Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Eastern Bloc: a chronically unstable

Socialist Organiser no. 385, 19 January 1989 · scan pp. 8–10 · Jean Lane · about 3,755 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Bruce Robinson contributes to our discussion on the Eastern Bloc. He that Trotsky's theory of the 1930s outdated, but that there is no new class in the Eastern Bloc systems, they have some particular progres! features which workers do and shi defend. Part 3 of Vladimir Derer's will appear next week.

In many respects Trotsky's theory of Stalinism is today outmoded and needs replacement by a theory that reflects the history of the past 50 years, in particular that:

* Stalinism has expanded into a whole number of new countries, rather than collapsing in World War II as Trotsky predicted;

* The main contradictions in these countries are between the working class and the bureaucracy, rather than between basically healthy proletarian property relations and capitalism, with the bureaucracy, endangering those property relations by its usurpation of them;

* The bureaucracy is not just parasitic on nationalised property but has moulded the Stalinist societies into very specific forms of social relations which are neither capitalist nor socialist.

Despite having existed as long as 60 years, Stalinıst societies remain highly unstable. The power of the bureaucracy is maintained by force, atomising the working class so that no collective action is possible. Once the barriers to collective action are removed, as in Hungary in 1956 or Poland in 1980-1, the Stalinist regimes are shown to lack any popular support and any ideological legitimacy.

Questions of workers' control and state power immediately come to the fore and the regime can only survive by using force to reimpose the atomisation of the working class. This instability of Stalinism is the reason why no independent unions can exist there, though they can in countries such as South Korea.

The Stalinist states have also been for a long time in economic crisis. It is possible to develop highly backward countries up to a certain point by a combination of terror/slave labour camps, ALIST ORGANISER PAMPHLET 80 PENCE A SOCI Stakhanovism, squeezing the peasantry and command planning from above.

However, the system cannot go beyond that to high-technology production (which requires a cooperative and at least somewhat motivated workforce). It cannot respond flexibly to the needs of the population, for those needs can be expressed neither through the market nor through democratic planning.

The Stalinist societies possess neither the dynamism of capitalism nor that which would be unleashed by real democratic planning. As Trotsky wrote:

"The working people themselves must participate in the running of the economy if it is really to be socialism, that is, production and other economic activity for the benefit of the people. It must not be that the bureaucrats unilaterally make decisions and the people simply obey — in that case the plans will not be corrected by those whom these plans ostensibly should be servicing.

"Under capitalism the correction takes place - or more accurately took place - through competition. Under socialism that can happen only through workers' and farmers' control. If that is not done, disproportions can develop which can lead to disproportionate results." (June 1935)

Thus these economies, once they have reached a certain level, stagnate and are unable to fulfill the real needs of the workers. Even the bureaucracy itself cannot really control how its plans will be executed, as it also consists of conflicting interests, which are arbitrated by and within the top levels of the Communist Parties and the state.

Introducing elements of market economy into these states is seen by the bureaucracy as a means of giving them some dynamism. This is the main motivation behind A Socialis Organiser pamphlet.

Available

from PO Box perestroika in the USSR today.

But, as we are now seeing in China, there are limits to how far Stalinism can let market forces develop. The bureaucracy's independent existence is tied up with the existence of nationalised property and the existing system in the Stalinist states.

The bureaucracy has neither the historic mission or viability nor the independent ideology of a new class. Many 'new class' theorists content themselves with a general description of the USSR and a few general arguments as to why what exists there must be presided over by a ruling class. For Marxists the existence of a ruling class is tied up with the need to develop the productive forces under specific social relations of production.

So is there anything the Stalinist states?

In relation to the real possibilities of working class democracy and socialism, Stalinism is totally reactionary. But this does not answer the question as to whether the Russian Revolution has degenerated so far that nothing progressive remains, or whether the Stalinist states have any features that go beyond capitalism.

To recognise such features does not necessarily imply a particular "tag' for the Stalinist states. Max Shachtman originally thought that MIT while they represented a new form of class society, they were nevertheless progressive in relation to capitalism.

Our basic approach should remain that of Trotsky in 1940: "Our general appraisal of the Kremlin and the Comintern does not, however, alter the particular fact that the statification of property in the occupied territories is in itself a progressive measure. We must recognise this openly...

*The statification of the means of production is, as we said, a progressive measure. But its progressiveness is relative; its specific weight depends on the sum-total of all the other factors. Thus, we must first and foremost establish that the extension of the territory dominated by bureaucratic autocracy and parasitism, cloaked by 'socialist' measures, can augment the prestige of the Kremlin, engender illusions concerning the possibility of replacing the proletarian revolution by bureaucratic manoeuvres, and so on, *This evil by far outweighs the progressive content of Stalinist reforms in Poland. In order that nationalised property in the occupied areas, as well as in the USSR, becomes a basis for genuinely progressive, that is to say socialist, development, it is necessary to over; throw the Moscow bureaucracy." (In Defence of Marxism, New Park. pp.23-4)

There is a progressive content to the "particular measures" carried through by Stalinism, despite the generally reactionary nature of the Stalinist bureaucracy.

State ownership of the means of production is part of our programme, whether for Stalinist countries, or advanced or backward capitalism. It is a pre-condition of socialism, though socialism is only realised when that state-owned industry is democratically controlled by the workers and forms part of an overall plan for society as a whole.

Nevertheless we defend even 1945-style capitalist nationalisation against attempts to reverse it, not because the workers' conditions or wages in those industries are necessarily " better (compare the Eastern bloc!) nor because it is itself inherently socialist.

Similarly we defend nationalisation in the Stalinist states because any revolution which will lead to real workers' rule in those countries will build on the basis of the existing state ownership of the means. of production. A reversion to private property would be regressive both in terms of the workers' immediate interests and our long-term aims.

If workers organisations such as Solidarnosc nevertheless were to wish to move towards a market economy, we still defend their right to exist and not give any support to the bureaucracy against them as the

Scan page 9

ke unions in USSR yst supposed "defender of nationalised property". We would nevertheless argue they were wrong to do so.

In practice, in all the major working class upsurges in Eastern Europe workers' control rather than the restoration of private ownership has been the focus of workers' demands.

The same approach applies to the extent that these societies are not subject to the law of the market and retain the capacity for planning. We should emphasise that the bureaucracy cannot plan properly because it cannot allow working class initiative, rather than rejecting planning as meaningless in Stalinist societies, or supporting market reforms because they have working class support. -The system in the Eastern Bloc has granted a number of economic concessions to the working class: low levels of unemployment and high job security; subsidised prices and rents. To some extent, these represent concessions to the negative pressure of the working class; in other respects they may be necessary for the system itself (eg. hoarding labour).

Nevertheless they represent something of considerable importance to the workers in those countries. For example, in Poland, both in 1976 and 1980, announcements of rises in food prices led to waves of strikes, which in 1980 directly led to the formation of Solidarnosc.

A recent Guardian report on the far-reaching introduction of market reforms in China states: "To put Chinese factories on a commercial footing would mean sacking up to 30 million workers or 20% of the urban industrial workforce. To really allow the market to set prices would inevitably mean real hardship for millions."

Similarly perestroika is aimed to increase the intensity of work, close unprofitable factories and cut subsidies on food, the carrot being the promise of a switch of resources to the production of consumer goods.

To the extent that the market is allowed free rein the bureaucracy will come increasingly into conflict with the working class. Our position should be to defend those elements of the existing system that are in the interests of the working class, independent of all factions of the bureaucracy.

It is of course true that features such as job security and low rents do not in themselves define whether a society is progressive or not. However if working class living standards cannot prove that a regime is progressive, no more can they be used to prove it's not.

If higher workers' living standards in the West show the superiority of market capitalism, thermarke a ration to alse healthy but backward workers' state of Lenin and Trotsky.

Stan There are no trade unions in the Soviet Union. The All-union Central Council of Trade Unions (AUCCTU) is not the Soviet equivalent of the TUC. It is a branch of the Soviet government. Its function is the opposite of a trade union:

it does not defend workers against the state, but the state against the workers.

The theoretical rationale for the role played by what pass themselves off as trade unions in the Soviet Union is that the working class holds state power and that the state is therefore a workers' state which should be protected and strengthened (ie. against the workers themselves).

Since the Communist Party is the ruling party the trade unions have the job of carrying out its policies:

*...The Congress (of the AUCC TU) assures the Leninist Central Committee of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union...that the trade unions of the USSR will always be reliable supporters of the Party and its active helpers...

The top men in the AUCCTU are therefore Party members, not elected to their positions by rank and file workers, but appointed by their fellow bureaucrats in the Communist Party. In general, they have little or no experience of "trade union" work. Shelepin, lastbut-one AUCCTU president, was transferred to the post from that of head of the KGB.

Although the Soviet media, and the admirers of the Soviet bureaucracy abroad, make great play of the supposed say which Soviet "trade unions" have in the running of society, their role is in fact small.

Rates of basic pay are decided nationally, within the framework of the overall economic "plan". In the individual workplace the basic rate of pay depends upon this national decision. Even if they so desired (and they do not anyway), Soviet i"trade unions" could not therefore win higher basic rates of pay at workplace level through challenging Saturday 21 January. Nicaragua Solidarity Campaign conference. City University, Northampton St, London EC1. Starts 10am. Contact: 01-253 2464.

Saturday 21 January. 'Further Education Socialists' planning meeting, in London. Details: contact Mark, 01-639 7967.

Saturday 21/Sunday 22 January. Weekend school for women supporters of Socialist Organiser. Details: contact Cate, 01-639 7965.

Monday 23 January. London SO education series on British labour history. "The Chartists' . Speaker: Martin Thomas. Conway Hall, Red Lion Sq, WC1. 7pm.

Monday 23 January. Manchester SO meeting. 'The Arab-Israeli conflict'. • The Millstone pub, Thomas S 7.30pm.

Monday 23 January. Leeds SO meeting. 'The New Realism'. Leeds Univ, Student Union. 7,30pm.

management.

Nor do "trade unions" have any say in production quotas, upon fulfillment of which other elements of workers' pay depends. Such quotes are partly determined by the production target set for a workplace by a higher level of the bureaucracy, and partly by production norms set by the workplace management on a supposedly "scientific" basis. There is no element of a bargaining process between trade unions and management.

If the "unions" have no say in what workers are to be paid or how much they are expected to produce, they certainly have an important role to play in ensuring the maximum rates of productivity from the workforce. According to the statutes of the AUCCTU:

*The Soviet trade unions direct their activities towards securing a further and powerful advance in all branches of the economy, fulfillment and overfulfillment of economic plans...Trade unions jointly with the organs of management organise socialist emulation among workers...they organise the movement for a communist attitude towards work.

Increased productivity is not to be achieved by the "unions" winning better working conditions, which would lead to more job satisfaction and, in turn, to a higher output. It is to be achieved by better labour discipline. The KGB-chiefturned-trade-union-bureaucrat Shelepin summed this up in 1972:

*It is our commitment to step up the struggle for the strengthening of labour and production discipline...Everyone must know that idlers and slackers, jobswitchers and bad workmen will receive no indulgence or leniency and that nothing will protect them from the wrath of their comrades.

The rights and opportunities of the trade unions for this are great and they must be used to a substantially improved degree.

The All-Union Congress of Soviet "trade unions" is, according to its statutes, meant to meet once every four years. In fact, it meets on the odd occasion that the Party bureaucracy finds it useful for it to meet - between 1932 and 1954 it met twice. Even if it met more often it would not thereby be more Monday 30 January. London Socialist Forum: 'Socialist Feminism into the 1990s'. . Conway Hall, Red Lion Square, WC1. 7.30pm.

Monday 30 January. Sheffield SO meeting: 'Arabs, Jews and Socialism'. Speaker: John O'Mahony. SCAU, West St. 8pm. Saturday 4 February. 'Alternative Policy Review' conference. Queen Mary College, East London.

Monday 6 February. London SO education series on British labour history. 'The New Unionism and the first Marxist groups'. . Speaker: Bruce Robinson. Conway Hall, Red Lion Sq, WC1. 7pm.

Monday 6 February. Manchester SO: debate with Socialist Outlook on the Eastern bloc.

Monday b February. Nottingham. SO meeting: 'Why the PLO has gonc for two states'. Speaker: Paul Mc Garry. 7.30, International Communi ty Centre, Mansfield Rd Saturday 11/Sunday 12 February. Socialist Student weekend conference, in Sheffield. Details: contact Mark, 01-639 7967.

Saturday 11 February. Marxism Today 'New Times, New Thinking" conference. Caxton House, St Johns Way, London N19. Starts 10am. ASTERN BLI democratic - the congresses are merely a series of speeches plus the obligatory unanimous vote.

The "unions" are so hand-in-glove with management that they do not even provide their members with the protection they are accorded by the Soviet legal system. No worker can be sacked without the approval of their "union" • But over 50% of workers who appeal to the local "People's Court" against their sacking win their case. This says more about the spinelessness of the "unions" than about the "fairness" of the Soviet legal system.

On the hitherto rare occasions that Soviet workers have dared to go on strike - thus opening themselves up to the catch-all charge of "anti-Soviet agitation"

- they have not received any support from their "unions" , even when, as in Novocherkassk in 1962, their strike had been crushed by troops.

Attempts by workers in the Soviet Union to set up genuine trade unions, free of state control, have swiftly been stomped upon by the bureaucracy, with the blessing, of course, of the official "trade unions"

In 1977 the Ukrainian miners Klebanov and Nikitin launched the Association of Free Trade Unions.

Within a year the Association had effectively been destroyed, crushed by harassment, arrests and detention of its founders in psychiatric hospitals.

The following year the Free Interprofessional Association of Workers was launched in Moscow.

Despite the majority of its founder members being jailed, sent to mental hospitals, or despatched into exile shortly after the launch of the Association, and despite subsequent waves of arrests, the Associaton continues to exist, albeit weakly.

Although Gorbachev has encouraged more debate and criticism within the fake state-run "unions"

and has also finally allowed Klebanov to be released, there is no prospect of him permitting a rebirth of genuine trade unionism in the Soviet Union. Free trade unionism will not be achieved in the Soviet Union as a concession from Gorbachev but as part of the struggle against the ruling bureaucracy and its sham "trade unions"

Sunday 12 February. Cardiff SO public meeting. Speaker: John O'Mahony.

Saturday 18/Sunday 19 FebruarySocialist Organiser industrial weekend school. Manchester Poly Student Union, Oxford Rd. Contact Tom, 01-639 7965.

Monday 20 February. London SO education series. 'The formation of the Labour Party'. Speaker: Cathy Nugent. Conway Hall, Red Lion Sq. WC1. 7pm.

Saturday 25 February. Women for Socialism conference. Wesley House, 4 Wild Court, London WC2. Contact Ruth Clarke, 7 Cumberland Park, London W3 6SY (01-992 0945).

Saturday 8/Sunday 9 April. 'Gorbachev and the European Left' conference. ULU, Malet St, London WC1. Contact: Gus Fagan, 30 Bridge St, Oxford OX2 OBA.

Saturday 29 April. CLPs conference on Party Democracy.

Saturday 20 May. Socialist Conference Local Government Conrerence. Shawfield School, Rochdale. Contact: Tony Trehy, 7 East View, Mitchell St, Rochdale. Saturday 17 June. Socialist Conference. Octagon Centre, Sheffield

Scan page 10

al life in the townsl The average American viewer Tar men ly reaches for his Her her channel-changer on average once every three minutes.

Although we haven't reached this quick-change style of TV viewing in Britain yet, we are getting there, according to Channel 4's chief, Michael Grade (interviewed on "3 Minute Culture', BBC2, Sunday) One of the reasons for it in the USA is the vast choice of programmes on offer. And one of the results is, according to Grade, the creation of an audience which does not have to think any more but can switch to the easiest, least challenging item to watch.

The logic of his argument appears to be against the opening up of new channels and the widening of choice. But surely he is missing the point.

During the interview we were treated to a view of Grade presiding over a scheduling meeting when an important decision is being made: whether Mork and Mindy (that thought-provoking programme with an in-depth analysis of the ills of our society) should clash with Belinda Weaver reviews 'Mapantsula' The posters for the film 'Mapantsula' claim 'Banned in South Africa!' It's not hard to see why. This excellent film shows how impossible it is for black people to try to live normal, apolitical lives in South Africa's townships. Their daily lives inevitably bring them up against the racist apartheid state. Neutrality is impossible.

'Mapantsula' tells the story of a petty criminal, nicknamed Panic, who lives in Soweto and who scrapes a poor living by robbing whites and housebreaking. When he's broke, he sponges off his mother or his girlfriend, Pat, who has a job as maid to a prosperous white family in Johannesburg.

Panic isn't much of a tough though. Despite his readily deployed flick knife, he's small and a bit of a weakling, given to boasting and bragging. He never lets truth get in the way of a good story.

He's not in any sense political. He likes to drink and dance and have a good time. He can't be bothered to work for the poor wages offered to black people. He feels no guilt about living off Pat and his mother, both hard working His mother complains about rent increases, but Panic can't get worried about it. He's not interested in going to meetings or fighting the police. Let other people do that; he's got other things on his mind.

For all hs weaknesses, Panic isn't loathsome. There is a touching kind of vulnerability about him. He's naive and simple. When he gets drawn into a protest and ends up in gaol, he's pitiful. He doesn't have the comradeship that sustains the other men in the cells; he's a complete outsider, With his crime record, the police can really put the screws on, trying to force him to inform on the the other men in the cells. Though he's always been out to save his skin before, Panic begins to realise he can't do that now. Times have changed; he can't stay out of the struggle any more.

The characters in the film aren't simple ones. Panic himself is a selfish, petty crook who turns out to be capable of heroism, and it's believable.

Duma, a trade union activist he meets, is a real hero, who runs considerable risks defending workers' rights, yet he's the kind of Sir Galahad who uses his good deeds as a come on to women.

Pat, who's long been downtrodden by Panic and her employers alike, begins to feel angry and to want to fight back.

This film doesn't present its main characters as saints. Too often anti-apartheid films present their black characters as fleshless martyrs in a. hope to gain our sympathies. Such an approach is wrong. Black South Africans deserve justice because they are human and no human being should have to endure that kind of oppression, But 'Mapantsula' is different. The characters live; they're not just abstract figures dreamed up outraged liberalism. Because they seem real, the story has much more resonance. It has plenty to say about life in the townships.

There, even if you are prepared to lie low and not make any fuss, as Panic's mother does, it's no guarantee of protection from the state. What the film says is that black South Africans can't make peace with the apartheid regime, can't live with it, even if they try. The circumstances of everyday life force them into conflict with the regime, eyen against their will.

----- pull-quotes -----

TREFORM REF IR REVOLUTUA IN EASTERN EUROPE?

SE15 4NA, for 80p plus 13p postage.

ACTIVISTS" DIIARY

Who hooses our TV? TV

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 385

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →