Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Time to rebuild socialist feminism

Socialist Organiser no. 385, 19 January 1989 · scan pp. 13–15 · about 3,248 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

In 1979 tens of thousands of workers took action against the right-wing policies of the Labour government under Callaghan and Healey.

The workers were strong and they were angry - but in the absence of a left political alternative the ousting of the Callaghan government led to Thatcher.

But the experience of Labour's betrayals resulted in the rise of the left in the Labour Party. A left that swore 'Never Again' a Labour government like that of 1974-9, a left that fought for a democratic Labour Party, in which MPs would be accountable to the rank and file, a left that wanted any future Labour government to be a party for the working class, not tor the vosses.

Feminists joined the Labour Party in their droves, demanding the right of women to take our place in the labour movement. There was a real movement to bring women's demands, women's needs, into the labour movement, to link the left and women's liberation.

Women's Sections were transformed from tea-making and jumble sale organising gatherings to real campaigning political bodies. We challenged sexism in the party, fought for positive discrimination, for childcare, often just to be taken seriously as political human beings.

The Labour left, particularly in local government, took on board the demands of women. As left-Labour administrations took power in the town halls women's units and equal opportunity programmes were established.

Ten years on, where are we? 10 years of Thatcher have taken their toll - many of the fighters of the early 1980s are now demoralised outriders for Neil Kinnock. The local government left is on the whole discredited, having used a feminist figleaf as a cover for the cuts. Kinnock has managed to roll back many of the gains made by the left in the early 1980s.

We have made gains - the Labour Party is far more habitable for women than it was 10 years ago. And this year women won the battle for better representation when conference agreed to one woman on every shortlist. But many of these gains have been partial, some have been double-edged. What started out as a vibrant, energetic socialist feminist current in the Labour Party has dwindled to little more than a few committee-room cliques But there are still many women in the Labou Party who want to fight, who desperately feel the lack of a coherent fighting socialist women's current in the party. For sure there is much for us to organise around - Thatcher's attacks, local government cuts, Kinnock's policy reviews.

Now is the time for us to start building, to start organising. To all intents and purposes socialist-feminism has vanished from the Labour movement. Now we need it more than ever. Join the fightback! they know it just will not do.

Just before Christmas Angela Rumbold told employers that they would have to change to "accommodate" women workers. This is the key to what the Tories probably intend to do. No way do they intend the state to fund universal nursery education. Employers should be encouraged to do it. Plans which have been mooted are for local employers to club together to fund nurseries not workplace nurseries, which the Tories also disapprove of.

Time and again governments have provided nurseries - when they need women in the factories. When we're not needed at work, nurseries are cut back.

Nursery education should not be dependent on the needs of the bosses. Our children have a right to pre-school education. We have a right to have our children well cared for while we go to work or college. The Labour Party should lead a fight to get free nursery provision for our children.

Scan page 14

Svivia Pankhurst (left). militant socialist feminist Cathy Nug reviews th pamphlet, Case for So Feminism' *The Case for Socialist Feminism" attempts to sum up not only a history of women's oppression, but also a history of feminist thinking: how and why women have fought against their enslavement and the ideas that have been used to explain the nature of that fight.

Part 1 of "The Case for Socialist Feminism" deals with the debate on the origins of women's oppression, the development of that oppression under capitalism and the programme for women's emancipation the early socialists adopted. It starts (perhaps not logically!) with the Pard fact womenapitalian has brought ever larger numbers of women into wage labour" This trend is scrutinised later and described, broadly, as progressive. Progressive, because capitalism has brought women "into the labour force as independent individuals"

this has given women a "promise" of equality.

This is a partial explanation of how capitalism generates struggle by women for equality, for what is "seemingly' and 'rightfully" theirs At the same time however, domestic labour or 'housework' "became a sphere sharply separated off from social labour, rather than closely intermingled with it". Capitalism im posed a new role on women. Women were now burdened down with a series of endless tasks: endless shopping for bargains, endless planning of menus to suit finickity families, endless cleaning of surfaces too old and worn to ever be clean, endless making sure the dust never settles on the furniture This is "Women's Realm" "Women's World"

And "this burden of housework has become the basis for the elaborate structure of women's disadvantage in capitalist society, including the relegation of women to lower paid jobs modelled on their domestic roles...

And in conclusion: *Capitalism makes the promise of equality, and incites the demand for equality; but beyond a certain point its roots in the family household make it incapable of satisfying those demands and those promises. That is why the movement for women's liberation is a child of capitalism, but potentially a tremendous force for anticapitalist revolution."

For the early socialists the position of women and the "emancipation of women" seemed to be bound up with a vision of a better, more equal society, with the liberation of humanity. Charles Fourier is quoted as one example: «the degree of emancipation of women is the natural measure of general emancipation". . In part 2 of the pamphlet, which focuses on the modern women's movement we see how this idea of liberating the whole of humanity was central to the original aims of that movement.

Marx and Engels accepted the programme of the 'Utopian' socialists, but tried to integrate it into a perspective of class struggle. Whilst Marx and Engels added very little to an understanding women's oppression under capitalism, their programme, for the socialisation of housework and childcare, is still pertinent today.

This section also outlines early attempts to organise working class women: the women's movement of German Social Democracy and later the efforts of Bolshevik women (Kollontai, Inessa Armand and Samoslova). What happened to women after the Bolsheviks' Russian revolution has become a taunt used by many feminists to say "women can't wait until the revolution, look what happened in Russia". In truth what happened in Russia was the defeat of the working class, women were defeated alongside that; the formal equality established after the revolution fell by the wayside, and with the rise of Stalinism and the corruption of workers' movements world-wide, so did the ideas of the early socialists and marxists.

Part 2 of the pamphlet explains how these ideas had to be rediscovered and developed and focuses on the ideas of the modern women's movement. The debate took place in the absence of a mass socialist movement: the connection (though it was always a tense and antagonistic connection) between the "Woman Question" and socialism was no longer there. Although the women's movement did initially identify with the 'left' that was a much looser, more heterogeneous movement and it was a left that was unable and unwilling to integrate the new insights of the women's movement into it's theory and practice.

*The politics of moral of oppression' now holds sway..."

The project for many women was to create a different sort of socialism. Sheila Rowbotham summed it up this way: "The so-called women's question is thus a whole people question, not only because our liberation is inextricably bound up with the revolt of all those who are oppressed, but because their liberation is not realisable fully unless our subordination is ended." The division between men and women was not explained in term of "biology'. Even 'radical' feminists such as Kate Millet saw society and its institutions as the causes.

The pamphlet then proceeds to deal with issues that modern feminists have raised and assesses just how far the 'new feminists' have retreated from the original 'revolutionary' goals and imperatives.

How should socialist women relate to the 'new feminists' such as Dworkin• The Case for Socialist Spender?

Feminism" is a short pamphlet, by no means a definitive statement. Still any kind of attempt to get to grips with this 'new feminism' in a genuinely critical way, is something unique on the revolutionary left.

Towards the end of the pamphlet this point is made (in the context of a critique of Heidi Harmann's 'dual systems' theory): (Marxists) "do not concern ourselves with attaching moral priorities to different struggles, but with soberly analysing which struggles present-day society inevitably generates, and their dynamics. We see working class struggle as central not because of moral choice, but because we believe hard facts say that the class struggle has the scope and force to draw on all other liberation struggles and to change society in a revolutionary way" . We should approach developing an "adequate" theory of women's oppression (one that can explain sexuality or rape for example) in this way. We should proceed on the basis of hard facts' In the early years of the modern women's movement this was the theoretical approach of many feminists. But it is not that of most 'popular' feminists today. The politics of moral priorities' ferent struggles' and 'hierarchies of oppression' now holds sway and is not confined to a handful of literary feminists: it has taken root in local government, the student movement and elsewhere. How this has come about is one of the central themes of the pamphlet.

What is this new feminism? Lynn Segal sums it up: "The feminist writing which is now most popular in this country, which is always listed among the bestsellers in the progressive literary magazines, is a new form of radical feminism. Mostly from North America, where it is known as 'cultural feminism' celebrates women's superior virture spirtuality and decries "male'l

Scan page 15

implistic view of patriarchy ism iolence and technology. Male violence (arising from the ower of the penis and the viologically natural agression in nen) is one side of this trend. The ther emphasises language and nale values. The picture of society ve see is one that is almost otalitarian for women. Male power in whatever form) is all-pervasive. Now, this is very peculiar. How is that these women, in such a brutal ostile world manage to get hemselve such very nice jobs, ublish their books freely, get such i wide public hearing?

The 'new feminists' say women nust strip (Cleanse exorcise. hemselves this Whereas before women protested bout language that expressed ubordination and subjection ecause it was used to intimidate nd stop women from getting a full ay, now the line is that such anguage is a pivotal part of male omination: women's minds have een *taken over. What women leed to do is get in touch with women's values', culture, language peace, nature, wombs) in order to berate themselves.

This is reactionary in several vays. Firstly, women have struggld to free themselves from these eminine stereotypes, which have leen based on our reproductive apacities (peace, nature, mother lature, etc). Secondly presumably nly a special group of women (and his is explicit in Daly's writings) an get "truly' in touch with vomen's culture (whatever that nay be - Daly lets her imaginaion run riot on this one with her piders' webs, spinning and witches" ovens). The majority of women, vorking class women, will be raitors to their sex/class. Whilst overty and economic inequality is lot important, inevitably working lass women will be ignored. The lew feminism the pamphlet ghtly points out is the property of le "leisured and comfortable asses".

The Case for Socialist Feminism" overs a lot of other ground. But erhaps the most important quesion for us is, why did the women's novement fragment? The pamphlet ums it up in this way: *Under the est of circumstances, a broad sontaneous movement like the omen's movement of the late '60s nd early '70s would fragment riously as views and positions ecame more defined. The ossibility of keeping a large fraglent it as a coherent, rogressively-developing revoluonary movement depended on the Penny Newell takes issue with Lynn Ferguson's criticisms of the theory of ticle (WF, December) •Patriarchy — a static theory', I must admit I flicked back to the cover of Women's Fightback. Yes I was reading WF! I thought for a minute that I'd picked up an old copy of Militant, froin under my bed, dated 1978. (Bought in a moment of boredom on a march to be laughed at later).

Just imagine! We used to say to each other, if you believed Militant all that needs to happen is 'the revolution' • We've got to wait until then. Discussions on the question of women's oppression a Militant supporter used to regularly tell me was "the politics of the crutch""

No, I know, I thought, they've pasted up an old article from the Militant, by mistake, that was kept for reference - but the article clearly said, "by Lynn Ferguson" and I knew she writes for WF regularly.

Better read it again I thought. This must be an editorial starting off a new debate on women. Wrong again, no 'editorial' written next to the title.

I won't disect the article sentence by sentence, like some of taose boring men do who write letters to other left papers. I expect they can't help being boring though, it's probably a result of capitalism. Bits of their brains have got damaged by the mode of production. Aren't we girls lucky, because of our subordinate role we've missed that bit of damage to our bodies.

Seriously though, I could see some parts of the article that made sense, she said generously, but some parts didn't. To get down to the nitty gritty.

It seemed odd to me to quote Shulamith Firestone and Christine Delphy on their definition of women's oppression in relation to Angela Davis the term partriarchy and not any socialist-feminists. Basically it's difficult to take any woman with a name that sounds like a car tyre manufacturer seriously and on top of that she's got some pretty naff theories.

There were two sentences in Lynn's article I couldn't understand.

At the beginning she said, when talking about the history of women's subordiantion, "The exact details of this are impossible to discover but most evidence shows that this was because it was men's work that the growth took place" And then at the end: "For women's oppression began with the beginning of class society"... "it is only the end of class society that can provide the precondition for the liberation of women" . These statements seem at odds with each other.

L also found the very large picture of black South African women on strike in support of a white woman worker with the caption "women must fight as part of the labour moment" too simplistic, Black women's oppression isn't mentioned in the article and while I agree that black and white women must fight as part of the labour movement those black South African's women's history is different from the white women's. They share the same conditions at work perhaps, but it ends at the factory gate. Just as Lynn says "A women's movement can't be built on a fudge of classless sisterhood", so it can't be built on white women's history alone.

To quote Angela Davis from •Women, Race and Class' . "Since slave women were classified as breeders as opposed to mothers their infant children could be sold away from them like calves from cows. At the end of the importation of Africans to the states a South Carolina court ruled that female slaves had no legal claim on their children and the young slaves 'could stand on the same footing as other animals It's hard to reconcile that these laws could be passed at a time when white women were organising women's suffrage campaigns. Yet free black slaves like Soujouner Truth got involved in those suffrage campaigns too. Her famous "And ain't I a woman" speech took the breath away of the men and inspired the women.

Not only did Shulamith Firestone in the Dialetic of Sex map out her theory of partriarchy she also claimed that "racism is actually an extension of sexism". Susan Brownmiller in "Against our Will" also accepts the racist ideology that black men are more likely to rape than white men.

No article on Women and Class can easily skip over the different history of black women particularly women who are descendents of slaves in the USA and other colonies. It is not the same as white women's history and it to not acknowledge this.

The article begins with the heading "Women's oppression is linked with class exploitation" Well strike a light what a revelation.

I feel like WF is saying that capitalism is linked with class exploitation. I didn't realise that this was a contended position. What I understood was that it isn't a matter of saying that a socialist revolution will automatically mean that women's oppression will wither away. Alexander Kollontai was constantly accused of 'bourgeois deviations' when she promoted her ideas in Russia before and after the revolutions. She said:

"As the struggle became increasingly bloodier, much of what was happening was very alien to many ways of thinking. But after all, there was still the unfinished task of women's liberation. Women of course, had received all rights but in practice they still lived under the old yoke without authority, enslaved by a thousand menial chores..." She was critised for offering the "fantasy" of complete liberation for women and of irresponsibly encouraging indiscriminate sexual relationships which released "African passions" (little spot of racism there) in young people.

She died in 1982 just before her 80th birthday and she was saying then that she hadn't had a bed of roses in her life. One of the things she grieved about was *The lack of understanding of my basic ideas on the women's question and the right approach to sexual matters"

During the 1970s and early "80s the women's question was recognised as complicated by many revolutionary socialist feminists. The order you put socialism and feminism when describing yourself was the subject of lots of debate. If we credit women (and men) who read WF with some intelligence than I think they deserve a regular series of articles on the various theories that socialist feminists have put forward during the last 100 years or so.

To open that debate we could start with the view of Rosalind Petchesky who said "If we understand that partriarchal kinship relations are not static but like class relations are characterised by antagonism and struggle then we begin to speculate that women's consciousness and their periodic attempts to resist or change the dominant kinship structures will themselves affect class relations"

----- pull-quotes -----

priorities, different struggles' and 'hierarchies

patriarchy On reading Lynn Ferguson's ar-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 385

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →