Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Work or full pay!

Socialist Organiser no. 386, 25 January 1989 · scan pp. 5–6 · about 2,758 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

Many real fight - and indeed do not want to risk their benefits, financial and other, in a real fight with the Stalinists.

The PPS-RD also encompasses many strands of thought from those who want a mixed economy and parliamentary system to a small group of mainstream Trotskyists selling a paper (news sheet) called KRET.

The PPS-RD will be adopting a programme early in this year, and three tendencies will probably present drafts. These will be KRET; a left group who are "interested" in Trotsky's ideas, including several leading members of the party, and a right group. Some in the party, with what seems an understandable syndicalist trend, oppose the adoption of any programme at all.

Another vital aspect of the new "action" strand in the opposition is the development of rank and file workers' groups based on the factory floor organisation.

After martial law much of the union work of Solidarnose was smashed. However, secret factory committees were set up composed of the best activists in each factory. From these factory committees, town-wide committees were elected, and regional bodies existed too, made up from the town committees.

This system was so organised that no-one knew who was on the body above them, but a union structure of sorts did exist which came into its own in any dispute.

In some areas the workers have organisea memseives as distinct groups calling for more action and organising and file militants. The two such groups I came across were MRKS in Warsaw and Wroclaw, and a group involving workers central to the August SEEKCS Gdansk, called Riot Solidarity.

PPS-RD often work alongside these groups and in the August strikes tried to help link up the rank and file groups and activists across regions.

Workers' dissatisfaction with the current leadership of Solidarnosc is certainly growing as une Tolnetable talks for which the August strike was snuffed out have recently heen delaved vet again. and the economic crisis continues deepen.

What is needed now is a rebuilding of democratic and comnational network of workers. This has started to happen and was boosted by 1988 strikes.

There is also good reason to hope that this time a more consciously socialist leadership will exist.

The British left must work with the PPS-RD and the workers' groups, giving solid support and engaging in debate to help develop clear political leadership of our class in Poland.

During my visit, however, it became sadly clear that the Western Despite all its leaders' talk of collaboration with the regime, Solidarnosc remains a workers' organisation. This is its policy on unemployment.

The Rakowski government plans to close down about 100 industrial plants, without any consultations or advice from leading economic experts. Thus the fate of enterprises is to be arbitrarily determined by the Prime Minister and not by economic realities.

Henceforth, total responsibility for the state of the economy falls squarely on this government. NSZZ Solidarnosc, however, cannot evade responsibility for the fate of the people threatened with unemployment and poverty.

Workers from enterprises slated for liquidation cannot expect anything positive from the official trade unions which have already failed not only to offer support at the Gdansk shipyard, but even to take advantage of the right to present their opinions prior to the announcement of the decision to close the shipyard.

On the contrary, the chairman of the official union openly supported the anti-worker policies of Prime Minister Rakowski, admitting his personal affinity for such a philosophy of government.

NSZZ Solidarnosc shall defend workers from enterprises set for closure regardless of their union membership. In the event of closures we demand that the government fulfill the following conditions (similar to those applicable to lay-off among administrative staffs):

1. That it accepts the principle that no person made redundant should suffer a loss in income or social benefits, be treated with worse working or housing conditions, or lower occupational status.

2. Persons, for whom the government cannot provide appropriate alternative employment in the same field, should have the following options: (a) the possibility of moving to a new area where there is appropriate employment and (b) occupational training in a freely chosen field, with assured income during the training period, equal to previous wages; (c) a one-off indemnity payment equal to an annual wage level plus all due bonuses and awards; and the beneficiary would then assume responsibility for tinding employment, nevertheless, employment continuity is preserved.

3. Workers residing in factoryowned hostels would enjoy security of tenure until acceptable housing is provided for them in new places of employment; families occupying factory housing gain tenancy rights.

4. Employees with 25 years seniority, as well as the elderly and ill, who might find it impossible to search for new employment, should have the right to early retirement.

5. Employees wishing to engage in entrepreneurial activity should receive necessary financial credits and assistance.

6. All funds for the implementation of these postulates should come from the employment opportunity and training budget which was set up for such purposes. We demand that the government give account of the state of this budget and use it entirely for the purposes for which it was created. We appeal to the workers from affected enterprises, to all working people as well as the official neo-trade unions, to support these postulates.

Gdansk, 12 November 1988. From Polish Solidarity Campaign Report, Oct/Dec 1988.

Scan page 6

Sean Matgamna survevs the The Tory Government has ganise the system under which dockers are employed -the National Dock Labour Board (NDLB).

According to the Independent (21 January), the Tories will push through the new law within the next twelve months, maybe much earlier.

The Tories want to abolish the NDLB. For years there have been rumblings against the NDLB from the port employers and Tory backbenchers. Now it seems that the Government is ready to have a go at abolishing it.

If they have hesitated for so many years, it is because of the dockers' determination to resist the abolition of the NDLB. TGWU dockers voted last year to strike if the scheme is threatened. There were two national docks strikes in 1984 against threats to the scheme.

The NDLB registers all Port workers and guarantees that dockers will have a basic minimum fallback wage, whether there is work for them or not. The Dock Labour Board is made up of representatives of employers and workers in equal numbers. It was set up by a Labour Government in 1947 to give dockers some minimal security in employment.

By its nature port work is not steady or constant. Ships come, unload, load and go. Often there are gaps in between.

Before 1947 dockers were hired and fired twice a day, morning and midday, for half a day at a time, as the bosses needed them.

Even in good times there would always be a pool of unemployed dockers. In bad times the pool would swell enormously. Anyone could go and get a job on the docks, without training - in a trade that was extremely dangerous and accident-plagued, The foremen would stand in the hiring pens, or on waste ground, with tallies to give out indicating that a man was hired, and gangs of dockers would mill around them. Fist-fights between competing dockers were common and normal. So was graft and corruption. The foremen had immense power over the dockers.

They could squeeze the dockers for money in return for hiring them. They could do deals with publicans to pay out wages in their pubs, thus ensuring good trade.

Poverty, crime, demoralisation, were the results of this system.

But the workers fought back. They began to organise trade unions. A hundred years ago this year, the dockers began to fight back as trade unionists, with the strike in London — led by Marxists like Tom Mann and John Burns -for the "docker's tanner". (The demand was for a minimum wage of sixpence an hour in old money, 2½p in today's. An average male wage was then around £1.20 a week).

The union began to discipline the dockers around the idea of solidarity - that they would stand together to better their conditions. It also conducted all sorts of subsidiary struggles - tor example, the strug gle against having wages paid out in pubs, which was a good system for the publicans and their foremen friends but not so good for a lot of children hungry because there was no money afterwards for food.

Substantial changes were won by the union, slowly and painfully. The level of working-class consciousness among dockers became high.

London dockers struck in 1920 to stop a British ship, the Jolly George, from sailing with a cargolly guns for the Polish Army which had invaded the revolutionary USSR. In 1936, dockers — a lot of them Irish — trooped to join those in the East End of London who fought the police trying to clear a way for fascists to march into the Jewish quarter. That was the battle of Cable Street.

1947 marked the really big change - the National Dock Labour Board. The dockers had fought their way to the point that the Labour Government set up system guaranteeing them a small basic wage at all times. Registered dockers would get this money even when there wasn't work, provided they turned swampa day to have availability).

The system was to be jointly administered by the union - the TGWU - and the bosses. The union had 50 per cent of control over hiring and I firing. This made most dockers' jobs very secure.

It was not socialism, but it was a long way up the scale of social evolution from the days of drunken and starving men fighting each other for a few hours' ill-paid and dangerous work.

How far the dockers had come was emblemised by the fact that their one-time leader Ernie Bevin, general secretary of the TGWU, was one of the strongest ministers in the 1945 Labour Government.

Yet there were problems too. The TGWU was then the bulwark of the right wing in the British labour novement. It was enormous, undemocratically run. bureaucratic.

It took to the job of helping run the docks in the spirit of the Stalinist bureaucrats who took over Eastern Europe about the same time — except that the TGWU officials did not have the power of an authoritarian state at their beck and call.

They never recognised strikes. TGWU officials organised strikebreaking against unofficial strikes. They could threaten militants with the sack if they did not toe the union line, which would normally be the NDLB line.

For example, in 1954 the entire branch committee of the union in Manchester was hauled up before the General Secretary, Arthur Deakin, who told them to toe the line or he'd have them sacked!

In 1955, 16,000 dockers in Manchester, Liverpool, and Hull left.the TGWU and joined a small London-based union, the National Association of Stevedores and Dockers. The NASD was called the "blue' union, after the colour of its cards; the TGWU was 'the white'). The "blue' dockers called it "the greatest jail-break in history"

The Dock Labour Board and the employers stood by their friends in the 'white' union, and refused to grant the "blue' negotiating rights. This was fatal, in an industry where conditions changed so much from ship to ship, hold to hold, and cargo to cargo that a price had to be negotiated for each job, sometimes more than once.

There was a long strike for recognition, which failed. The immediate result was divided trade union organisation on the docks, and soon afterwards non-unionism made its appearance. Yet militancy did not decline. On the contrary, it grew.

Dockers' militancy, was enormously, almost ettortlessly, eitective in the '50s, '60s, and "70s. In Glasgow and Liverpool there was a system known respectively as 'spelling' and 'the welt' , under which it was custom and practice - under the eyes of the foremen, and with their agreement - for half of a gang working a ship to do the first four hours of a shift, and then do what they liked, while the other half did the second part of the shift.

Dockers had the power to shut down the country.

But things were changing. The cargo-handling techniques in the ports were very ancient, little different from ancient Rome - vast armies of men humping cargoes on their backs.

A technological revolution in the 1960s changed all that. Now cargoes were packed into giant containers in factories or special depots, and unpacked in other factories or depots. Dockers just had to roll the giant containers on and off specially designed ships.

This meant the end of most dock jobs over a period of decades. On average containers can be handled in one-tenth of the man-hours of old-style cargo.

Containerisation gave the bosses a great weapon against the dockers, and at the same time a strong incentive to reorganise the ports.

The 1964 Labour Government appointed a Royal Commission under Lord Devlin to investigate strikes on the docks, and then implemented the Commission report to 'decasualise' the docks.

Dockers were to be taken into permanent employment with a particular employer, instead of being hired out for some many hall-days by the Dock Labour Board. They would therefore lose a big part of the control the union had over hiring and firing through the Dock Labour Board.

The Dock Labour Board would only be the fallback employer for a pool of unattached dockers who did not have a regular employer.

At the same time such practices as 'spelling' and 'the welt' would go. Thus - so the bosses hoped the docks could be modernised, with fuller bosses' control that had existed on the docks for twenty years.

And the dock labour force could more easily be cut down over the years, as modernisation took place.

What happened next is one of the most tragic - and representative experiences of the British working class in recent decades. It summed up the whole story of how we were beaten, and how the great working-class militancy of the '60s and "70s gave way to the present Thatcherite reaction.

Here were the most militant workers in Britain. They had tremendous solidarity. In certain ports a docker had only to run down the quay shouting "Everybody out" and the men would come out to hear what it was all about.

The day-to-day struggle for wages and good conditions had taught them that solidarity was the best way to protect themselves.

The employers were trying to carry out an open and drastic revolution in the ports, openly revoking the elements of workers" control won over decades of struggle. The workers had the strength to stop them.

But the bosses had decisive advantages: a conniving right-wing Labour Government; the trade union officials, who supported the Devlin proposals; and, above all, the fact that the hyper-militant dockers had no real alternative to the reorganisation except defence of a status quo increasingly made impossible by technological change. The charge of Luddism" (backward-looking opposition to new technology) was a potent one in the mouths of both Labour politicians and trade union leaders.

Yet the dockers' answer should have been obvious and clear-cut: increase workers' control and modernise on that basis, using the advantages of modernisation to benefit. the workers. Most dockers wanted the nationalisation of the ports, and most wanted to expand workers' control rather than give full control back to the bosses.

But there was simply no force on the docks with the organised strength to lead that sort of fight. The "white" union was as bureaucratic as ever. The left-wing groups were wea often unclear.

The Communist Party had of influence, but they trailed l the 'white' union bureaucr who, until 1970, still banned munists from being union off The major Trotskyist group w fluence in the ports - the So Labour League/Workers' R tionary Party - was rabid! tarian and incapable of work. Workers' Fight, the Trotskyist group active ther two dockers in Manchester.

So there was no coherent back. Dockers were split u confused by offers of better n Attempts by an ad hoc rank a committee to organise a na stoppage were defeated In the autumn of 1967, chester, Liverpool and struck against Devlin, but it enough. The conditions substantially bettered by the s but modernisation proceede dockers' jobs bled away.

The next, and most recen turning point on the docks ca 1972. Alarmed at the loss of j

----- pull-quotes -----

Matgamna moves towards a

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 386

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →