Palestine and Israel's class struggle
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-01-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Edward Ellis reviews "Terrible Days: social division and political paradox in Israel' by Adam Keller (Cypres) B and the Israeli/ ooks abound on Israel Palestine conflict, But often they cover the same or similar ground. Adam Keller's 'Terrible Days', however, deals with rarely touched-on subjects.
His focus is on Israeli Jewish social structure, though he also gives a powerful portrayal of the position of Arabs in Israel. For example, he deals much more thoroughly with the question of 'Oriental' Jews than most writers do. Keller examines the early formation of Israeli society, and the role played in it by ethnic division. "Oriental' immigrants came to fill the lower places in Israeli society, housed in 'development towns' in Israel's outlying regions, working for the lowest wages.
Keller describes how this ethnic division (European Ashkenazi Jews at the top, Orientals or Sephardis at the bottom — but above the Arabs, of course!) has helped, along with the national conflict, to Launch Meeting The Struggle for Palestinian-Israel peace Speakers: Adam Keller, Representative from the PLO, Clare Short MP, Representative from the Jewish Socialist Group and other guest speakers 7.30 pm Monday 13th Feb Conway Hall, Red WC1 idam Keller arp Israeli politics. So left" nd 'right' have a peculiar gnificance. People who are progressive' on the Palestinian uestion - favour negotiations ith the PLO, or favour a 'alestinian state — might be, in iritish terms, right-wing on conomic policy.
Conversely, the most rabid actionaries on the Palestinian uestion can be populist, at tast (or demagogic) on issues uch as housing.
Racism towards Sephardi ews pervades even the mainstream left. Keller recounts ow many in the 'peace camp' end to see Sephardis as inerently or unchangeably with he right'. Keller quotes one colmnist associated with the peace camp': "I am asked to ave consideration for their (the ephardis) cultural deprivaon...I am being put in a cage ith a rampaging baboon...hrow him a banana, after all ou are brothers." (p.69) Keller is acutely aware of the roblems these attitudes pose, s unlike most writers he is conerned about the nature of the sraeli working class. He looks Iso at the structure of the sraeli labour movement. This is uite a widely researched topic, ut Keller's account of it is paricularly lucid.
He shows how socialist origins of Israel led to a peculiar dominance in society of the vastly bureaucratic Histadrut. He describes "the paradoxes created by the Histadrut's position as Israel's largest employer and, simultaneously, its only trade union federation.
*The perpetuation of this anomaly can be attributed to the Histadrut's continuing ability to fragment, coopt or break all challenges to its authority; to the Histadrut's sheer organisational power, and...to the lack of any coherent alternative." (p.25)
Also interesting ORS analysis of the kibbutzim. He shows how here, also, the socialist Zionist dream is exploitative in practice, relying upon Arab labour. Unlike many critics of the kibbutzim, however, Keller notes how many of their members participate in progressive movements in Israel.
The book's indictment of Israel's treatment of the Arabs covers perhaps more familiar ground. But it is a particularly accessible account, full of detail. He deals especially with the notorious Koenig memorandum of 1976 which recommended action against the overly Arab demographic character of the Galilee, which threatened the Jewishness of the state.
Keller's final chapter deals with the various organisations and struggles of the peace movement, touching on a wider range of different issues.
"Terrible Days' is an extremely useful and readable addition to the literature on Israel from an Israeli radical perspective, reflecting the concerns and strategies of the Israeli radical left. It holds firmly to a 'two states' view, advocating a separate Palestinian state and a dialogue with Palestinian nationalists.
Scan page 7
POLA
----- pull-quotes -----
Lion Square, Holborn London