1988: year of the lost opportunity
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-01-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
Neekend school for tr. ing the unions, building labour Party School, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA T NHS offered a great he battles of 1988 in the chance to take on and topple the Tories. They also presented the best hope in years of building a rank and file movement in the health service.
With the outcome of the Tories? "review" of the NHS still to be announced, there will be more struggles in health in the near future. What lessons can be learned? Back in February and March last year, what was the shape of things? How did the left respond?
In January, through limited industrial action, nurses and blood transfusion workers won small victories. Confidence was boosted. The Tories insistence that there was no money for the NHS fuelled anger too.
Thousands of nurses struck (many for the first time) and took to the streets. There were days of action across cities and regions. -Other groups of workers, in the car industry, local govcrament, the mines, buses, engincering. the post office, civil service and more supported these actions - often with -(illegal) solilanty strikes.
A moromant began to swell by the week, itching to square up to the Tories. An opinion poll showed most Tory voters backing the protest. The bosses' government began to fret. The TUC responded with a demonstration in London. CoHSE and NUPE each announced a day of action - CoHSE for 14 March, NUPE for the 15th. This divisive stunt was backed up locally.
NUM wash to stole in here he health union officials toured the coalfield to tell miners their support was not wanted. The TUC health services committee promised a "campaign" — individual lobbying of MPs, winning media coverage and so on. "2p for Health' pleaded CoHSE. Have a Heart, Prime Minister' blubbered the GMB.
But there was another factor here. In major areas, rank and file health workers were organised. Many hospital Joint Shop Stewards Committees had been revived and in some places city-wide stewards" committees and action committees had sprung up.
The levels of militancy and of organisation varied. Some, in London and Mao-hest, were at times able to organise local action without the officials. In many others, the confidence to fight without a lead was lacking. Yet the building and drawing together of rank and file structures was necessary and possible.
It was clear that the sporadic action could not go on forever. Even without the barea rats' sabotage. demoralisation and exhaustion would sooner or later set in. Equally clear was the need to make the leaders fight — organise united, national action, naming a day for indefinite strike with emergency cover throughout the NHS. A national network of the rank and file committees could "combine demands for action on thr TUC and national officials with consistent and serious organising of the base. " (SO 350).
Socialist Organiser supported the calling of a national conference on this basis, "not magically to create an alternative leadership to that of the official health unions. Rather, a national shop stewards' conference would be a step along the road of building a national network of health shop stewards..able to exert real pressure on the union officials. It would also be able to form a realistic picture of what kind of action could be called without official backing." (SO 350).
What did the rest of the organised left have to offer the workers? The Mintant tendency hailed a *new generation of union activists straining at the leash to take action" as "millions of trade anionists have been just waiting for the call to take action alongside the health workers." (Militant 883). This gung-ho optimism went hand-in-hand with rank scetarianism.
Militant supporters who were health workers played little or no role in building the stewards committees, instead using their front organisation, the Broad Left Organising Comatitue, to try to capture the movement. When . a stewards' conference was held on 26 March, Militant supporters proposed that a national machine be created, paralleling the official unions and complete with bureaucratic constitution and structures — no doubt with Militant in charge.
The ultra-leftists of Workers Power and the Revolutionary Communist Party differed a bit. Workers Power insisted on a national strike committee. This did not take account of the widely varied levels of militancy. It was also an alternative to making the leaders fight, based on the mistaken idea that the leaders always, inevitably, sell out. The RCP wanted a campaign solely for health workers' pay and conditions, since the NHS was a product of the capitalist system and therefore not worth defending. Revolution or bust — but only around the issue of NHS workers' pay and conditions'!
What each of these sects (wrongly) thought they were doing was trying to develop and advance the movement that had sprung up. If that movement were a river, they were trying all kinds of engineering feats to divert it, steer it uphill, dam it up, squeeze it into pipes and so on. But one sect, the Socialist Workers Party, curiously mirrored the bureaucrats, were reluctantly carried along by the current, bobbing up and down.
They knew that the "down-turn" and "New Realism" had just about triumphed in the health unions, as elsewhere. They saw the attempt to build national rank and file organistion as pie-in-the-sky antics. They argued that the rank and file could not organise action independent of the officials.
Yet they said the rank and file should hold out against "tail-ending the bureaucrats" - for instance against CoHE's day of action on 14 March. They said health workers had been deeply infected by "New Realism" save for a "militant minority" Yet the business of a national stewards" conference must wait until the spontaneous struggles reached a sufficiently high level! The SWP were at sea, much as they had been during the 1984/85 miners' strike.
It is true that in many hospitals basic union organisation needed to be built. But the SWP canterprosed that low-level work to a wider strategy and to a national stewards network. The point is that a national stewards' network could help reach out to those less organised, less militant hospitals. If it could press the barcaucrats to call national strikes, those could surely given confidence to the less organised, less militant places.
Socialist Worker partly acknowlcdged that the "thin layer of militants on the ground can have a powerful effect in building organisation...However this can only be done if militants take ac-