Perestroika isn't working
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-01-25Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
Internationally it seems that Mikhail Gorbacher can do no wrong. His arms cuts were a major propaganda victory. Opinion polls show his ever-increasing popularity.
But at home things look considerably less rosy for Russia's reforming monarch. He has had to denounce both the conservatives in the party who would like to halt the reforms, and those who want more than Gorbachev is prepared to offer.
"We must not be backward looking, we must not stand on the sidelines of history," he says. But also, "We must not go too fast. We must not allow our policies to be hijacked by those who want to undermine the leading role of the Communist Party." • Gorbachev is having to fight for •The emancipation of the working class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction of sex or race' Karl Marx Socialist Organiser PO Box 823, London 4NA. Phone 01-639 7965. date for reports: first Monday or by phone Monday evening. his programme of limited political openness and of economic restructuring.
But in Gorbachev's own terms, perestroika is looking decidedly threadbare. Ethnic conflict and regional demands are burgeoning, with many republics setting up semi-autonomous 'popular fronts' which have latched on to a whole variety of festering grievances.
Amongst ordinary Soviet workers, perestroika is flagging in its (probably hyped) popularity as its immediate effects are felt - rising inflation and declining availability of consumer goods.
Inflation is now at 10% and is rising. Basic foodstuffs are in short supply. In about one third of the Russian Federation, the largest of the USSR's republics, with a population of 143 million, meat and butter are rationed.
An article in the paper Sovietskaya Rossiya reckons that the availability of many consumer goods has declined sharply over the Typesetting: Upstream Ltd (TU), 01-358 1344.
Published by Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.
Printed by Press Link International (UK) Ltd (TU). Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office. Signed articles do not necessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser last year. Washing machines and refrigerators are hardly available. Shoes and clothing are in chronically short supply.
Economic growth over 1988 was officially reckoned at 4.2%. But plan targets are calculated in roubles rather than in items produced. According to the Sovietskaya Rossiya commentator this means that many factories have been producing fewer but more expensive goods. The 4.2% indicates not so much a growth in the production of goods, as a rise in prices — identified by some Soviet economists as "hidden inflation"
Small businesses, have been legalised in the form of cooperatives'. This has meant increased availability of some goods — but at vastly inflated prices. Hence the co-operatives are not popular with the ordinary people who are forced to buy from them because of the goods or services are unavailable elsewhere.
Gorbachev has managed to blame the failures of perestroika on the obstructiveness of conservative bureaucrats. But a report last summer from leading planning officials cited the problem as Gorbachev's attempts to graft reforms onto existing structures.
Factories are now supposed to be self-financing. But centralised planning and the need to meet targets cuts across this. That consumer price reform has been put off indefinitely means that the selffinancing/profitability framework collapses.
Soviet sociologists also think that Gorbachev's land policy will be a flop. Land is being effectively privatised by allowing tarmers to lease land for up to 50 years. The intention of this was to boost the production of basic foodstuffs — to use the carrot of profit to get more food into the shops.
The policy bears some resemblance to the policy pushed in the mid-'20s by Gorbachev's hero, Bukharin. But times have changed, and it looks like only one or two per cent of the USSR's farmers will take the chance to 'enrich themselves?.
There are groups who want to take perestroika to its logical conclusions. The Democratic Union, founded last May, has a programme which calls for an end to the political monopoly of the CP, a multi-party system with free elections to a national assembly, and the right to accumulate capital. It has only around 2,000 members, , 'Glasnost' and circulations.
Members of the Democratic Union have been subject to vitriolic denunciations and blatant police harassment. Gorbachev's speech indicates his fear of the old guard, but more the fear of what he may have unleashed, the fear that glasnost and perestroika may lead to the end of his own power.
In his speech he said the last year had been a tough one, and that there would be more trials to come, but that it would be worth it. His claims are sounding less convincing by the minute. Maybe now the misty-eyed Gorbachev tans on the British left will learn what the Russian people already have perestroika isn't working.