The Tories' assault on freedom
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-01-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
While it spouts about freedom, the Tory Government has greatly expanded stat power at the expense of civil liberties. Liz Millward surveys the trends, especially as they affect students. Liz Millward is member of the National Union of Students Executive, writing in a personal capacity.
Are we sliding slowly Wing an authoritarian state? Are we close to il already? Is the Labour Party exaggerating when it accuses the Thatcher government of having organised 'the greatest erosion of civil liberties in living memory'? These are some of the most important questions in politics today.
Anyone who's been around in the student movement for very long will agree that civil liberties have indeed been 'massively eroded'. The mounted police charge into the demonstration on Westminster Bridge was the culmination of a longer process of restricting student's rights of 'free assembly?.
All over the country the police are being less and less co-operative in allowing any sort of student protest. They are more and more willing to wade into demonstrations violently and abusively.
Arrests are made at random, and once arrested people are bullied and beaten. Charges are out of all proportion to 'offences' - one Sheffield student is charged with incitement to riot' for taking part in a peaceful demonstration.
Turner/Insight Another, Emma Colyer, who has photographs showing her being dragged along the ground by several police officers, is charged with 'obstruction'. The situation has not always been like this. Police violence towards students has noticeably increased in recent years.
This change is not arbitrary. The police have never been the friends of the working class, or the black community or demonstrating students — only now it is worse. The changes are in direct relation to what the police think they can get away with.
The Tories have made previously legal forms of protest illegal. Picketing is the clearest example. The right to demonstrate has been made subject to delays and police approval under the Public Order Act. Thus all protestors can be treated as criminals and trouble makers and so when a police bully boy lays into pickets or students they are only getting what they deserve. That the climate and that is the psychology;
In Ine guise of expanding "freedom' the Tories are more and more silencing opposition to themselves and the business interests they serve, In the name of democracy they restrict the right of democratic organisations (like trade unions and student unions) to take action in defence of their interests.
Before Christmas Newcastle Poly student union was served with an injunction preventing the executive organising any form of direct action. This is despite the fact that the executive could and would do nothing without a democratic mandate from their members!
So it is democracy, not violence, which is being curtailed.
In his ruling, the judge referred to the violence during the miners" and printers' strikes and on Westminster Bridge. In all those cases the violence came from the police and was directed at the protesters or pickets. In all those cases the action had been democratically decided upon.
What the Tories are restricting is the vital freedom of people to organise to change government policy or to defend themselves or their interests. Much of what this goverment does is preemptive action to stop people resisting or reversing the •Thatcher Revolution', For example, collective action, especially labour movement action, is one of the Tories' main targets. They want to stamp it out because they can see, quite rightly, that the labour movement could, if it were mobilised and led properly, defeat them. The labour movement is thus target number one.
But the Tories do not just wage physical war on organised labour, using police violence backed up by the courts and the jails. They also wage an ideological battle against any and all political opposition.
Under the banner of 'freedom' freedom of the press is restricted, allowing the Tories and their press. barons to mould public opinion. They create bogey threats from which they protect us with ever more draconian laws.
They sell the vicious class legislation for the Poll Tax as a measure to "give us more say in how local government spends money". Other paper tigers they have protected us from include forced lesbian and gay indoctrination; the council as a landlord; local authority schools; and the ever present issues of violence, crime, terrorism and breaches of 'national security'. In most cases the Tories have either created, or exacerbated the original "problem'.
Tory spokesmen argue that people should have the freedom to "stand on their own feet'. In other words people should be free to direct their own lives, free from overbearing state interference.
That's fine, that's what socialism's all about. But that is precisely what the Tories are moving away from!
When the Tories 'free" Polytechnics and colleges from Local Education Authority 'control' they are freeing local people from the right to have a say on what goes on in them. That usually means fewer part-time courses, abolition of equal opportunities policies, privatisation, merger, course closure - that is less and less freedom of choice for students and local people. The Tories have also freed most colleges from the burden of enough money on which to run properly!
Freedom for the individual must involve real choices. Under this system and especially under this government many working class young people have no choices, and so no freedom.
They have no choice about the cheap-labour Youth Training Scheme, or about leaving home and getting their own place to live. And their rights to organise to improve their conditions are SO restricted that they have little freedom there either.
And as the education system becomes more Americanised, choices will be further curtailed. The chance of an education will become more dependent on parental income and on the amount a 'free' individual can raise from the Police officer in arrest of Emma Colyer. Photo: Neil Turner/Insigh bank.
The same technically free individual has little (and will have even less freedom to information, or freedom of confidentiality.
Already a system of identity cards is proposed for students in Scotland as part of the implementation of the poll tax. Football supporters too face identity cards. On their past record, if the Tories introduce identity cards for these two groups, it will not be long before everyone is carrying them.
Universal identity cards in Britain seem almost impossible now, but then 5 years ago so did the idea of keeping someone in a police cell for a week without charging them, or allowing them to contact the outside world Five years ago no one would have imagined that the 'right to silence' without prejudice would simply be removed by the Tories., The British legal system for all its faults and with all its class bias and prejudice is founded on some fine principles which, it universally and consistently applied, should ensure Justice and fairness.
It is those very principles which are being attacked by a government which supposedly believes in freedom and equality of the individual.
In recent months two European countries have refused to extradite people to Britain on the grounds that they would not get a fair trial.
What makes all this worse is that the Tories are acting for political ends. Their ideological onslaught, for which they use the institutions of the state, has a political purpose, that of maintaining themselves in power by manipulation of information. So far they have succeeded terribly, aided by the feebleness and gutlessness of the Kinnock-Hattersley leadership of the Labour Party.
Thatcher and Co are essentially following in the footsteps of disgraced and ousted former US President Nixon, the man behind the "Watergate" scandal of the mid-70s. The only difference is that they have already changed the law so that they can't be indicted for what they do!
The real tragedy is that all this doesn't have to happen. The organised labour movement has the power to stop the Tories taking away its hard earned democratic NUS Steward Emma Colyer is dra November 24 NUS demo. Photo: rights.
true that if the Tories had made all their attacks in 1l their attacks in 1979 or 1980 the labour movement abour movement would have fought back and won. t back and won. But the Tories have taken our rights e taken our rights away bit by bit, growing more con- owing more confident with each step. tep.
step the Tories have made, Labour and the TUC ur and the TUC have retreated. Where the rank and nere the rank and file have tried to fight, the bureaucrats have stifled, stifled, strangled and denounced them. hem. They have scurried before the Tories : Tories.
All the regard postal balloting as less democratic than voting based on hearing both sides earing both sides of an argument at a mass meeting t a mass meeting
Scan page 7
LABOUR 7