Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Charter 88 - right issue, wrong approach

Socialist Organiser no. 385, 19 January 1989 · scan p. 5 · Martin Thomas · about 517 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

The second list of T signatories to "Charter 88" will be published on 22 January. Ore Cemocratia call titional more democratic settlement' in Britain. The name is intended to associate it with Charter T7 in Czechoslovakia, and with the People's Charter proclaimed by the British working class in 1838; but Charter 88's signatories, when it first appeared on 29 November last year, were drawn more from the Establishment than from the people.

It was a broad range of the establishment, though: from leaders of the Democrats Roy Jenkins, Richard Holme, Des Wilson, Richard Wainwright), through a wide range of showbiz people, writers, and academics, to figures of the literary Marxist lett (Perry Anderson, Robin Blackburn, Darcus Howe, Ralph Miliband, Sheila Rowbotham, A. Sivanandan) and two right wing trade union leaders (Gavin Laird of the AEU and John Ellis of the The call for a campaign to defend, extend and safeguard civil liberties is timely. But Charter 88 is the wrong platform for such a campaign, with the wrong people and the wrong methods.!

The labour movement should launch a campaign for civil liberties; should have launched one long ago. The Tories' assault of civil liberties — from their trade union laws, through their strengthening of the police, to the poll tax, Clause 28, and ratecapping — is a policy of class struggle, and must be fought through class struggle.

As Bob Fine puts it in the new issue of Workers' Liberty, "The substance of authoritarianism is an attack on the social foundations of the labour movement; the trade unions, local government in the large cities, and the capacity of workers to use their vast numbers to control the streets". The substance of a fight back must correspondingly be a mobilisation of those social foundations of the labour movement.

Nothing can be hand with the bigwigs of Liberalism. During the miners' strike, the Liberal-SDP Alliance criticised the Tories for not repressing the miners enough, for not using the law against them sufficiently! David Owen set the pace, but the future 'Social and Liberal Democrats' did not dissent.

No wonder, then, that Charter 88 says nothing about workers' rights to organise, to strike and to picket. Its version of a fight for civil liberties is one divorced and abstracted from the class struggle. Hugo Young summed it up quite aptly in the Guardian: "The Charter 88 movement, founded to push for the Democrats' version of constitutional reform, is the stronger for having gathered significant backing among Labour activists"

It is very much "the Democrats' version" . It omits mention not only of trade union rights, but also of the "shoot to kill" policy in Ireland the increasing aggressiveness of the police, the poll tax, and much else. On most issues it does cover, Charter 88 is vague. It calls for "reform (of the upper house to establish a democratic, non-hereditary second chamber" for example - but why not abolition of the House of Lords, and what do they mean by "democratic"?

On one point, and one point only, Charter 88 is suddenly precise: "Create a fair electoral Will

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 385

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →