Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A tale of free enterprise

Socialist Organiser no. 383, 5 January 1989 · scan p. 10 · about 739 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

reviews "Tucker: the man and his dream' The story of misundergenius is an old favourite in Hollywood. The plot has whiskers on it by now. What's surprising is that Francis Coppola has suddenly discovered it, and given it the full treatment in *Tucker: the man and his dream?.

After 'Greystoke: the legend of Tarzan, Lord of the Apes', I turned against films with colons in the titles. Seeing "Tucker' has convinced me I was right.

It's a nauseating, nostalgic recreation of the life of the 'visionary' car manufacturer, Preston Tucker, who was drummed out of business in the late 1940s. According to the film, Tucker wanted to design safer, better cars, but was beaten because powerful lobbying from the Big Three (Ford, GM and Chrysler) forced the government to withdraw his backing.

Tucker's innovations including placing the engine in the back, padscreens, an aerodynamic shape, disc brakes and improved headlights. Many of these are now standard in Big Three cars, after considerable consumer pressure (and years of automobile deaths). In one scene, a bureaucrat opposes the use of seat belts in the Tucker cars, because he believes the public will then view the cars as unsafe. This scene is in the movie just to show the bureaucrats are uncaring and inhuman, the very opposite of good ole Tucker:

film has kind of black/white morality that characterised early westerns. Tucker should be wearing a white hat; he's the Jimmy Stewart character. Everything Tucker does is supposed to be good, which is a shame. He's SO abrasive and unlikeable (despite his I'm loveable' grin), that he gives good a bad name.

Geniuses generally get a bad script in Hollywood, and "Tucker' is no exception. Most geniuses are shown as behaving badly, with only their genius for an excuse (see "Amadeus' and other big bie bictures). Tucker's form behaviour (apart from the ever-present boyish grin) is to live constantly beyond his means, to give way to insane and misplaced op timism, to get other people to do all the work, and to turn constantly deaf ears to anyone trying to tell him anything that might puncture his daydreams.

This is the kind of picture where people pick up phones so that they can talk to anyone at all but the person on the other end. This is meant to convey bustle and excitement; it's simply irritating, like all those meals you never see eaten on TV shows.

To spite Tucker, the Washington bureaucrats dream up a fraud case that will finish Tucker commercially. They aim to prove he never intended to build cars, but to raise the money for his, own use. In an expansive gesture, Tucker shows up with the fifty cars he has produced, the fruits of his $26 million investment. And his is acquitted!

Belief became unhinged here. Even in the post-war boom, $500.000 for a car seems pretty steen. innovations notwithstanding! But his little boy grin wins the jurv over. He's out of business, but he can still walk tall. Yuk!

The film is really very In his speech to the jury, Tucker defends the free enterprise system passionately, but then complains that bureaucrats have tied it up so much it isn't free any more. Like all good geniuses, he whines that he was born out of his epoch. Basically, he wished he'd been Henry Ford.

But these free enterprise advocates never get past the first paragraph of what the system is all about. They hear 'free' and assume that they can do whatever they want. What they completely ignore is the trend in 'free' enterprise "Tucker' has less romance than a Coca-Cola commercial. It hasn't got a single character in it; everyone has become a cartoon. Tucker himself, his senselessly adoring family, his loyal team (whom he thoroughly exploits) and the Washington bad guys are all utter cardboard. And the glossy presentation just underlines the falsity.

Ironically, Coppola rolls the closing credits over photographs of the real Tucker's life, and it's a riot. The real Tucker is older and slightly chinny, Mrs T is comfortably plump, the Tuckerettes showing off the car are plainer and fatter, and no one has Hollywood-new clothes. Coppola can't resist piling money onto his films until they simply sink under the weight. The closing photographs show the real Tucker with a mad sparkle in his eye. There's more story in that one photograph than in the rest of the picture altogether.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 383

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →