Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Can the workers rule from jail?

Socialist Organiser no. 386, 25 January 1989 · scan p. 7 · about 1,124 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

rious a lot ehind IS -comcials. In Inialist volusecrious other had fight oney. d file ional Manndon asn't were ikes;

big the waterfront, dockes began to picket warehouses outside the dock areas in which containers were filled and unpacked by cheaper nonDock-Labour-Board labour. But Edward Heath's anti-union laws had just come into effect. Such picketing was forbidden.

In July 1972 five dockers were jailed for refusing to obey a court order to stop picketing. Immediately a wave of protest strikes spread over Britain. A quarter of a million workers stopped. Crowds marched to Pentonville • Jail, where the dockers were held. For a few days there was uproar. The TUC decided to call a one day general strike from the following Monday. The Government caved in, and released the dockers.

The anti-union law remained on the statute books, but it was crippled. Labour repealed it in 1974. It was a tremendous victory.

The dockers won a victory, too the Jones-Aldington agreement. The temporarily unattached 'pool" was abolished; the Government would pay the employers a subsidy to compensate them for hiring surplus labour; and the Government would also offer large payoffs for dockers quitting their jobs.

Atter that, the docks got quieter. Mechanisation was pushed through. The number of dockers declined dramatically, year after year. There are now fewer than 10,000 registered dockers. In the early '50s there were over 80,000. As late as 1972 there were still 43,000, As Britain's trade has shifted towards Western Europe, ports like Liverpool and Manchester have declined. Previously small ports outside the Dock Labour Scheme - notably Felixstowe and Dover — have become important. Over 20 per cent of trade now comes through non-scheme ports, worked by about 3,000 dockers.

rur several years Tories have flown kites about abolishing the Dock Labour Board. Now it looks like they are about to try to do it. It is one more drive to beat down the defences workers have built up over the decades.

It is still not too late to stop them abolishing the Dock Labour Board. Dockers still have tremendous UL power, especially in growing ports like Southampton. Although the number of dockers has declined, the amount of trade has risen. Dockers can deal more blows at the Tories where it hurts — in the economy -than most other workers.

Will the dockers use that power? They may do. If they do, and if they take on the Tories, then it will be the most important struggle since the miners' strike of 1984-5.

If that seems unlikely, remember that the miners didn't have an official strike between 1926 and 1970. And then they made themselves felt!

The steady rise in inflation is likely to spur on a revival of general industrial militancy. The slight drop in unemployment will encourage that revival. A fight around the Dock Labour Board could be a key turning point - just as the strike for recognition of the 'blue' union in the mid '50s was one of the pivots of the start of a prolonged wave of industrial militancy that lasted, with ebbs and flows, for twenty years.

Support the dockers in their fight to defend the National Dock Labour Board!

Philip Ward (Letters, SO ting questions about the USSR, concluding that SO is "heading down a dead end" since its break with the 'orthodox Trotskyist' position, to which Phil adheres, that the USSR is a bureaucratised workers' state.

His first criticism, that SO has not debated the 'orthodox' position but merely caricatured it, is unfair. We defended the 'orthodox' position for many years. We have rejected it because we no longer find it convincing.

Phil objects that we say *defencism = nuke western workers". In fact he quotes from one of our comrades who still supports 'defencism' and who was objecting to other Trotskyists' versions of 'defencism'!

Beyond that, Phil argues main points:

1) State capitalist/bureaucratic collectivist analysis cannot explain 'problem cases' (Mozambique, Angola) any better than 'workers" state' analysis can. Fair enough, but you could invert the complaint.

What certainly is true is that the working class played absolutely no independent role in the Angolan or Mozambican revolutions. Did it then in the Chinese, Vietnamese, Cuban, etc?

Phil's international tendency replies with a resounding Yes. The working class was present in the Chinese revolution, for example, via a 'deformed workers' party' Mao's CP.

The Maoist party was in reality a peasant-based movement that repressed the working class. To describe such a movement as a 'workers' revolution' reduces the working class to a spiritual presence, expressed terrestially in any old social class that comes to hand.

No problem Phil points to in our position could be as serious as this one. And this is our main point -blems, but that the "solution Pro- not that we have solved the fered by 'orthodox' Trotskyism poses worse problems.

Does our position mean that "radical' Stalinists like the Philippines CP are logically worse than old-fashioned tankies? Not necessarily. We can, after all, distinguish between different bourgeois movements, and do so concretely. Our position does, however, help to avoid the illusions in radical Stalinism that the Mandel current has managed to have so repetitiously. Turn it around: does Phil's position mean that Pol Pot's Cambodian CP is better than the workers' movement in France and Italy?

2) Phil supports USSR withdrawal from Afghanistan from the point of view of the world working class, but considers it against the interests of the Afghan masses. This however is not the view, it would seem, of the Afghan masses, and it is beyond me why basic Marxist principles on the right of nations to self-determination should be rendered irrelevant by the backwardness of that nation and the allegedly proletarian character of its oppressors.

3) Phil argues that without the Bolshevik revolution, Russia today might be a neo-colony like Turkey, and its advances prove the progressiveness of its property relations. But (a) Russia before 1917 was a rapidly-developing imperial power, and I find Phil's speculation unconvincing not to mention at odds with his own presumable theory of imperialism; and (b) North Korea is not more advanced than South Korea, rather the reverse.

Finally, "negativism' and 'formalism' are charges I would throw back, in triplicate, at Phil and his co-thinkers. He asks rhetorically, *What happened to the world balance of class forces since (1917)?" Phil presumably thinks things are more favourable to the working class now, one third of the world being proletarian. That is formalism for you.

For certain much remains to be discussed, but ditching the perverse absurdity that various countries are secretly ruled by a working class whose best fighters are in prisons or lunatic asylums is a precondition for a serious discussion.

Clive Bradley South London

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 386

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →