behaved as if it owned them: property in the Soviet Union was nationalised, but the "true owners" of this nationalised property was the bureaucracy/"ruling class" ' given that it held state power. Thus, Rizzi concluded, the surplus value squeezed out of the direct producers went to the new exploiting class en bloc.
Rizzi's starting point was at least basically correct. He quoted the Marxist method for the analysing of society, as outlined in 'Das Kapital" and declared: "We too completely agree that the intimate secret of the social edifice is revealed in the economic form in which surplus value is extracted from the immediate producers."
His shortcoming was to fail to recognise that the bureaucracy collectively did not exercise that control over the surplus product which is the hallmark of a ruling class. (It was an easier mistake to make in the 1930s than now: the Soviet Union was being industrialised in the thirties, and therefore it easily seemed to be the case that it did exercise control over the surplusion 0f Burnham's version of "bureaucratic collectivism" was a vulgarised version of a vulgarised version of a class-analysis of the Soviet Union. His definition of a "ruling class" was: that "group of men that controls the chief instruments of production". Such control manifested itself in the ability to deny others access to the means of production, and preferential treatment in the distribution of the products of the means of production. This convenient definition allowed Burnham to declare that the bureaucracy in the Soviet Union (and its alleged variants in Italy and Germany)_ was a new "ruling Burnham's intention was to "prove"' that Stalinism/ fascism/the American 'New Deal' were really all the same thing ushering in the epoch of a new "rul. ing class' in history. In an attempt to achieve his goal he thus had to come up with a definition of "ruling class" broad enough to cover Stalinists, fascist, and American managers. His main work, "The Managerial Revolution', was thus a book written backwards: having decided in advance upon the existence of a new "ruling class" Burnham then sought the "proof" to back up his initial unfounded allegation. Others, more recently, have pursued a similar approach.
Trotsky himself never really took up Rizzi's arguments about a new "ruling class" in the Soviet Union. (Burnham's book was not published until after Trotsky's death. His attention focused more upon the conclusions which flowed from Rizzi's argument than upon the actual accuracy of this argument with regard to the situation in the Soviet Unien itself.
Trotsky dismissed Rizzi's arguments (We see no reason for following in the footsteps of a writer who has obviously lost his balance.") because, if correct, they would have meant that socialism was off the immediate agenda and that the working class had lost its revolutionary potential for the current epoch.
Insofar as Trotsky refers, in passing, to the idea of the bureaucracy deny such a possibility: "Symp tomatic of his oncoming death agony, by the sweep and the monstrous fraudulence of his purge, Stalin testifies to nothing else by the incapacity of the bureaucracy to transform itself into a stable ruling class.
This assessment is not negated by Trotsky's proposition that "either the Stalin regime is an abhorent relapse in the process of transforming bourgeois society into a socialist society, or the Stalin regime is the first stage of a new exploiting society. If the second prognosis proves to be correct, then, of course, the bureaucracy will become a new exploiting class.
But the Eastern Bloc states of today are manifestly not a *new exploiting society" and nor therefore, has the Stalinist bureaucracy become a "new exploiting class" The Stalinist bureaucracy remains an abhorrent relapse, dragging any society over which it holds sway ever deeper into a historical blind alley. "mere technicality constitutes the It is this which hibits calling the bureaucracy "ruling class". Those who todayseek to attach such a label to the bureaucracy can certainly find precedents for their etforts in the "bureaucratic collectivists" of the 1930s, but they will not find any ideological legitimacy.
Scan page 9
Rotten