Joking Nazism
Socialist Organiser1989 1989-01-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Capitalism long ago turned the old religiou festival of the birt of Jesus Christ into our commercial Xmas. Even our image of a white-bearded Santa Claus clad in red robes, etc. was created by Coca Cola's advertising agents a mere three quarters of a century ago.
Now television increasingly turns the commercial Xmas into our annual festival of old movies.
Something like a hundred old movies went out over the four channels this Xmas, filling a big proportion of transmission time. Some were truly awful, and a few so good that they gleamed hard and bright like gem stones set in papier mache and tinsel, providing a standard against which to measure TV's normal fare as well as its Xmas offerings.
It so happened that I watched the long-running and very popular "Allo, 'Allo' for the first time just before Xmas. This is a sort of 'Carry on Gestapo', about a comic French Resistance group centred around a cafe/brothel forever outsmarting the political police of the occupying German Army. The Nazis strut, but comically; they are oppressors, but ineffectual with it: altogether they are just too stupid to be taken seriously.
• laughed here and there, but I found the mixture deeply disgusting and offensive.
How can people with even a dim idea of what the Nazis did in the lands they ruled - including Germany bear to watch such miserably insensitive rubbish? Or is that the point - that today there are so many people who don't have even a dim idea of what the Nazis were or of that they really did? The sort of people who buy and wear T-shirts jokingly itemising 'Adolf Hitler's European Tour 1940-45' in the sartorial junkshops of Oxford Street?
On New Year's Day — after midnight unfortunately - Channel 4 showed Fritz Lang's 1943 piece of wartime Hollywood anti-Nazi propaganda 'Hangmen Also Die' Partly scripted by Bertold Brecht, the well-known Stalinist playwright, this is a fierce diatribe, in the form of a fictionalised account of the assassination in 1942 of Heydrich, the Nazi overlord of Occupied Czechoslovakia, and the Nazi terror that followed. It was crude and very powerful, but, essentially, just and true.
I don't know what it says about the world we live in, that a piece of propaganda produced on behalf of one of the contending imperial blocks during World War II should be more truthful than an 'entertainment' produced in Britain during capitalism's present patchy Indian Summer. Maybe: in war, we get the truth - about the enemy. Part of the truth, sometimes.
A few years or a decade from now we may have a TV series, "Carry On, Joe' Or 'Hello, Hello Comrade Beria'! Come to think of it - we've been there once before.
The same Hollywood system that produced 'Hangmen also die' churned out whitewash jobs on Stalin's regime at the same time, as a service to the US bosses' wartime ally. Hollywood even produced a movie justifying and glorifying Stalin's Moscow Trials of the thirties, the publicly visible part of the great purges during which the remnants of Lenin's Bolshevik Party were murdered for the crime of